Eerie true story behind Ellen Pompeo’s new show Good American Family as orphan ‘faked her age & plotted to kill family’

THE story behind Ellen Pompeo’s new show Good American Family is even more dramatic than it seems on TV. 

In the Hulu series, Pompeo plays Kristine Barnett, a woman who adopted Natalia Grace, a 7-year-old Ukrainian orphan with dwarfism. 

Natalia Grace in an interview.
Ukrainian Natalia Grace was adopted at 7 years old by Kristine and Michael BarnettCredit: Dr Phil
Mark Duplass and Ellen Pompeo in a scene from "Good American Family."
Ellen Pompeo plays her adoptive mom Kristine in Hulu’s new show Good American FamilyCredit: AP
Natalia Grace using a laptop in her bedroom.
Natalia was born with a rare form of dwarfism and her adoptive parents accused her of pretending to be a child and plotting to kill family membersCredit: Matt Symons for The US Sun

However, Pompeo’s character begins to believe her adopted daughter is actually a fully grown woman posing as a child. 

The plot line may seem like it could only come from the depths of a writer’s imagination, but some viewers will be shocked to discover it’s all based on Natalia Grace’s true story.

While the show does take some creative liberties in Hollywood-izing Natalia’s story, it attempts to tell the mind-bending case from everyone’s point of view in an “emotionally authentic” way.

Natalia’s story started in 2010 when she was adopted by Kristine and Michael Barnett and went to live with them in Lafayette, Indiana. 

“We wanted to help somebody who was in danger of never being loved,” Michael Barnett said in the first season of the 2023 docu-series The Curious Case of Natalia Grace.

The Barnetts initially got along well with young Natalia, taking her to Disneyland and on new adventures, but everything changed once they settled back into their Indiana home.

Natalia moved in with Kristine, Michael, and their three sons – Jacob, Wesley, and Ethan. 

Michael and Kristine began to accuse Natalia of hiding her real age and having “sociopathic” tendencies. 

In the docu-series, the Barnetts alleged Natalia had admitted to having a period and had fully grown pubic hair at just 7 years old. 

Michael further claimed that Natalia threatened her adoptive siblings.

Shocking true story that inspired Lifetime’s The Bad Orphan & adoptee Natalia Grace who was accused of posing as a child

“She threatened to stab my sons, drag their bodies outside, and bury them underneath the deck,” Michael Barnett alleged in The Curious Case of Natalia Grace.

“I promise you within 5 years someone is dead.”

Natalia refuted these allegations, saying she “can’t even bend [her] fingers to grip a knife.”

Kristine also accused Natalia of poisoning her coffee with cleaning liquid, an accusation that has haunted the Barnetts’ son Jacob to this day.

“I can’t share a drink with someone,” Jacob said in the docuseries.

“It’s rooted in this fear that Natalia is coming to poison us.”

Natalia believes the Barnetts were simply trying to recreate the 2009 horror movie, Orphan, with their wild allegations.

Who is Natalia Grace?

Everything to know about Natalia Grace.

  • Born: Mykolaiv, Ukraine
  • Mother: Anna Volodymyrivna Gava
  • Date on original birth certificate: September 4, 2003
  • Date on court-adjusted birth certificate: September 4, 1989
  • Disability: Dwarfism
  • 2010: Grace was brought to the US and adopted by Michael and Kristine Barnett
  • 2012: The Barnetts successfully petition to change Grace’s age on her birth certificate
  • 2013: The Barnetts move Grace into an apartment and move away to Canada
  • 2013: Grace eventually contacts authorities and moves in with Cynthia and Antwon Man
  • 2019: Indiana authorities charge the Barnetts with child neglect and abandonment because of her disability
  • 2023: Michael is acquitted and the charges against Kristine are dropped
  • 2023: The Curious Case of Natalia Grace premieres on ID and Max
  • 2024: Natalia Speaks airs

The complicated accusations of the story proved to be a “creative challenge” for Pompeo while playing the role of Kristine.

“I was looking for a real creative challenge,” Pompeo told the Associated Press. 

“I think this was an opportunity for me to completely disappear into a role. Characters like this don’t come along all that often.”

A BIG CHANGE

The story only gets more complicated when the Barnetts officially petitioned to change Natalia’s actual birth year from 2003 to 1989. 

