An expert has cautioned that the motive behind the brutal quadruple homicide of four University of Idaho students may never be disclosed following a plea deal between suspect Bryan Kohberger and prosecutors.
The unexpected plea reversal occurred just before Kohberger, a former graduate student at Washington State University, was scheduled to stand trial in Boise, Idaho, in August.
Under the proposed terms of the deal, the death penalty would be eliminated as an option, and Kohberger, aged 30, would admit to four counts of first-degree murder, felony burglary, and relinquish his right to appeal.
Kohberger would serve four life terms without the possibility of parole.
Additional details about the plea deal have not been revealed; however, Judge Steven Hippler still has to sign off on the agreement to make it official.
Eric Faddis, a criminal trial attorney in Colorado who is not associated with the case, believes the public may never know Kohberger’s motive behind the brutal stabbings.
“I’m not sure we’re going to get there. I’m not sure that would be required for the plea agreement,” Faddis told The U.S. Sun.
“In most plea agreements it wouldn’t. Usually, just the plea of guilty is all that the defendant is required to give.
“I’m not sure we’re ever going to know about the motives behind these gruesome killings of four students.
“I would mention too at the sentencing hearing, although the court will receive input from the victims’ families, that likely is not going to change what will be the ultimate outcome for Bryan Kohberger, which is life behind bars without the possibility of parole forever.”
As part of the deal, Kohberger will reportedly not have to explain why he’s changing his plea or disclose why he committed the crimes, sources told Fox News.
BOXED IN
Up until Monday, Kohberger – the only suspect arrested in the brutal quadruple homicide case – and his defense continued to push his innocence and even sought to delay the projected August 18 trial start date.
However, as his day in court approached, Kohberger’s defense strategy was slowly being chipped away by Judge Hippler, who denied an array of motions by the defense team.
The latest blows came after the judge ruled against Kohberger’s alternate perpetrators theory and the ability for the defense to present an alibi.
Kohberger’s defense team offered four individuals as alternate perpetrators who could have committed the crime – a theory Judge Hippler ruled was only based on “wild speculation” and not proof.
“Nothing links these individuals to the homicides or otherwise gives rise to a reasonable inference that they committed the crime,” The judge wrote in his ruling.
“Indeed, it would take nothing short of rank speculation by the jury to make such a finding.”
Idaho law requires that a judge approve an alternate perpetrator defense before a trial begins.
I’m not sure we’re ever going to know about the motives behind these gruesome killings of four students.
Eric Faddis, trial attorney based in Colorado.
The defense also failed to meet the deadline to present an alibi to support their claim that Kohberger was not in the area of the off-campus house on King Road on the night of November 13, 2022.
Since no one was able to vouch for where Kohberger was on the night of the murder, his defense team argued the defendant was “stargazing at night,” driving around alone.
They argued Kohberger would often go alone on “hikes, runs, and/or see the moon and stars.”
‘FAMILIES SPLIT’
The news of a plea deal received mixed reactions from the families of the victims, Madison Mogen, 21, Kaylee Goncalves, 21, Xana Kernodle, 20, and Ethan Chapin, 20.
The families of Mogen and Chapin were relieved when they learned about the plea deal, according to CBS News and NewsNation.
However, the families of Kernodle and Goncalves lashed out at the prosecution, saying the state of Idaho “failed them.”
The Kernodle and Goncalves families said prosecutors briefly spoke to them about a potential plea deal on Friday, but admitted they were blindsided when the news of the agreement broke on Monday afternoon.
The Goncalves family bluntly said the talks about a plea deal was a “HARD NO” for them.
“We are beyond furious at the state of Idaho. They have failed us,” the family wrote in a statement on Facebook.
“NOTHING in our conversation prepared us for the next steps. Sunday night we received an email that sent us scrambling.
“We immediately jumped into panic mode and started making phone calls and sending emails. Unfortunately all of our efforts did not matter.”
Kristi Kernodle, the mother of Xana, “strongly opposed” the plea deal, according to TMZ.
Prosecutors said the plea deal was proposed to Kohberger as an attempt to “seek justice” for the families.
“We cannot fathom the toll that this case has taken on your family,” the letter signed by Latah County Prosecutor Bill Thompson read, according to the Idaho Statesman.
“This resolution is our sincere attempt to seek justice for your family.
“This agreement ensures that the defendant will be convicted, will spend the rest of his life in prison, and will not be able to put you and other families through the uncertainty of decades of post-conviction appeals”
‘KOHBERGER’S ADMISSION’
A hearing for the plea change has been set for Wednesday.
The hearing could mark the first time Kohberger addresses the court directly and enter a guilty plea on his behalf.
“I think he has to. I think the judge will require that to come from his mouth,” Faddis, the Colorado-based trial attorney, added.
“Certainly it has legal effect. It’s an admission to the most serious crime there is.
“But it also kind of has a broader social effect, certainly an effect for the community, certainly an effect for the victim’s families.
“To hear it come from his mouth, to say, you know, after all the months of pleading not guilty and talking about alibis and everything else, now he’s really coming to the table and saying, ‘Hey, look I did this. I killed those four college students. I’m pleading guilty to it.’
“This is what’s going to happen at the plea hearing.”
