BBC Gossip
  • Home
  • Health
  • News
  • Crime
  • Local News
  • People
  • Guest Post
BBC Gossip
BBC Gossip
  • Home
  • News
  • Health
  • People
  • Celebrities
  • Crime
  • Entertainment
  • Finance
  • Guest Post
Home Supreme Court to review lawsuit after FBI mistakenly raids Atlanta residence
  • Local News

Supreme Court to review lawsuit after FBI mistakenly raids Atlanta residence

    The FBI mistakenly raided their Atlanta home. Now the Supreme Court will hear their lawsuit
    Up next
    Suspect arrested for alleged theft of Kristi Noem's bag containing $3K in cash: reports
    Person arrested for reportedly stealing Kristi Noem’s purse with $3,000 in money.
    Published on 27 April 2025
    Author
    BBC Gossip

    ATLANTA – In the early hours of October 18, 2017, FBI agents forcefully entered Trina Martin’s residence in Atlanta, barged into her bedroom, and aimed weapons at her and her then-partner while her 7-year-old son cried out for her in another room.

    Unable to console her son, Martin trembled in shock as the events unfolded before her, lasting what seemed like an endless span of time. Fortunately, the situation concluded swiftly as the agents soon realized their mistake – they had raided the wrong house.

    On an upcoming day, Martin’s lawyer will present her case to the U.S. Supreme Court, seeking to have her 2019 legal claim against the U.S. government reinstated, alleging the agents’ actions amounted to assault, false imprisonment, and other infringements.

    A federal judge in Atlanta dismissed the suit in 2022 and the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that decision last year. The Supreme Court agreed in January to take up the matter.

    The key issue before the justices is under what circumstances people can sue the federal government in an effort to hold law enforcement accountable. Martin’s attorneys say Congress clearly allowed for those lawsuits in 1974, after a pair of law enforcement raids on wrong houses made headlines, and blocking them would leave little recourse for families like her.

    FBI Atlanta spokesperson Tony Thomas said in an email the agency can’t comment on pending litigation. But lawyers for the government argued in Martin’s case that courts shouldn’t be “second-guessing” law enforcement decisions. The FBI agents did advance work and tried to find the right house, making this raid fundamentally different from the no-knock, warrantless raids that led Congress to act in the 1970s, the Justice Department said in court filings starting under the Biden administration.

    In dismissing Martin’s case, the 11th Circuit largely agreed with that argument, saying courts can’t second-guess police officers who make “honest mistakes” in searches. The agent who led the raid said his personal GPS led him to the wrong place. The FBI was looking for a suspected gang member a few houses away.

    Martin, 46, said she, her then-boyfriend, Toi Cliatt, and her son were left traumatized.

    “We’ll never be the same, mentally, emotionally, psychologically,” she said Friday at the neat, stucco home that was raided. “Mentally, you can suppress it, but you can’t really get over it.”

    She and Cliatt pointed out where they were sleeping when the agents broke in and the master bathroom closet where they hid.

    Martin stopped coaching track because the starting pistol reminded her of the flashbang grenade the agents set off. Cliatt, 54, said he couldn’t sleep, forcing him to leave his truck driving job.

    “The road is hypnotizing,” he said of driving tired. “I became a liability to my company.”

    Martin said her son became extremely anxious, pulling threads out of his clothes and peeling paint off walls.

    Cliatt initially thought the raid was a burglary attempt, so he ran toward the closet, where he kept a shotgun. Martin said her son still expresses fear that she could have died had she confronted the agents while armed.

    “If the Federal Tort Claims Act provides a cause of action for anything, it’s a wrong-house raid like the one the FBI conducted here,” Martin’s lawyers wrote in a brief to the Supreme Court.

    Other U.S. appeals courts have interpreted the law more favorably for victims of mistaken law enforcement raids, creating conflicting legal standards that only the nation’s highest court can resolve, they say. Public-interest groups across the ideological spectrum have urged the Supreme Court to overturn the 11th Circuit ruling.

    After breaking down the door to the house, a member of the FBI SWAT team dragged Cliatt out of the closet and put him in handcuffs.

    But one of the agents noticed he did not have the suspect’s tattoos, according to court documents. He asked for Cliatt’s name and address. Neither matched those of the suspect. The room went quiet as agents realized they had raided the wrong house.

    They uncuffed Cliatt and left for the correct house, where they executed the warrant and arrested the man they were after.

    The agent leading the raid returned later to apologize and leave a business card with a supervisor’s name. But the family received no compensation from the government, not even for the damage to the house, Cliatt said.

    Martin said the most harrowing part of the raid was her son’s cries.

    “When you’re not able to protect your child or at least fight to protect your child, that’s a feeling that no parent ever wants to feel,” she said.

    ___

    Whitehurst reported from Washington.

    Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.

