Cynthia Erivo to play JESUS in new stage show... but Wicked star's casting divides fans

Cynthia Erivo will star as Jesus in a new production of Jesus Christ Superstar this summer in LA – sparking an avalanche of reaction from fans.

At 38 years old, the actress from Wicked revealed her upcoming role as the male lead in the famous musical by Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice. The production is scheduled to take place at the Hollywood Bowl from August 1 to August 3, according to Variety.

The current Best Actress Oscar nominee for her role as Elphaba in the blockbuster, wrote on Instagram: ‘Just a little busy this Summer, can’t wait.’

Erivo previously played Mary Magdalene in an all-female version of Superstar in 2020, with Morgan James taking on the role of Jesus.

The announcement of the casting decision caused a split among fans. Some criticized the choice of having a woman play the male religious figure, calling it ‘blasphemous’. On the other hand, some fans embraced the innovative approach to the project.

One fan wrote: ‘What the actual f**k is going on’ while a second typed: ‘Absolutely friggin blasphemy. You’re mocking Christ the King.’

Cynthia Erivo will star as Jesus in a new production of Jesus Christ Superstar this summer in LA - sparking an avalanche of reaction from fans - pictured this week in London

In a new rendition of Jesus Christ Superstar in Los Angeles this summer, Cynthia Erivo will portray the character of Jesus. This casting news prompted a wide range of reactions from fans, as seen in a recent photo of her in London.

The Wicked actress, 38, is nominated for the Academy Award for Best Actress for her role as Elphaba (pictured with Ariana Grande as Glinda)

The Wicked actress, 38, is nominated for the Academy Award for Best Actress for her role as Elphaba (pictured with Ariana Grande as Glinda)

Jesus Christ - the central figure of Christianity, the world's largest religion - is depicted as a male and the son of God

Jesus Christ – the central figure of Christianity, the world’s largest religion – is depicted as a male and the son of God

Others wrote: ‘Hollywood really is just a fishbowl of likeminded individuals; good luck with this one.

‘Cynthia should be more careful about the roles she gets. This is just plain disrespectful.

‘This is blasphemy. Jesus Christ is not a woman. 

‘F**k it. Whatever. Nothing matters. Set your money on fire, production company. I don’t care.’

Others came out in support of the casting, reveling that Erivo’s role would ‘p**s off those MAGA snowflakes.’

Followers wrote:  ‘She is extremely talented and no doubt slay and, doubly, if it pisses off the magabillies and Leon lovers this if GREAT NEWS.

‘Oh no here come the conservatives up in arms because their feelings are hurt that someone isn’t playing “their version,” of Jesus!

‘oh, this is going to piss off a LOT of people, and I am here for it.

The casting news divided fans - with some lambasting the casting of a woman as the male religious icon 'blasphemous' while others delighted in the fresh take on the project

The casting news divided fans – with some lambasting the casting of a woman as the male religious icon ‘blasphemous’ while others delighted in the fresh take on the project

Others came out in support of the casting, reveling that Erivo's role would 'p**s off those MAGA snowflakes.'

 Others came out in support of the casting, reveling that Erivo’s role would ‘p**s off those MAGA snowflakes.’

 ‘plus, she can f*****g SING.

Tony Award winner Sergio Trujillo will direct and choreograph the show, while Stephen Oremus will serve as musical director and conductor.

Among the most famed actors to play Jesus in Jesus Christ Superstar include Ted Neeley in the 1973 film adaptation and Jeff Fenholt in the original Broadway production of the show.

John Legend also played the Messiah in a live TV production in 2018. 

Erivo recently opened up on her Wicked experience and how she feels Elphaba is a representation of black and queer people because of her ‘otherness’.

The actress said the film opened up conversation about racism and queerness, as she discussed the blockbuster in AnOther’s spring/summer issue.

Cynthia stars opposite Ariana Grande’s Glinda in the film and the two have been open about the deep bond they formed while filming the two-part epic.

Discussing what it was like to play someone so outcast by society, Cynthia said: ‘It’s a green witch. But I think what they see also is so many parts of me. 

‘There’s a deep understanding of what it feels like when you don’t fit, what it feels like to constantly want to be accepted and not be accepted…

‘What it feels like to know what your responsibility is and to have to be brave enough to take it, what it feels like to feel like you have more to offer but nobody believes that you have that in you.’

Ted Neeley played Jesus in the 1973 film adaptation

Ted Neeley played Jesus in the 1973 film adaptation 

John Legend also played the Messiah in a live TV production in 2018

John Legend also played the Messiah in a live TV production in 2018

‘The green skin is like the umbrella under which the “other” lives. So yes, it’s a conversation about racism, but it’s also a conversation about anyone who’s been othered. It’s a conversation about queerness.

‘The green sets Elphaba apart from everybody else. She is the ultimate other. And I think there’s this added responsibility because I’m a black woman underneath that green, so we can also really have the conversation about what it’s like to be a black woman when nobody wants you there.’

Cynthia also revealed that she has to detach herself from her characters because she gives so much of herself to each role and ‘cares deeply’ about them.

You May Also Like

Kanye West Disrespects Diddy in Court by Insulting His Shiny Teeth

An individual identified as “Jane,” who used a pseudonym, appeared in court…

Video captures object ‘falling from Air India aircraft’ moments before accident – expert praises ‘incredible’ rescue of British passenger in seat 11A

Internet conspiracy theorists have identified the specific moment when one of the…

Kanye West Surprises at Diddy’s Federal Trial in New Video

Kanye West reportedly arrived at a New York federal courthouse on Friday…

Israel conducts airstrikes on nuclear site and eliminates high-ranking military officials after years of covert operation involving Mossad establishing a hidden drone base inside Iran, escalating tensions in the Middle East towards a potential global conflict.

Israel has initiated an extraordinary attack on Iran, utilizing fighter jets and…

Live Updates: Tensions rise in the Middle East as missile strikes target Tehran’s nuclear facilities and senior Iranian officials are killed

THE Middle East stands on the brink of all-out war after Israel…

Joey Barton makes shocking comments about Gary Neville and his wife after siding with Eni Aluko in their dispute

Joey Barton has declared war on Gary Neville as the former Manchester…

Mossad operatives spent years preparing for Israel’s targeted assault in Iran, employing drones, eliminating military leaders and nuclear experts, and destroying radar and missile facilities in the most severe attack on Iranian land in almost fifty years.

Months, if not years in the planning, it was the most devastating…

Silver Alert Issued for Missing Texas Woman: Keep an Eye Out

The Texas Department of Public Safety has issued a Silver Alert for…

Father Accused of Incest for Having 3 Children with Daughter

A West Virginia man was indicted on Monday for sexually abusing his…

“Melania Trump Unveils Gorgeous New Appearance, Fans Rave about First Lady’s Improved Look as She Whispers to Husband”

MELANIA Trump debuted a bold new look as her husband showered her…

Comprehensive guide to deadly plane crashes in 2025, with 383 passengers tragically lost

We are only half-way through 2025 and there have already been several…

50 Cent insults Kanye West’s wife Bianca Censori during Diddy trial appearance

50 Cent quickly targeted Kanye West and his wife Bianca Censori after…