President Trump and FEMA: Is a Commission the Answer to an Agency Ripe for Overhaul?

The president’s remarks were quickly followed by the introduction of a high-level commission. The purpose of this commission is to evaluate FEMA’s recent performance and propose essential changes to improve the agency’s operations.

This development is considered positive because the existing FEMA model is ineffective and is in need of significant reform. However, the decision to establish a commission may come as a surprise, given the numerous executive orders issued by Trump the previous week, which addressed a wide range of critical issues.

The president has demonstrated a keen judgment on various topics and has the ability to use his platform to communicate his policy stances effectively. Therefore, it is somewhat unexpected to see him entrust FEMA’s issues to a commission that has been allotted up to a year to compile and present its conclusions.

The president had other options here. On an individual basis, he has broad authority to grant or deny requests for federal disaster assistance. While there are suggested, written parameters for providing federal disaster relief, it is the president’s sole decision to grant or deny relief, to determine what kinds of relief are available, and to identify which counties and other entities are eligible. In other words, Trump already has full authority to mold FEMA relief.

The president could also have taken the executive order route by laying out prospective requirements that states would have to comply with in order to receive FEMA assistance. He could, for instance, require a state to execute an underbrush removal plan to prevent wildfires or to certify that local governments have adequate firefighting capacity. There are many ways to bend policy by executive orders.



But, the president has here announced the appointment of a high-level commission to look at all of FEMA, with the ultimate goal of a major overhauling of its mission. This is an optimistic goal because the history of meaningful change arising from presidential commissions is spotty. Presidents form commissions for a variety of reasons: to provide external fact-finding expertise on difficult issues; to confirm, in a seemingly objective manner, the president’s views on an issue; or, in many cases, to convince the public that the president cares about an issue that he’d rather kick down the road. Some cynics claim that presidential commissions are where good ideas go to die. 

Historically, the commissions that have fared best are (1) those that continue to occupy the public’s interest during the course of their fact-finding and deliberations and (2) those that conclude those activities in a relatively short period of time. Franklin Roosevelt’s Roberts Commission analyzed the causes of the attack on Pearl Harbor, interviewed more than 100 witnesses, and released its findings in a scant two months. Similarly, the Rogers Commission undertook a very public review of the shuttle Challenger explosion and came to specific conclusions that fundamentally changed the way NASA functioned.

FEMA doesn’t have this sort of continual visibility. FEMA is primarily noticed when bad things happen during disasters. Sometimes, this is unfair finger-pointing and scapegoating because of the perception that FEMA isn’t doing enough; sometimes, it is self-inflicted, as when FEMA supervisors tell their staff not to help people with Trump signs in their yards. 

But, other than specific events, most people don’t think at all about FEMA most of the time. So, in that context, will Trump’s FEMA commission have enough dynamism, enough oomph, to create findings and meaningful suggestions that Congress will actually act on a year from now? Will the desire to reform FEMA in fundamental ways, a concept that now has some real momentum, sustain itself for a year?  That is the ultimate task and goal, and time will tell, but these are important goals that deserve a full airing. 


Christopher E. Hagerup is a Senior Advisor to the National Sheriffs Association, a former Trump appointee, and the former Director of Intergovernmental Affairs at FEMA under President George W. Bush.

You May Also Like
JK Rowling posts essay about 'signatories motivated by fear' after Harry Potter stars she created turn on her by signing pro-trans open letter

“JK Rowling Shares Response to ‘Signatories Driven by Fear’ as Harry Potter Stars Sign Pro-Trans Open Letter”

We, the film and television professionals who have signed this statement, express…
New Nostradamus who foresaw COVID-19 makes shocking prediction about Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce's future

Shocking Prediction about Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce’s Future Made by Modern-Day Nostradamus

A psychic who successfully foresaw dozens of global events in 2024 has…
British police arrest several Iranian men over alleged plot to attack target in London

Iranian Men Arrested in London Over Alleged Attack Conspiracy

British authorities detained a group of Iranian individuals suspected of plotting an…
Biden press secretary Jen Psaki makes outlandish claims about former president's cognitive decline

Jen Psaki, Biden’s press secretary, makes bold statements regarding ex-president’s mental acuity

The press secretary for the former President, Joe Biden, admitted that she…
Trump Talks Tough on US Tariffs and China: 'I'm Not Happy About This'

Trump expresses dissatisfaction with US tariffs and China, stating, “I am displeased with the situation.”

On Sunday morning, President Donald Trump took part in a wide-ranging interview…
Most Brits say strip Harry and Meghan of their HRH titles after bombshell interview as backlash grows - amid palace anger at BBC for failing to challenge Duke

Majority of Brits want Harry and Meghan to lose their royal titles after explosive interview causes uproar – palace upset with BBC for not questioning Duke’s actions

Prince Harry faced a growing backlash from ministers, the Royal Family and…
Elon Musk Has 1-Word Answer When Asked If He Regrets DOGE Role, Adds: 'At Least I Didn't Get Shot'

Elon Musk Shares His Regret About DOGE Involvement with Humor

The wealthiest individual in the world remained mostly uninvolved in the country’s…
Will the next pope be from Asia?

Could the future pope come from Asia?

In KAOHSIUNG, Taiwan, the College of Cardinals is about to convene inside…
Rockets vs. Warriors Live Stream: Start Time, Channel, Where To Watch Warriors-Rockets Game 7 Live

Warriors vs. Rockets Game 7: How to Watch Live Stream, Start Time, TV Channel

Two consecutive nights featuring Game 7s? It doesn’t get much more thrilling…
Trump administration makes shock decision in lawsuit over Jan 6 rioter Ashli Babbitt who was shot and killed by Capitol Police

Surprising move by Trump administration in lawsuit involving Capitol Police shooting of rioter Ashli Babbitt on Jan 6

The Trump administration has agreed to settle a lawsuit with the family…
Divorce attorney brutally murdered Cleveland nurse in elaborate plot to avoid taking her case to court

Cleveland nurse tragically killed by divorce lawyer in a complex scheme to avoid court battle

A divorce attorney murdered a Cleveland nurse in a plot to avoid…
Houthi missile strikes near Israeli airport after evading missile defenses

Missile fired by Houthi rebels hits close to Israeli airport despite avoiding missile defense systems

A Houthi missile struck Israeli soil near Tel Aviv’s largest airport on…