Senator Josh Hawley questioned Frontier and Spirit executives about rewarding staff for detecting oversized carry-on bags and imposing additional fees on customers at the gate.
During a Senate subcommittee hearing in Washington, members criticized airline CEOs for introducing a variety of fees for services such as early boarding and seat upgrades that were previously included in the ticket price.
Senator Richard Blumenthal suggested that the government should examine the airlines’ practice of implementing what he referred to as unwarranted fees and consider imposing penalties on them.
Blumenthal, the chairman of the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, said seat fees were pure profit for the airlines because they don’t have to create new seats or incur other expenses by allowing customers to pick where to sit.
Some senators expressed frustration during Wednesday’s hearing when airline executives could not explain how they set the amount of various fees. They said the vagaries of airline pricing make it hard for consumers to budget for trips.
“We’re all captives on your airplanes at a certain point. You just say, ‘You want to pick seat? We’re just going to charge you some random amount more,’” Sen. Maggie Hassan, D-N.H., said. “It would be good if you guys could be transparent about what you do and why.”
The fees don’t seem to be discouraging anybody. Americans are flying more than ever.
The Transportation Security Administration reported screening nearly 3.1 million travelers at airports around the country on Sunday, a new single-day record. The 15 busiest days in TSA history have all occurred this year, with traffic at airport checkpoints up 5% over 2023.
Airline executives bristle at the term “junk fees,” and argue they are merely giving consumers what they want: choices.
“Our customers who prioritize affordability have the option to choose a lower-fare product and, in doing so, opt out of paying for additional services that they do not want,” Andrew Nocella, the chief commercial officer of United Airlines, said in testimony prepared for the panel’s hearing. “But we also have customers who seek more services, and they retain the ability to choose the services they value, for an incremental fee, like a seat with extra legroom or checked bags.”
Airlines have been adding fees on desirable seats to take advantage of increasing demand.
The airline executives took offense at the charge that they are gouging travelers.
“It has never been more affordable to fly,” said Steve Johnson, chief strategy officer for American Airlines.
Transportation Department figures indicate that airfares have fallen by about one-third since 2000 when taking inflation into account. However, those figures do not include fees.
Senators said fees should be described clearly during the ticket-buying process. The executives said their airlines do that.
Some subcommittee members also criticized airlines for the way they enforce fees.
Sen. Josh Hawley, R-Mo., sparred with executives of Frontier Airlines and Spirit Airlines, which paid employees $26 million in bonuses for spotting customers whose carry-on bags were too big to fit under a seat. The passengers were forced to pay a fee — up to $77 on Spirit and $99 on Frontier — to use an overhead bin.
“If people want to know why it’s such a terrible experience to fly, this is news for them today,” Hawley told the airlines executives Wednesday. “Your airlines are paying millions of dollars to your employees to harass people who have already paid!”
Frontier Chief Commercial Officer Robert Schroeter and his counterpart at Spirit, Matthew Klein, said ensuring that people follow the rules was a matter of fairness to all passengers.
When Hawley asked why bag fees may vary from one customer to another, Schroeter said Frontier must cover its costs.
“Overall, our job is to generate the most revenue we can so we can keep profitable as an airline,” he said.
U.S. airlines raised more than $7 billion from fees on checked bags last year, with American Airlines and United Airlines leading the pack. They scooped up another $1 billion in ticket-change and cancellation fees, although that was about one-third of what they raised before the coronavirus pandemic, when the biggest airlines dropped change fees.
Exact figures on other types of fees are hard to determine, but the Senate panel reported last week that United, American, Delta Air Lines, Frontier and Spirit collected a combined total of more than $12 billion in seat fees between 2018 and 2023. That included charges for things such as more legroom or an aisle seat near the front of the plane.
Airline fees have been a frequent target of criticism by the Biden administration, all the way up to President Joe Biden.
A Transportation Department rule that took effect in October requires airlines to make automatic cash refunds for tickets and fees when flights are canceled.
The airline industry is suing to block another regulation requiring more prominent disclosure of baggage and cancellation fees. An appeals court has blocked that rule, and its fate is uncertain under President-elect Donald Trump. Blumenthal asked the five executives to drop the lawsuit. None agreed to do so.
The airline industry and Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg have continued to fight over fees and other regulations, even after the November election.
