Married mum teacher, 43, who had sex with student, 17, accuses her husband of ‘neglect’ as she faces 10 years in prison

A MARRIED teacher who had sex with a teenage student suggested that her husband’s “neglect” prompted her sick actions.

Mum-of-three Emily Nutley, 43, pleaded guilty on Monday to two counts of sexual battery over a physical relationship with a 17-year-old student.

Screenshot of a news report about a high school teacher accused of having sex with a student.
A married mum and teacher, 43, who had sex with student, 17, accused her husband of ‘neglect’ as she faces 10 years in prisonCredit: Fox19
Mugshot of a blonde woman.
Emily Nutley was the former head counselor at the prestigious all-boys St. Xavier High SchoolCredit: Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office
Photo of a family with faces blurred.
The mum-of-three’s husband, Jonathan Nutley, filed for divorce weeks after her arrestCredit: Facebook

Several of the sexual encounters occurred at the prestigious Catholic school Nutley worked at in fall 2023.

She was fired from St. Xavier High School in Ohio last October when the victim shed light on her abuse, leading to her arrest and indictment.

Her soon-to-be ex-husband Jonathan Nutley filed for divorce weeks after her arrest.

The depraved teacher retaliated by alleging that her partner had been “guilty of gross neglect of duty and extreme cruelty” throughout their marriage, as reported by TMZ.

Prosecutors said the former head counselor pursued the minor outside of school hours.

They say she texted the youngster nude photographs of herself, as well as sexually explicit messages shortly after she was hired.

At the time she was supervising a program set up to help academically struggling pupils.

The teenage victim was attending the at-risk group she was leading when they met, officials said.

The first affair turned physical in November and the duo had a second sexual encounter a month later.

Paedo teacher Jeremy Forrest spotted with new girlfriend 15 years his junior after ditching his second wife for her

They had sex multiple times in mid-November, with at least one instance taking place in her office.

The sickening encounters took place on and off school grounds.

Prosecutors added that Nutley continued to trail the student after he tried to end the affairs.

The relationship was discovered through an internal investigation by the school.

The all-boys school then contacted Springfield Township Police, who launched their own investigation.

The vile offender will be sentenced on June 10, facing up to 10 years in prison.

She is also required to register as a sex offender for the rest of her life.

Nutley joined the school ahead of the 2021-22 year and was named the “multi-tiered systems support coordinator” in the student handbook.

She also has two daughters and a son, the eldest of whom is a junior at a different school and only slightly younger than the victim.

Family photo on a beach.
The mum faces up to 10 years in prisonCredit: Facebook
St. Xavier High School; news report about a teacher accused of sex with a student.
Several encounters between the two occurred at the Catholic St. Xavier High School in Cincinnati, OhioCredit: Fox19
You May Also Like

Investigation Underway Into Suspicious Fires at Former North London Residences of Sir Keir Starmer

The Metropolitan Police is investigating the blaze, with a spokesman for the force saying…

New hearing date scheduled for Menendez brothers as they face consequences for misbehavior in prison

ERIK and Lyle Menendez will finally get their resentencing hearing, despite a…

The spooky deserted airport where planes have sat decaying on the runway for 50 years in a popular vacation destination

Unbelievable images capture the ghostly remnants of a deserted airport in a…

Hidden US Capitol Tunnel with Spooky Staircase Discovered, Drawing Attention Despite Distractions

A SECRET tunnel has been discovered under the floorboards of the US…

Kai Trump Embraces Turning 18 with NYC Trip and Girls’ Night Out, Hailed as a Promising Figure in MAGA Movement

PRESIDENT Trump’s granddaughter Kai has marked the end of her childhood as…

Will Keir’s new migration rules be effective, from cracking down on deportation avoiders to strict English tests – but do they have good chances of success?

By HARRY COLE, Political Editor The Home Secretary dedicated the latter part of…

France Criticizes Russia for Spreading False Conspiracy about ‘Cocaine Train’ and Alleged Macron Video

FRANCE has blasted a fake Russian claim that President Emmanuel Macron had…

“Start of Diddy’s $10 Million Defense Today Sparks Jury Anxiety”

A jury has been seated in Sean “Diddy” Combs’ sex-trafficking trial. The…

Behind the Scenes at the BAFTA TV Awards: Highlights and Surprises

The 2025 BAFTA TV Awards were held on Sunday night, celebrating famous…

Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs’ Sex-Trafficking Trial Begins with Opening Statements

A jury was finalized on Monday in Sean “Diddy” Combs’ federal sex-trafficking…

Did Morena and Tony from MAFS Australia Stay Together After the Show? Let’s Find Out Their Current Relationship Status

The 2025 season of Married at First Sight Australia (MAFS) brought us…

Alert: 11-Year-Old Georgia Girl Reported Missing After Going Outside to Play

Police in Georgia are searching for Gingua Benson-O’Neal, an 11-year-old who has…