DAILY MAIL COMMENT: The British public deserved the facts on Southport

As every GCSE physics student should know, nature abhors a vacuum. Where there is emptiness, natural forces will act to fill it.

Social media follows a similar pattern. If genuine information is lacking, it becomes a breeding ground for cranks and conspiracy theorists to spread their ideologies quickly.

While many times their fabrications have minimal impact on our daily lives, there are instances where their influence can be profound. This was evident in the aftermath of the tragic Southport murders.

Following the horrific incident where Axel Rudakubana fatally stabbed three young girls at a Taylor Swift-themed dance class, the police held back crucial details about his identity and background for several days.

As a result, the online rumour mill went into overdrive. The killer was a Muslim asylum seeker, they said. He had only recently arrived here, and this was how he repaid our hospitality.

This was a flat lie, of course, but it gathered such currency that anger grew and anti-immigrant protests sprang up around the country, some involving attacks on mosques and migrant hostels.

It was an inexcusable orgy of violence, but it could have been nipped in the bud had the police seized the narrative by countering the lies with salient facts.

For days police refused to release more than the most basic information about the identity and background of Axel Rudakubana (pictured) who stabbed three young girls to death at a Taylor Swift-themed dance class

For days police refused to release more than the most basic information about the identity and background of Axel Rudakubana (pictured) who stabbed three young girls to death at a Taylor Swift-themed dance class

Instead, they hid behind contempt of court rules to justify virtual silence. This was spurious and seriously unwise.

Those laws are meant to prevent a ‘substantial risk of serious prejudice’ to a fair trial. They should not be used as a blanket excuse for keeping the public in the dark on a matter of huge importance.

Yesterday, Rudakubana, 18, pleaded guilty to three murders, ten attempted murders, producing the deadly poison ricin and possessing an Al Qaeda training manual.

He is clearly a severely unbalanced young man, obsessed with murder and genocide. He had been excluded from school following a knife threat and was known to the authorities through Prevent, the Government’s anti-extremism programme.

However, he was not an asylum seeker, and he is not a Muslim. He was born in Wales to Christian parents originally from Rwanda. 

If this information had been disclosed at the time, the riots would almost certainly not have happened. 

As it was, while the families of the dead and wounded were in the throes of shock and grief, a malign circus was playing out around them.

Yesterday, Rudakubana, 18, pleaded guilty to three murders, ten attempted murders, producing the deadly poison ricin and possessing an Al Qaeda training manual. Pictured: victims of Axel Rudakubana (L-R) Alice da Silva Aguiar, nine, Bebe King, six, and seven-year-old Elsie Dot Stancombe

Yesterday, Rudakubana, 18, pleaded guilty to three murders, ten attempted murders, producing the deadly poison ricin and possessing an Al Qaeda training manual. Pictured: victims of Axel Rudakubana (L-R) Alice da Silva Aguiar, nine, Bebe King, six, and seven-year-old Elsie Dot Stancombe

Axel Rudakubana was not an asylum seeker, and he is not a Muslim. He was born in Wales to Christian parents originally from Rwanda. If this information had been disclosed at the time, the riots would almost certainly not have happened. Pictured: Riot police hold back protesters in Southport

 Axel Rudakubana was not an asylum seeker, and he is not a Muslim. He was born in Wales to Christian parents originally from Rwanda. If this information had been disclosed at the time, the riots would almost certainly not have happened. Pictured: Riot police hold back protesters in Southport

Extraordinarily harsh penalties were eventually handed down to rioters and those who spread false rumours that fuelled them, but the damage was already done.

The police and Home Office no doubt believed they were doing the right thing in suppressing the truth. They may have thought that even mentioning asylum seekers or Muslims was inflammatory.

But they must understand in the age of social media they cannot control the flow of false information. They can only refute it with facts. Silence is no longer an option.

Other troubling questions arise out of this heart-rending case. Why, for example, was Rudakubana not monitored despite being referred three times to Prevent?

He may not have been aligned to any group, but he was known to police and social services. How could they have failed to notice how dangerously disturbed he really was?

It is always said after traumatic incidents like this that lessons must be learned. For the sake of those poor girls and their bereft families, let’s hope this time it’s true.

You May Also Like

Discovering Paul Burton’s current whereabouts.

PAUL Burton is the subject of the hard-hitting Channel 4 documentary 24…

Virginia Giuffre, Survivor of Jeffrey Epstein’s Abuse, Passes Away at 41 in Apparent Suicide

Virginia Giuffre, 41, a prominent survivor of Jeffrey Epstein’s sexual abuse, died…

Aimee Lou Wood misses White Lotus event while Walton Goggins walks the red carpet after his SNL hosting debut. The actress was recently teased about her teeth on the show.

Aimee Lou Wood decided not to attend a White Lotus event in…

Luigi Mangione brought to court for controversial ‘electric chair’ exhibit, pleads not guilty despite facing death penalty.

The CEO assassin Luigi Mangione has denied the federal charges after his…

Check out the amazing new £3 billion airport renovation in a small country that might be perfect for your long-haul vacations

THIS is the brand-new £3 billion airport upgrade in a tiny Middle…

Touching messages for dear British person discovered deceased in Benidorm following body being found on shore.

The relatives of a man who was tragically found dead on a…

Father and Son Accused of Fatally Beating Former Family Friend in Response to Daughter’s Assault

In New Jersey, a 55-year-old man and his 17-year-old son were taken…

Attention: Authorities Looking for Information on Woman Missing in North Carolina

Police in North Carolina are currently looking for a missing 30-year-old woman…

Stars Arrive in Inverness for Filming of New Series – Charlotte Church and Paloma Faith Make a Stylish Entrance in Pajamas and Eccentric Outfits

The Celebrity Traitors cast touched down at Inverness Airport on Friday, as…

Scarlett Johansson may face her ex Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively at a gala, worrying they may steal the spotlight from her important career event

Scarlett Johansson exuded confidence on Thursday night at the star-studded 2025 Time100…

Meghan Markle’s podcast, “Confessions of a Female Founder,” fails to make an impact on charts and loses to a sleep-related show

The Duchess of Sussex has suffered another blow this week after her…

Sad News: Karen Silva, a contestant from The Voice Kids, passed away at the age of 17 after suffering a stroke.

Karen Silva, a former contestant on The Voice Kids, has sadly passed…