St. Thomas More Catholic church closing on Southwest Side; community raises money to help Greenstone Methodist Church in Pullman

CHICAGO (WLS) — The Easter Holiday brings good news for one Chicago church, but sadness for another.

In Pullman, Greenstone Methodist Church managed to collect sufficient funds to continue operating, bringing relief to the congregation. However, the situation is different at Saint Thomas Moore Catholic church on the Southwest Side, where parishioners are facing their final Easter Sunday service before the church permanently closes.

ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch

Saint Thomas More church is surrounded by stained glass windows that narrate the story of the saint, with a striking blue-toned mosaic in the apse and intricately carved wood panels illustrating the 14 stations of the cross.

The traditional Southwest Side Catholic church attracted more than 1,200 people when it was built in 1958.

“It’s a gorgeous church with a lot of spirit to it that should be utilized,” parishioner Bill McDonald said.

Long-time St. Thomas More parishioner, McDonald, expressed his shock and disappointment upon receiving a letter from the Archdiocese of Chicago on Palm Sunday. The letter stated that all masses at the church will cease after May 27, leaving the community saddened by the imminent closure.

“I don’t think I will be I will register at any church anymore if they close this church, I’m glued to Saint Thomas More,” parishioner Kate Aguanunu said. “I love this church. I love it with my heart. “

Kate and Chika Aguanunu have belonged to St. Thomas More since 1985.

With only about 160 members left, the Archdiocese gave the church and its parishioners three years to recruit more members, specifically African-American Catholics, but time is up.

“We want to continue the mission of attracting new Catholics to the faith,” McDonald said. “And they’re just saying, ‘No, you’ve had a chance.'”

While St. Thomas More parishioners pray for another chance, a few miles south, Pullman residents are celebrating their efforts this Easter weekend in saving a church.

RELATED | Community effort to help historic Greenstone Church in Pullman

“We are so happy to be here today on this religious holiday of Good Friday to celebrate our GoFundMe was very successful,” said Cindy McMahon with the Historic Pullman Foundation.

Historic Pullman District residents pulled together to raise over $20,000 dollars to pay for a People’s Gas bill that would restore gas service to the historic Greenstone Methodist Church. The 144-year-old church has gone through two winters without heat.

“Even though there are people here of different faiths and things and different religious traditions, we all consider this our church,” Pullman resident Roderick Lewis said. “And so, whenever they need something, the call goes out and we respond.”

With almost all of it’s original fixtures, Greenstone is the last Pullman building that was built for it’s intended use, and residents said they will fight to keep it that way.

The Greenstone Church will be open to the public on May 17 and 18 for Pullman Railroad days.

In the meantime, St. Thomas More Parishioners will celebrate their last Easter mass on Sunday. They hold our hope the Archdiocese will have a change of heart.

Copyright © 2025 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

You May Also Like
‘North Of North’s Dogsledding Fetish Sex Scene Is One Of A Kind — And Even Had Star Anna Lambe Feeling “Mortified”

“Unique Dogsledding Sex Scene in ‘North Of North’ Leaves Star Anna Lambe Feeling Embarrassed”

It might be cold in Ice Cove, Nunavut — but North of…
Beyonce mercilessly mocked as tickets for 'flop' Cowboy Carter tour reach same price as a McDonald's meal

Beyonce ridiculed as ticket prices for failed Cowboy Carter tour drop to cost of a meal at McDonald’s.

Beyonce has been ridiculed by music fans after tickets for her struggling…
The Evening Docket - Montana Saves the Day

“Montana: A Nightly Savior”

Friday in court was quieter than Thursday, but there were still important…
Pope Francis funeral: Trump and Zelenskyy among dignitaries converging on Rome

Dignitaries including Trump and Zelenskyy to attend Pope Francis’ funeral in Rome

VATICAN CITY — Leaders from around the world will gather in Rome…
Bain, member of K-pop group Just B, comes out as gay on final stop of band's world tour

Bain from the K-pop group Just B reveals he is gay at the last show of the band’s global tour

Bain, a 23-year-old member of the K-pop boy band Just B, came…
Trump's lone GOP-critic in Congress considers shock career move amid Pentagon power struggle

The only Republican congressman who criticizes Trump is thinking about making a surprising career change during a power struggle at the Pentagon.

One of the few remaining critics of Donald Trump on the Republican…
Watch 'Francis: The People's Pope'

View the documentary ‘Francis: The People’s Pope’

The ABC Owned Television Stations are highlighting local communities across the country…
Democrat-run Los Angeles failing wildfire victims’ rebuilding plans months after Trump visit: GOP rep

GOP Representative says Los Angeles, managed by Democrats, is struggling to help victims rebuild after wildfires despite Trump’s visit earlier this year.

Months after the devastating wildfires caused widespread destruction in Southern California, thousands…
Humiliating NFL Draft moment as Shedeur Sanders' dreams are crushed by brutal prank call

Shedeur Sanders faces an embarrassing prank call that crushes his NFL Draft dreams

Shedeur Sanders’ NFL Draft nightmare took a cruel twist Friday when his…
Aimee Carrero On Why Signing Onto ‘Your Friends And Neighbors’ Was A No-Brainer For Her: “I Love Nothing More Than Subverting A Stereotype”

Aimee Carrero: Embracing Role in ‘Your Friends And Neighbors’ to Challenge Stereotypes

From Elena of Avalor to Elena of Westmont Village in Your Friends…
Pope Francis' funeral schedule, what to expect from the Novendiali, a 9-day period of prayer, mourning

People attending Pope Francis’ funeral?

The upcoming funeral for Pope Francis, who passed away at 88 on…
Arbor Day 2025: Morton Arboretum helps students plant trees at Ted Lenart Regional Gifted Center in West Chatham, Chicago

Morton Arboretum supports tree planting with students at Ted Lenart Regional Gifted Center in West Chatham, Chicago for Arbor Day 2025

CHICAGO (WLS) — Some students in the city’s West Chatham neighborhood rolled…