Inset: Dylan Lamb (Monroe County Sheriff’s Office). Background: Amoray Dive Resort in Key Largo, Florida (WPLG/YouTube).
During a meeting with his parole officer, a Florida man left out a key detail about his recent activities: that he allegedly committed a murder.
Dylan Lamb, 33, is facing charges of murder in connection with the death of Nadyne Marie Tillman, 43, at a resort hotel in the Florida Keys. The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office responded to a missing persons report at the Amoray Dive Resort in Key Largo at about 11 a.m. on Monday. Deputies discovered Tillman’s body in a hotel room, concealed in a closet beneath a water heater. She had been fatally beaten.
More from Law&Crime: ‘Riding his a—’: Florida man pleads guilty to shooting, killing father and injuring mother after dad told him to stop playing video games and get a job
According to details from a probable cause arrest affidavit accessed by Law&Crime, Lamb had allegedly arranged for a sexual encounter with Tillman through a website. Investigators later communicated with one of Tillman’s acquaintances who had exchanged messages with her before she went to the hotel on Saturday morning. The acquaintance disclosed that Tillman had agreed to meet a man at the resort for a “date.” She messaged her friend upon arrival at the door, but received no response initially. After a short while, the man, identified as Lamb, finally opened the door.
“I’m in,” Tillman told her friend.
It was the last time anyone heard from her.
A resort employee told cops Lamb rented the hotel room using Expedia and provided his mother’s phone number. He checked into the room on Friday night, but hotel employees tried to move him to another room the next day. Lamb spoke to the employees through the door and declined. He was allowed to stay in the room until Sunday morning.
The housekeeper found three large trash bags inside the room after Lamb left, the affidavit said.
“The bags were filled with soiled towels and bed linens, and were described as heavily stained with substances consistent with blood, urine, and feces,” cops wrote.
Instead of alerting law enforcement, staff threw the bags into a dumpster that has since been disposed of and is unable to be recovered, detectives wrote. The Miami Herald, citing unnamed sources, reported an unwitting guest stayed the night in that room with the corpse on Sunday into Monday.
Tillman’s family members became concerned about her well-being after she failed to respond to messages and reported her missing. Her daughter tracked her car to the resort on Monday morning and alerted law enforcement, which is what led to the discovery of her body.
Investigators identified Lamb as the person who had rented the room. Lamb was on probation from a previous grand theft of a motor vehicle conviction. Cops contacted his parole officer on Tuesday, who told them he had met with Lamb in person the day before. Detectives went to his job where he worked as a kayak instructor and took him into custody without incident.
Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.
Post-Miranda, Lamb told cops he paid Tillman $200 for sex but claimed she tried to leave without providing the services, according to the affidavit. He allegedly said he blocked the door to prevent her from leaving and she started hitting him. Lamb insisted he only hit her once in the face. She fell, hit her head and lost consciousness, he claimed. Lamb went to the bathroom to calm himself down and when he returned, he saw she wasn’t breathing, the affidavit stated.
He told cops he “freaked out” and instead of calling 911 tried to clean up the mess using towels and linen before putting her body inside the water heater closet. He threw away the towels, linen and victim’s cellphone in the trash bags, the affidavit said. Tillman’s injuries were not consistent with just one hit to the face, cops said, because she had two black eyes, busted lips and other facial trauma.
