'A Press Release Is Not a Pardon': CA Judge Terminates Hunter's Tax Case, Eviscerates Joe's Rationale

The repercussions of President Joe Biden pardoning his troubled son Hunter persist as the final details of the two federal legal proceedings involving the First Son are wrapped up.

As we reported Sunday, while acknowledging the president’s authority to issue the pardon, the Department of Justice, through Special Counsel David Weiss, objected to the cases being dismissed outright, arguing that the pardon doesn’t negate the indictment or the guilt; it merely calls for the case against the pardoned person to be “terminated.” In lodging the objection, Weiss pointed out that Biden’s contention that his was a politicized prosecution was found to be hogwash by multiple courts, noting, “In total, eleven (11) different Article III judges appointed by six (6) different presidents, including his father, considered and rejected the defendant’s claims, including his claims for selective and vindictive prosecution.” 

Monday morning, Judge Maryellen Noreika acceded to the DOJ’s point and, rather than dismissing the Delaware gun case outright, as requested by Hunter’s attorneys, simply terminated the case. 



That left the California tax case, and late Tuesday, Judge Mark Scarsi followed suit, but not without offering his observations as to the rationale put forth by Joe Biden in his statement regarding the pardon — in a word: Malarkey. 

The net effect of Scarsi’s order is that the California case against Hunter is now also terminated. But after first noting that Hunter’s team botched things by merely providing a hyperlink to the White House press release regarding the pardon rather than filing an accurate copy of the pardon, Scarsi included some delicious parting shots on the matter (emphasis added, citations omitted):

The President’s statement illustrates the reasons for the Court’s disapproval, as representations contained therein stand in tension with the case record.

In short, a press release is not a pardon. The Constitution provides the President with broad authority to grant reprieves and pardons for offenses against the United States, U.S. Const. art. II, § 2, cl. 1, but nowhere does the Constitution give the President the authority to rewrite history. 

In a nutshell: Fine, Hunter — you’re off the hook. But your lawyers don’t know what they’re doing. And neither does your dad. 

You May Also Like
Pope Francis funeral: Trump and Zelenskyy among dignitaries converging on Rome

Dignitaries including Trump and Zelenskyy to attend Pope Francis’ funeral in Rome

VATICAN CITY — Leaders from around the world will gather in Rome…
Karen Read says she poured extra shots into her cocktails before John O'Keefe's death

Karen Read admits to adding extra shots to cocktails prior to John O’Keefe’s death

Sometimes, Karen Read might take things into her own hands, like when…
Luigi Mangione heads to federal court as DOJ debuts death penalty 'shift': ex-federal prosecutor

Luigi Mangione Appears in Federal Court as Department of Justice Changes Stance on Death Penalty: Former Federal Prosecutor

Luigi Mangione is set to appear in federal court on Friday afternoon…
Paris Hilton, California Republicans Announce 2 New Bills Geared to Protect Kids

Paris Hilton and California Republicans Unveil Two New Bills Aimed at Safeguarding Children

In a recent update on X, the socialite and reality TV personality…
George Santos to be sentenced for fraud, identity theft; prosecutors seeking 7-year prison sentence

George Santos Faces Sentencing for Fraud and Identity Theft – Prosecutors Push for 7-Year Prison Term

NEW YORK — Disgraced former U.S. Rep. George Santos, who lied about…
Jeopardy Liam Starnes: University of Chicago student and Barrington High School alum blows away game show competition

Liam Starnes from University of Chicago and Barrington High School impresses everyone on Jeopardy with his skills

CHICAGO (WLS) — Liam Starnes of Barrington has been enjoying a winning…
Arbor Day 2025: Morton Arboretum helps students plant trees at Ted Lenart Regional Gifted Center in West Chatham, Chicago

Morton Arboretum supports tree planting with students at Ted Lenart Regional Gifted Center in West Chatham, Chicago for Arbor Day 2025

CHICAGO (WLS) — Some students in the city’s West Chatham neighborhood rolled…
Democrat-run Los Angeles failing wildfire victims’ rebuilding plans months after Trump visit: GOP rep

GOP Representative says Los Angeles, managed by Democrats, is struggling to help victims rebuild after wildfires despite Trump’s visit earlier this year.

Months after the devastating wildfires caused widespread destruction in Southern California, thousands…
Michelle Obama Reveals Why She Skipped Trump’s Inauguration – and It’s As Self-Absorbed As You’d Imagine

Reasons Michelle Obama Skipped Trump’s Inauguration – It’s Just Like You’d Think

Michelle Obama finally revealed why she failed to attend President Trump’s second…
'Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back' turns 45 and celebrates at the TCM Classic Film Festival.

Celebrating 45 Years of ‘Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back’ at the TCM Classic Film Festival

LOS ANGELES — “I am your father.” Those four words from Darth…
7 Shows Like ‘Ransom Canyon’ If You’re Craving More Soapy Sagas Or Small-Town Streams

7 TV Series Similar to ‘Ransom Canyon’ for those Wanting More Dramatic Stories or Shows Set in Small Communities

Get ready with your cowboy gear because Netflix has a hot new…
Ana Navarro Shades Donald Trump After Alyssa Farrah Griffin Claims Straight Men Do Not Wear Makeup: “Has Anybody Met Donald Trump?”

Ana Navarro Throws Shade at Donald Trump in Response to Alyssa Farrah Griffin’s Claim That Straight Men Don’t Wear Makeup: “Has Anyone Seen Donald Trump?”

The hosts of The View were full of compliments for John Cena…