Who are Caroline Glachan’s killers Robert O’Brien and Andrew Kelly?

FOURTEEN-year-old schoolgirl Caroline Glachan’s body was discovered on the banks of the River Leven in 1996.

BBC documentary Murder Trial: Girl in the River delves into the horrific case, which went unsolved for a quarter of a century.

Photo of a girl smiling, wearing a white shirt and tie.
Caroline Glachan was murdered and dumped in a river in 1996Credit: BBC

Caroline Glachan had just waved goodbye to her friends when she was bludgeoned to death and dumped in the River Leven on 25 August, 1996.

A drug addict found her beaten body in the water the next day. Her sneakers were left on the riverbank in Renton, West Dunbartonshire.

The schoolgirl’s death became one of Scotland’s most high-profile unsolved cases.

‘Waiting for a breakthrough’

Caroline’s mum Margaret McKeich previously said: “I am just waiting for that knock on the door telling me there has been a breakthrough.

“I imagine that scenario all the time and think about what it would be like.

“The cold case team are looking at it with a fresh pair of eyes and starting from the beginning so there is a lot for them to get through.”

In 2016, the case was reopened on the 21st anniversary of her death, with police issuing a fresh appeal for information.

Detective Chief Inspector Stuart Grainger expressed gratitude to the public for their help in the investigation and for sharing crucial information about Caroline’s death.

In November 2021 Robert O’Brien, Andrew Kelly and Donna Brand were charged with Caroline’s murder.

Her mum Margaret said cops “couldn’t have given me a better Christmas”.

Long-awaited trial

In November 2023, the long-awaited trial took place at Glasgow’s High Court.

Robert O’Brien, O’Brien, Kelly and Brand finally faced murder charges 27 years after Caroline’s tragic death.

Although they will eventually be released from prison, it offers no solace. The loss of Caroline condemns me to a lifetime of anguish, living without my daughter.

Margaret McKeichThe Scottish Sun

The trio were found to have repeatedly punched, kicked and thrown bricks or similar items at the teenager, causing blunt force trauma to her head and body, before pushing her into the river.

Sadly, a fourth suspect passed away before authorities could arrest her.

In December 2023, O’Brien, 46, and Kelly, 45, were found guilty of killing O’Brien’s 14-year-old girlfriend following a trial at the High Court in Glasgow.

They were both given life sentences, with O’Brien to serve a at least 22 years and Kelly at least 18 years.

Donna Marie Brand, 45, was also sentenced to life behind bars with a minimum of 17 years.

Photo of a young girl in a white shirt and plaid skirt.
Her murder went unsolved for 25 yearsCredit: BBC

Scum of the earth

Speaking to The Scottish Sun before sentencing, Carole’s mum said: “They are scum of the earth.

“They’ve just been out for themselves with a total disrespect for life, I have total contempt.

“I’m hoping that the judge gives them a very lengthy sentence because that’s what they deserve. I hope they rot in prison.

“I would hope that they never ever get out. They’ve had 27 years of freedom.

“They will serve a sentence and then get out. It will never bring Caroline back.

“But I serve a life sentence. I have to live my life without a daughter.”

Mugshot of Robbie O'Brien, convicted of murder.
Robert O’Brien was sentenced to life and will be behind bars for at least 22 yearsCredit: PA

Who is Robert O’Brien?

Robert O’Brien was 18 years old at the time of the schoolgirl’s murder.

He was Caroline’s boyfriend and had a history of violence towards Caroline.

Her mother disapproved of the age difference and said that he had previously “lifted his hands to her”.

He was described as the main perpetrator in the murder, using “extreme violence” on the teenager.

Addressing O’Brien during sentencing, Judge Lord Braid said: “Nobody who heard the evidence of the pathologist Dr Marjorie Turner could fail to be sickened by her descriptions of the injuries caused by you.”

Mugshot of Andrew Kelly, convicted of murder.
Andrew Kelly was sentenced to life with a minimum of 18 yearsCredit: PA

Who is Andrew Kelly?

Andrew Kelly was 16 years old when the murder took place.

During sentencing the judge said that while Kelly played a lesser role in the murder, he inflicted “murderous violence” on the teen.

He said: “Caroline was a lover of life, but due to both of you Caroline has been deprived of the opportunity of living that life, becoming an adult, having children, fulfilling the potential she had.

“You have taken a daughter from a loving mother. Mrs McKeich has spoken of the pain that Caroline’s death has caused, the void her death has left that will never be filled.

“She has been deprived of seeing the woman that Caroline would have become. No sentence that I pass could possibly make up for what she has lost.”

Murder Trial: Girl in the River will air on BBC Two at 9 pm on Wednesday, January 29, 2025.

You May Also Like

2-year-old child dies 2 days after being struck by ‘Islamist terrorist’ driving Mini into crowd, injuring 36 in Munich

A CHILD has tragically died from serious injuries after a suspected Islamist…

Coroner confirms that three Indiana sisters were killed.

An Indiana coroner says a mother killed her three daughters last year…

Mother Livestreamed the Dead Bodies of Her 3 Children on Facebook Live Before Ending Her Own Life

A Virginia mother who was found dead with her three children last…

Customers Criticize USPS for Neglecting Mail Problems Resulting in Packages Moving Between Facilities for Weeks

THE United States Postal Service has been slammed by customers for “ignoring”…

Hamas will release three Israeli captives who have been held for nearly 500 days since being abducted on October 7th.

Three additional Israeli hostages have been freed by HAMAS in Gaza as…

Man from Alabama Accused of Committing Rape and Sexual Abuse Against a Minor

An Alabama man was arrested this week and charged with 41 counts…

USPS customers angered by mailman’s disrespectful behavior caught on camera, agency’s response deemed confusing.

USPS customers are raging after a mailman was caught on camera flinging…

Criticism for Chinese zoo painting donkeys as zebras in yet another “fake animal” scandal

A CHINA zoo has been slammed for painting donkeys in black and…

Authorities discover weapon in search for perpetrator of Valentine’s Day shooting as RNLI lifeboat aids in search for suspect following woman’s fatal shooting outside bar

Police have found a gun as they hunt for Valentine’s Day killer…

Lawyer argues that Prince Andrew couldn’t be unaware of Epstein abuse, as he was seen at a party with underage girls

A LAWYER who represented victims of Jeffrey Epstein said it would have…

Gaza refugee granted permission to remain in the UK despite falsifying application about being in danger.

A REFUGEE was allowed to stay in the UK despite having an…

The spouse of Rob Burrows shares the heartbreaking moment when her ex-Rugby player husband signaled that he could no longer continue, while she was by his side in his last hours. This happened shortly after they watched their wedding video together one final time.

Rob Burrows’ wife, Lindsey Burrow, shared the heart-wrenching moment when her husband…