Discover the top 20 must-visit ice cream shops in Northeast Ohio for 2025

CLEVELAND — Craving the best ice cream in Northeast Ohio?

3News has compiled a list of 20 top ice cream spots to check out in the area, spanning from popular local spots in Cleveland to lesser-known treasures in Akron and nearby regions. So, if you’re in search of a sweet treat, look no further!

Whether you’re in the mood for creamy custards, indulgent sundaes or unique handmade flavors, these iconic spots promise a sweet experience for all. 

Get ready to explore the top places to satisfy your ice cream cravings. 

• 6484 Brecksville Road, Independence

Discover a classic, family-owned ice cream stand tucked away near the Towpath Trail – Dairy King. This hidden gem is celebrated for its large servings of soft-serve ice cream, decadent sundaes, and flavorful milkshakes.

• Locations: Parma Heights, Painesville, Mentor, Lyndhurst and Fairview 

Since its establishment in Parma Heights in 1985, East Coast Custard has been a beloved institution in Northeast Ohio. With a rich selection of over 100 custard flavors that differ from store to store and are frequently updated, there’s always something new to try. Additionally, their outlets also feature vegan-friendly custard options made from oat milk.

• 8094 Columbia Road, Olmsted Falls

Falls Ice Cream, located at Grand Pacific Junction in Historic Olmsted Falls, serves a variety of ice cream flavors in a nostalgic setting.

Fairport Harbor Creamery, founded by Brian and Karen Volzer, offers house-made ice cream, boozy ice cream and baked goods, focusing on creative flavors, quality ingredients and a welcoming lakeside experience.

Since 1974, Honey Hut has been offering special flavors of ice cream. With 13 regular flavors and special flavors rotating each week, there is always something new to try at Honey Hut.

Grab a delicious scoop and walk down to Chagrin Falls Waterfall for a scenic ice cream experience by the water,

Kamm’s Corners Ice Cream is known for creating premium homemade ice cream flavors at family-affordable prices. They also make custom ice cream cakes that can be ordered ahead of time. 

King Kone has a flavor for everyone, with over 30 Hershey’s hard-serve flavors as well as rich, creamy soft-serve flavors.

K Cream Korner, located in Lorain, offers a wide variety of ice cream flavors, making it a popular destination for both locals and visitors.

• 30136 Euclid Avenue Wickliffe

Jerry’s Dairy Pride, situated in Wickliffe, is a well-loved ice cream shop offering a diverse selection of flavors, making it a go-to destination.

Mason’s Creamery is known for its ice cream in the summer and ramen in the winter, both made using the best ingredients they can source. The shop offers classic flavors as well as unique flavors that are the signature of Mason’s Creamery. The creamery also offers egg waffle bowls or even a macaroon ice cream sandwich!  

Serving locally sourced ice cream since 2022, Mickey’s offers a variety of hard and soft-serve flavors, milkshakes, sundaes, and cobblestones. They also serve jumbo hot dogs and crêpes daily. Located in Downtown Willoughby, it’s a great spot for a sweet treat or a quick bite.

Mitchell’s Ice Cream is a Cleveland staple that creates each batch of ice cream in their kitchen in Ohio City. Mitchell’s offers many delicious flavors, ranging from fruity combinations to a chocolate lover’s dream. 

Mount Granita Italian Ice

Perhaps you’re not in the mood for ice cream, but you’re still seeking a refreshing treat. Mount Granita Italian Ice in Little Italy and features handmade Italian ice with fresh fruit, cane sugar and no artificial flavoring. 

Rosati’s Frozen Custard offers rich, creamy frozen custard made fresh all day, featuring a rotating selection of unique special flavors crafted with premium local ingredients.

Customers at Skoops can enjoy a homemade custard that uses three main ingredients: milk, cream and egg yolks. In addition to the traditional chocolate, twist, or vanilla custard, they offer a weekly specialty flavor of homemade custard. Skoops is also known for its super-premium ice cream, which is made with elevated levels of butter fats, giving you a rich, creamy texture and taste unlike anywhere else.

Founded in 1936, Strickland’s Frozen Custard is known for serving up two special flavors each day. 

The ice cream parlor in Canton has been around since 1926 and features ice cream parfaits, sundaes, twisters and ice cream cookie sandwiches. 

Since 1900, Toft’s has been creating “one quality” products through fresh milk and real cream from their family farms to create a unique creamy taste.