    You May Also Like
    Families of Kate Brown, Carnell Sledge release statement following Cleveland Metroparks police update on double homicide investigation
    • Local News

    Kate Brown and Carnell Sledge’s families issue statement after Cleveland Metroparks police provide an update on the investigation of their double homicide

    “Due to the close proximity of the Westpark murder, Metropark detectives are…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025
    Akron police release bodycam video from incident where suspect fired at officers
    • Local News

    Police in Akron share bodycam footage from incident involving suspect shooting at officers

    Police say one officer suffered a ‘minor leg injury.’ A 27-year-old woman…
    • BBC Gossip
    • May 31, 2025
    A bridge collapse causes a train to derail in Russia, killing at least 7 people, officials say
    • Local News

    Train accident in Russia kills 7 after bridge collapse

    Moscow Railways reported that the bridge in Russia’s Bryansk region, near the…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025
    Water quality predicted 'poor' again at Edgewater Beach due to E. coli concentration levels
    • Local News

    Edgewater Beach Expected to Have Low Water Quality Again Because of High E. coli Levels

    At Edgewater Beach, the amount of E. coli present is currently 106…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025
    2 fans died and an officer is in a coma after Champions League celebrations in France
    • Local News

    Tragic Outcome at Champions League Celebration in France: 2 Fans Dead, Officer in Coma

    PARIS – According to French authorities, tragic incidents marred the celebrations following…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025
    'Lilo & Stitch' passes 'Sinners' to become 2nd highest grossing film of 2025
    • Local News

    ‘Lilo & Stitch’ Beats ‘Sinners’ to Take 2nd Place for Highest Earnings in 2025

    With $280.1 million total, it surpassed “Sinners” to become the second-highest grossing…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025
    Thousands evacuated in 3 provinces as Canadian wildfires threaten air quality into some US states
    • Local News

    Canadian wildfires force thousands to evacuate in 3 provinces, endangering air quality in US states

    FLIN FLON, MB – Officials have reported that more than 25,000 residents…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025
    ‘He did nothing wrong:’ Family demands answers after Orange County deputies shoot, kill man
    • Local News

    “Family Seeks Answers: Orange County Deputies Shoot and Kill Man Despite No Wrongdoing”

    In Orange County, Florida, the family of a man who was shot…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025
    Netflix reveals details about Lady Gaga on 'Wednesday,' 'Squid Game' and 'Stranger Things' finales
    • Local News

    Netflix shares information about the conclusions of “Wednesday” with Lady Gaga, as well as the finales of “Squid Game” and “Stranger Things.”

    Netflix hosted an event in Inglewood, Calif., where it shared exciting news…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025
    Exercise boosts survival rates in colon cancer patients, study shows
    • Local News

    Study demonstrates that exercise improves survival rates for individuals with colon cancer

    An international experiment, a first-of-its-kind, showed that a three-year exercise program improved…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025
    Central Floridians still seeing higher grocery prices amid economic uncertainty
    • Local News

    Economic uncertainty continues to drive up grocery prices for Central Florida residents

    ORLANDO, Fla. – Central Floridians are still battling high prices when making…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025
    Adam Sandler steps back on the golf green in latest 'Happy Gilmore 2' trailer
    • Local News

    Adam Sandler returns to the golf course in the new preview for ‘Happy Gilmore 2’

    The sports comedy sequel will also feature many familiar faces from the…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025

    Recent Posts

    • Investigation launched by police after popular Haribo sweets are found to contain cannabis, prompting a recall due to reports of a family falling ill.
    • Lawsuit filed after man sustains ‘catastrophic injuries’ on Disney ride
    • Retailers openly disregard new ban on disposable vapes, claiming lack of communication about the law’s enforcement.
    • “Hamas Ministry’s Claim of Casualties During Aid Collection Challenged”
    • Corpse discovered on famous Georgia landmark, Stone Mountain
    Haribo recalls popular sweets found to contain CANNABIS as police launch probe into gummies that ‘made family fall ill’
    • News

    Investigation launched by police after popular Haribo sweets are found to contain cannabis, prompting a recall due to reports of a family falling ill.

    HARIBO has recalled packets of sweets in the Netherlands found to contain…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025
    Man suffered 'catastrophic injuries' on Disney ride: Lawsuit
    • Crime

    Lawsuit filed after man sustains ‘catastrophic injuries’ on Disney ride

    Downhill Double Dipper at Disney World in Florida (Disney). A Florida man…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025
    Disposable vape ban goes up in smoke! Shopkeepers openly flout new law... and some say they've NEVER been told it was coming in
    • News

    Retailers openly disregard new ban on disposable vapes, claiming lack of communication about the law’s enforcement.

    Shopkeepers flouted the new vapes crackdown today by selling single-use e-cigarettes on…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025
    Dozens of Palestinians killed, nearly 200 wounded while on their way to collect aid in Gaza
    • US

    “Hamas Ministry’s Claim of Casualties During Aid Collection Challenged”

    Reports indicate that a tragic incident occurred in the Gaza Strip where…
    • BBC Gossip
    • June 1, 2025
    BBC Gossip
    • Home
    • Privacy Policy
    • News
    • Local News
    • Health
    • Crime
    • Guest Post