The happy A-list couple were acting like two giddy teenagers behind the bleachers when one lucky New Yorker spotted the pair on a romantic park date.
Palley Chizmar, a resident of Tribeca, shared her excitement about unexpectedly encountering Kylie Jenner and Timothée Chalamet during an exclusive interview with the Daily Mail.
Recalling the moment, Chizmar described how she initially thought the famous duo resembled “cute little high school lovers” from afar. She admitted to being a hopeless romantic and found herself captivated by their interaction. Observing Jenner’s face turned towards Chalamet, Chizmar mistook them for young high school students kissing on a bench.
Chizmar continued: ‘Then, I saw his face, from the side, and I’m a huge fan of his, so I recognized him immediately!’Â
At this point, she said the path she was walking down was so narrow if she ‘had reached out’ her arm she could have ‘touched’ Jenner’s leg.Â
‘I was so close to them,’Â Chizmar marveled, before noting that the duo were in no rush to leave.

The incident of Kylie Jenner and Timothée Chalamet being mistaken for teenage sweethearts by a fortunate New Yorker who spotted them enjoying a romantic park date was quite amusing.
Despite describing them as ‘definitely acting like teenagers’ during their laid-back outing, Chizmar clarified that their PDA was not ‘gross in any way.’Â
Chizmar explained that ‘they were holding hands in a cute way’ and Jenner had her ‘head on his shoulder.’Â
‘Her legs were sorta turned over on his. So they just looked like they were really in love,’ she gushed.Â
As for whether Jenner seemed really comfortable around Chalamet, Chizmar confirmed she did.Â
‘I could tell she was kind of hiding her face from me in his neck,’ she said. ‘He was the one that was kind of more nonchalant about the fact that somebody was walking past and, maybe, recognized them.’Â
While sitting on the bench, Chizmar said ‘they were totally cuddled up to each other’ and he was enjoying a juice shot.Â
‘[Kylie] did look very smiley and smitten. Whatever they were saying was very hush hush. I didn’t even hear their voices as I passed, but that’s probably because they didn’t want me to recognize them,’ she added.Â
Apart from one runner, who didn’t even take a photo of the lovebirds, Chizmar believes she ‘was the only person’ to recognize them at the pier, full of mostly men working in finance. Â

On Wednesday, Tribeca resident, Palley Chizmar, excitedly detailed her chance encounter with the happy couple during an exclusive interview with DailyMail.com

Despite describing them as ‘definitely acting like teenagers’ during their laid-back outing, Chizmar clarified that their PDA was not ‘gross in any way’Â
Jenner and Chalamet seemed to have asked their security for some privacy as Chizmar said they appeared to be alone.
‘I didn’t see anyone with them. [Their body guards] could have easily had someone hiding, but nobody was, like, apparent,’ she noted.
Jenner and Chalamet’s latest sighting comes just a week after they made their red carpet debut as a couple at the 70th David Di Donatello Awards red carpet in Rome.
Earlier this week, they were joined by Kylie’s sister, Kendall Jenner, at a New York Knicks game, where they all sat courtside.Â

While sitting on the bench, Chizmar said ‘they were totally cuddled up to each other’ and he was enjoying a juice shotÂ

Jenner and Chalamet appeared to ask their security for some privacy as Chizmar said they appeared to be alone
Things between the pair indicate that their relationship is more serious than ever. Â
This month a source also told Us Weekly that the stars were ‘practically living together.’
‘Kylie’s really happy and relieved they finally made their debut,’ a source close to the couple told the outlet.Â
They continued: ‘It was time and she wanted to publicly support him and show how proud of him she is. She and Timothée have gotten really serious, and this was a big step.’

Jenner and Chalamet’s latest sighting comes just a week after they made their red carpet debut as a couple at the 70th David Di Donatello Awards red carpet in Rome (seen on May 7)
The insider also divulged: ‘They are practically living together at this point, as he stays at her house often when he is not working. He has been fully integrated into her life.’
The reality star and two-time Oscar nominee were first romantically linked in April 2023.Â
The couple went on to first publicly debut their relationship at a Beyoncé concert in September 2023.Â
She has been his date to several awards shows, including the Golden Globes and Academy Awards.