Kristin Smart killer's Hail Mary attempt for reduced sentence criticized by AG: 'Meritless claims'

California Attorney General Rob Bonta is pushing back against Paul Flores, the man convicted of murdering California Polytechnic State University (Cal Poly) freshman Kristin Smart in 1996, for his request to overturn or reduce his convictions, calling his request “meritless.”

Flores is currently serving a 25-year-to-life sentence for Smart’s murder following a three-month trial in October 2022. 

In a new 107-page court filing, Flores’ defense claimed that Monterey County Superior Court Judge Jennifer O’Keefe abused her discretion multiple times, including not dismissing a juror that Flores argued showed signs of bias and allowing a ball-gag photo to be shown at the end of the trial.

His appeal argued that while just one of the alleged errors did not deprive him of his right to a fair trial, but that the accumulation of all the errors did.

According to the court schedule, Flores is expected to respond to the attorney general’s brief by May 5.

Stepheny Price is a writer for Fox News Digital and Fox Business. She covers topics including missing persons, homicides, national crime cases, illegal immigration, and more. Story tips and ideas can be sent to [email protected]

You May Also Like
Chicago Earth Day 2025 events: Excel Academy of Roseland students join in 2nd annual Joyce Chapman Clean and Green Cleanup

Excel Academy of Roseland students participate in the 2nd annual Joyce Chapman Clean and Green Cleanup for Earth Day in Chicago 2025.

CHICAGO (WLS) — Tuesday is Earth Day, and the Excel Academy of…
Harvey Weinstein's rape retrial opens at a different #MeToo moment with new allegations from former model

New allegations from former model as Harvey Weinstein’s retrial starts during a changed #MeToo era

In New York, the #MeToo retrial of Harvey Weinstein began on Wednesday,…
Timber Trails Elementary School teacher Katie Pappas, in kidney failure for 2nd time, is in desperate need of organ donation

Elementary School Teacher Katie Pappas Needs Kidney Donation for the Second Time

In Hoffman Estates, Illinois, Katie Pappas is faced with a challenging situation.…
Texas executes man 20 years after he strangled, stabbed a young mother to death

A man in Texas is put to death two decades after he strangled and stabbed a young mother.

<!–> Could Luigi Mangione face the death penalty? Panelists Jonna Spilbor and…
Nuclear watchdog urges 'trust but verify' that Iran engages in good-faith negotiations

Nuclear inspector suggests trusting Iran but confirming their commitment to negotiations

There is still much to be uncovered about the ongoing nuclear talks…
Trump insists Ukraine-Russia peace deal is close, but mistrust in Putin leaves experts skeptical

Experts doubt the likelihood of Ukraine-Russia peace deal as Trump trusts Putin

President Donald Trump this week said he is “very” optimistic that Ukraine…
'DWTS,' 'Golden Bachelor,' 'Mormon Wives,' 'Vanderpump Villa' and more: All the news from the Hulu Get Real Event

Exciting Updates from the Hulu Get Real Event: ‘Dancing with the Stars,’ ‘Golden Bachelor,’ ‘Mormon Wives,’ ‘Vanderpump Villa’ and Beyond

BEVERLY HILLS — Reality stars came together in Beverly Hills for Hulu’s…
The Fly on the Vatican Wall

Observing Secrets at the Vatican

Both of these individuals have openly displayed their Catholic faith in the…
The world says goodbye to Pope Francis: Emotional faithful enter St Peter's Basilica as the pontiff's body is placed on display for three days of mourning

Pope Francis Passes Away: Emotional Followers Pay Respects at St Peter’s Basilica as His Body Lies in State for Three Days

The Vatican has opened St. Peter’s Basilica to the public so thousands…
Illinois among 12 states suing President Donald Trump's administration to stop tariff policy

12 states, including Illinois, suing President Trump’s administration to halt tariff policy

NEW YORK — Illinois is among a dozen states that sued the…
Trustees hire law firms to defend Thornton Township, Tiffany Henyard in lawsuits over meeting brawl

Law firms hired by Trustees to defend Thornton Township and Tiffany Henyard in lawsuits related to meeting brawl

SOUTH HOLLAND, Ill. (WLS) — Thornton Township trustees have hired two law…
Michael Jordan out earns every athlete in the world for another year as eye-watering income is revealed

Michael Jordan remains the highest-earning athlete in the world for yet another year with staggering income disclosed

Some athletes do not have to give up the glamorous lifestyle of…