'Tradition is tradition': Ohio State fans plunge into the Maumee River after loss to Michigan

Seventeen years ago, a simple playful bet between two brother-in laws has now become a tradition featuring dozens.

TOLEDO, Ohio — It’s a tradition that goes back nearly two decades.

Several individuals in Toledo take part in Ohio State and Michigan themed polar plunges, where supporters of the losing team must jump into the frigid Maumee River.

Seventeen years ago, a simple playful bet between two brother-in laws has now become a tradition featuring dozens.

Gerald Chasteen is a loyal Michigan Fan, while his brother-in law Richard Chizmar is an Ohio State fan.

“This is very cold. This is very, very cold. It’s ridiculously cold,” said Chizmar.

“It’s essentially about uniting the city, bringing friends, family, neighborhoods, everyone together,” said Chasteen. “Look at us, we’re all coming together, guys.”


This tradition means more than just jumping in the freezing cold water.

“I believe it holds significance because it’s something that everyone does. The whole community gathers to participate. It’s a great way to bring everyone together,” mentioned Alyna Foreman, a Toledo resident.

Historically, Ohio State has been dominant and Chasteen had to jump in the water more often than not. For the last four years in a row, Michigan turned it around and won the big game, meaning it’s been Chizmar’s turn to do the honors of making the plunge.

Chizmar says last year was a lot warmer compared to this year with temperatures in the 20’s.

The water was frigid and it’s hard to stay in it for more than a few seconds. But for these two, a bet is a bet.

“Tradition is tradition, man. You got to stick with it because I expect you [Chasteen] to do it next year,” said Chizmar.”

The tradition will continue next year and Gerald said they expect it to be another Ohio State loss, just like this year. Although Richard warned, don’t be so sure.

You May Also Like

Prepare for the possibility of severe storms in Central Florida, along with a high likelihood of rain continuing throughout the weekend. Find out everything you need to know here.

ORLANDO, Fla. – If you’ve been wondering when the rain will let…

“Billboards Address Reductions of DOGE at Cuyahoga Valley National Park”

More than 70 billboards across Ohio are calling out the Elon Musk-led…

Carla Hayden, Librarian of Congress, Dismissed by President Trump

WASHINGTON – President Donald Trump unexpectedly terminated Librarian of Congress Carla Hayden…

“Tragic Loss: Investigation Launched After Eustis Woman’s Death”

In Mount Dora, Florida, this Mother’s Day weekend has been especially tough…

Dismissal of charges for 3 defendants in the Christian Glass lawsuit in return for training video

In Eagle, Colorado, it has been almost three years since Christian Glass,…

Reactions of Orlando Catholic clergy to new pope: Strengthened by his election

ORLANDO, Fla. – The election of the first American pope in history…

List of 34 upcoming Walmart stores in Florida that will showcase innovative features.

New Walmart “Stores of the Future” are in the works nationwide —…

Russia celebrates 80th anniversary of defeating Nazi Germany with Victory Day parade

In Moscow, Russia commemorated the 80th anniversary of the victory over Nazi…

City of Mount Dora advises of potential temporary water discoloration during fire hydrant testing

MOUNT DORA, Fla. – Mount Dora’s fire and water departments are conducting…

Palm Bay stops using school zone speed cameras for the rest of the school year

In Palm Bay, Florida, the city has decided to suspend its school…

How the Fentanyl Crisis is Impacting Ohio Families for the Long Term

Fentanyl is a significant contributor to the most severe drug crisis the…

Location of Arrest for 3 Fugitives Wanted in Ohio for Separate Murder Cases

One of the cases dates back to September 2024 when a body…