Ivy League murder suspect acted superior, did not expect to be caught: body language expert

When Luigi Mangione was brought into a Pennsylvania courthouse, his body language revealed crucial information about his state of mind, as observed by a body language expert.

Mangione, who is accused of killing UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson in Manhattan, was apprehended in Altoona, Pennsylvania, after a McDonald’s patron noticed his resemblance to the shooting suspect portrayed in images.

Currently facing charges in Pennsylvania for forgery and unlawfully carrying a firearm, Mangione has opted not to forgo his right to an extradition hearing, where he will potentially be transferred to New York to face allegations of murder.

As he was escorted into Blair County Court on Tuesday by a cadre of officers, the jumpsuit-clad 26-year-old was wide-eyed and had his head on a swivel as he shouted at surrounding reporters. Susan Constantine told Fox News Digital that Mangione showed a “rigidity” that indicated he was fearful. 

Luigi Mangione mugshot in prison orange

Luigi Mangione pictured in a Pennsylvania mugshot after his arrest in connection with the murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson. (Obtained by Fox News Digital)

“This was not the sinister killing [face] – this was him, his charismatic personality, his flirty personality, the one that everybody and his friends and family are all talking about,” Constantine said. “He’s a great guy. They like him. He’s, you know, engaging and he’s, you know, speaks in front of the public and doesn’t have any fear about it. That’s his personality.”

“These types of killers disassociate – it’s called cubing,” Constantine continued. “So when they’re in active pursuit, there is one personality. And then when he’s in relationships, he has another one… he’s able to disassociate from what is the sinister thoughts and ideas and radicalism that’s actually flooding through his mind.

“All of a sudden, that smile turned to a frown [during his perp walk] – the lifted cheeks turn into droopy cheeks. And then he had a more rigid and more tension in his facial expression that was dissimilar to what we have seen in the past. So this was a game over expression.”

A photo obtained by Fox News Digital shows Luigi Mangione.

A photo obtained by Fox News Digital shows Luigi Mangione. (Obtained by Fox News Digital)

The suspect’s confident stance during the shooting, captured on surveillance footage, is another side to the “cube” – and indicates the planning that went into the attack. 

“He had already rehearsed – he was ready for the engagement. This was not something that just happened spontaneously. This is something that he thought out, measured and planned,” Constantine said. “That’s why you see his body language being very much in control. He’s not startled. He knows exactly what he’s going to do. That’s why his countenance is down. His energy level is down because he’s in hyper-focus.”

In a photo taken from Crime Stoppers, a man in what appears to be an olive green jacket smiles

The suspected gunman in UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson’s murder, believed to be Luigi Mangione, is seen flirting with a hostel employee on surveillance footage before the Dec. 4 shooting. (NYPD)

Constantine told Fox News Digital that Mangione’s body language – both during his perp walk and in a photograph snapped by police in a holding cell the day before – indicated that he did not expect to be apprehended by police. 

“There are behavioral signatures and cognitions of people that are being deceptive,” Constantine said. “[People display] rigidity when [they are] caught. What do they do? They sit up straight, they’re very militant… So when you think about his structure, he’s just very robotic.”

You May Also Like
Meghan Markle dances the night away at Beyonce's Cowboy Carter tour in Los Angeles - as Prince Harry awkwardly shuffles in a cowboy hat

“Meghan Markle enjoys Beyonce’s Cowboy Carter tour in LA while Prince Harry dons a cowboy hat”

Meghan Markle and Prince Harry were seen at the fifth night of…
Pope Leo XIV calls this a challenge to 'human dignity' in first address to cardinals

“Pope Leo XIV Deems It a Threat to ‘Human Dignity’ in Inaugural Speech to Cardinals”

Leo XIV’s initial address as pope featured a poignant message to the…
Revealed: How Prince William went 'ballistic' after he was presented with a 'dossier of distress' documenting claims about Meghan Markle's treatment of staff

Prince William’s reaction to a ‘dossier of distress’ detailing claims about Meghan Markle’s treatment of staff was explosive.

Prince William went ‘ballistic’ when he heard claims that Meghan Markle was being…
Uncle Sam’s Devil’s Island: From Al Capone to ‘Machine Gun’ Kelly, meet Alcatraz’s most infamous inmates

Explore the Most Notorious Prisoners of Alcatraz: From Al Capone to ‘Machine Gun’ Kelly

President Donald Trump recently stirred controversy by suggesting the reopening of Alcatraz,…
Ukraine and its allies push for a 30-day ceasefire starting Monday

Ukraine and its partners advocate for a 30-day ceasefire to commence on Monday.

Leaders from four major European countries came together in Kyiv on Saturday…
The State of Michigan's Growing Budget Must Be the Priority of Whoever Replaces Gretchen Whitmer in 2026

Focusing on Michigan’s Increasing Budget Should Be the Top Concern for the Future Leader after Gretchen Whitmer in 2026

Truly never too soon, Is It? Before delving into the main topic…
MAUREEN CALLAHAN: Even for The View, this was heinous... but I'll never forget THAT delicious, blink and you miss it on-air slip up

“A Look Back at a Memorable On-Air Moment on The View That Had Everyone Talking”

The Bidens are back from the political dead. Or trying their hardest,…
Former Trump advisors wage Balkan campaign as MAGA moves into Europe

Trump’s ex-advisors promote MAGA in Europe’s Balkan region

Former campaign advisors of President Donald Trump are currently working on a…
Star snaps of the week: Boys’ club with Tom Cruise, George Clooney, David Beckham and more
Round-up of the week’s celebrity sightings: Men’s group featuring Tom Cruise, George…
Jordon Hudson, 24, almost quit Miss Maine pageant amid furor over her treatment of boyfriend Bill Belichick, 73

24-year-old Jordon Hudson considered leaving Miss Maine pageant due to controversy surrounding her relationship with 73-year-old boyfriend Bill Belichick

Jordon Hudson, a contestant aiming to be Miss Maine, faced criticism for…
Florida man, 89, and his dog mauled to death by black bear in state's first fatal attack

An 89-year-old man and his dog killed by a black bear in Florida’s first deadly bear attack

Confirming reports, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) announced on…
Tom Cruise makes rare comment about ex Nicole Kidman as girlfriend Ana de Armas seen solo after couple's trip

Tom Cruise gives rare statement about former wife Nicole Kidman while Ana de Armas spotted alone following vacation with the couple.

Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman have been divorced for more than two…