In 2012, Kristine and Michael offered evidence supposedly proving Natalia was actually 22 years old and had conned them into believing she was a child.

Michael claimed to have hired a private investigator who said Natalia’s birth certificate looked fake, Time reported.

The allegedly fake birth certificate, on top of Natalia’s period, led the courts to officially change the young girl’s birth year, making her a legal adult. 

In 2013, following the change, the Barnetts relocated Natalia to her own apartment in Indiana and then fled the country, moving to Canada without her.

“I really disliked being the girl who was re-aged and lived in her own apartment,” Natalia told People. 

“I didn’t understand why I was alone. I just knew I had this instinct in me to push and survive. 

“All I was told was, ‘You’re 22 now. Whenever somebody asks you what your age is, you say you’re 22 and you tried to murder your family.’

“I was taught to lie.”

Ellen Pompeo speaking at a podium.
Ellen Pompeo called playing Kristine a creative challengeCredit: AP
Natalia Grace, a young woman with a disability, sits in a beanbag chair using a laptop.
The new Hulu series shows Natalia’s story from multiple perspectivesCredit: AP

In The Curious Case of Natalia Grace, Natalia said the apartment she was living in wasn’t suited for someone with disabilities so she couldn’t reach the stove, shelves, or mailbox. 

Stranded Natalia was taken in by Cynthia Mans and her husband Antwon, who already had 10 children. 

THE TRUTH COMES OUT

A DNA test taken by Natalia proved her real birth year is around 2003 rather than 1989 like the Barnetts alleged. 

The case took another dramatic turn in 2019 when the Barnetts were charged with neglect of a dependent, neglect of a dependent causing bodily injury, and conspiracy to commit neglect of a dependent for abandoning Natalia in 2013.

At trial, Michael was found not guilty and Kristine’s charges were dropped in 2023.

In The Curious Case of Natalia Grace, the orphan confronts her adopted father, saying, “I was a kid. You were supposed to be my dad.”

Michael said he beat himself up “for not being stronger.” 

Following everything that happened with Natalia, Michael and Kristine divorced in 2014. 

Michael stood by Natalia’s side, blaming himself for not having the strength to confront his wife, Kristine.

Good American Family is available to stream on Hulu following its release on March 19.

You May Also Like

Staff Member of Senator Cory Booker Arrested at Capitol for Gun Charge Shortly Before Senator Began Lengthy Speech

One of Senator Cory Booker’s staff members was taken into custody for…

Be on the lookout: Authorities are looking for information on a woman who has disappeared in Maine.

The Portland Police Department in Maine is searching for a missing 23-year-old…

Court Prevents Publication of Gene Hackman & Wife’s Death Images

A New Mexico judge ruled on Monday that images of Gene Hackman…

“Suffolk Law Graduate Dubbed ‘Screaming Banshee’ Smelling of Liquor Hits victim With Car and Insults Officer”

Lauren Mullins, an aspiring lawyer, was driving home in Cambridge, Massachusetts, after…

“Germany Deploys 5,000 Troops for First Foreign Mission Since World War 2 to Confront Putin”

GERMANY launched its first deployment of troops to foreign soil since World…

A British mom and her two young daughters die in a car accident in New York as a fancy wig designer’s Audi hits them while they walk along a crowded street.

Tributes have been given to a well-liked British woman and her two…

A box truck hit pedestrians on a sidewalk in Boston and crashed into a building, sending 5 people to the hospital.

AT least five people are hurt after a box truck barreled onto…

Jason and Kylie Kelce welcome their fourth child and share the baby’s name

Jason and Kylie Kelce have welcomed their fourth child, announcing the birth…

Images reveal the residence where a malnourished man was held captive for two decades.

On Tuesday, officials released photos of a Connecticut home where a woman…

‘Women on park bench’ confront pregnant woman for sitting in their usual spot using offensive language.

A pregnant mother was left humiliated when two ‘Karens’ mercilessly berated her,…

King Charles shares laughs and banter with friend Alan Titchmarsh while resuming royal duties and awarding honours following hospitalization

King Charles recently resumed his public duties after a brief hospitalization due…

Volunteers Work to Find Dismembered Remains of Indigenous Teen Emily Pike

In Arizona, a volunteer group is organizing a search to find the…