Daniel Penny jury fixated on single piece of testimony about how Jordan Neely died

The New York City jury, composed of seven women and five men, is deliberating on whether Marine veteran Daniel Penny is guilty of manslaughter for putting homeless man Jordan Neely in a chokehold. The focus of the jury has been on the testimony regarding Neely’s death.

The jury, deliberating under the oversight of Judge Maxwell Wiley, submitted a note around 3 pm on Wednesday requesting to review part of the city Medical Examiner’s testimony. Specifically, they wanted to revisit the information about issuing a death certificate for Neely without awaiting toxicology results for the 30-year-old victim.

During the trial, Dr. Cynthia Harris, the city Medical Examiner, emphasized that after reviewing bystander video footage of Penny’s interaction with Neely on the F train in Manhattan, along with investigative findings, she had ample evidence to conclude that Neely’s cause of death was neck compression. This key detail has been pivotal in the jury’s deliberations.

‘No toxicological result imaginable was going to change my opinion,’ Harris said, even if it showed ‘enough fentanyl to put down an elephant.’

She also claimed at one point that she did not know whether she observed Penny exerting ‘sufficiently consistent pressure’ on Neely’s neck in the video to kill him, according to Gothamist.

The jury also asked Wednesday to review the six-minute clip a Mexican journalist took of the chokehold, as well as body camera footage from when New York Police Department officers arrived on the scene as EMS workers tried to revive Neely, and footage of Neely’s interrogation at the police station in the aftermath.

Defense attorneys had argued that Neely did not die just from the chokehold, but from a combination of schizophrenia, use of synthetic marijuana, a genetic condition and his struggle with Penny onboard the subway.

They noted that first responders opted to use Narcan to reverse the effects of opioids before they administered CPR, and in his closing arguments, defense attorney Steven Raiser pointed out no expert witness during the trial could prove key elements beyond reasonable doubt.

The jury tasked with determining whether Marine veteran Daniel Penny (pictured) committed manslaughter when he put homeless man Jordan Neely in a chokehold have zeroed in on testimony about his death

The jury tasked with determining whether Marine veteran Daniel Penny (pictured) committed manslaughter when he put homeless man Jordan Neely in a chokehold have zeroed in on testimony about his death

The jury of seven women and five men asked a judge to rehear pat of the city Medical Examiner's testimony about issuing a death certificate without getting toxicology results for the 30-year-old victim

The jury of seven women and five men asked a judge to rehear pat of the city Medical Examiner’s testimony about issuing a death certificate without getting toxicology results for the 30-year-old victim

The defense attorneys have argued that Penny was only trying to protect others in the subway car in May 2023 when he subdued Neely to the point of death by placing him in a chokehold for six minutes.

Witnesses had said Neely boarded the uptown train on May 1, 2023 and started moving erratically, yelling about his hunger and thirst and proclaiming that he was ready to die, go to jail – or as Penny and some other straphangers recounted – kill.

In his closing statements, Raiser described the commuters onboard the subway that day as being ‘frozen in fear,’ and claimed there was an obvious reason that there was no footage of Neely’s outburst – because they were too afraid to move.

He then quoted experts and witnesses who testified during the trial, and reminded the jurors that Neely was described as having ‘severely psychotic cases.’

But Assistant District Attorney Dafna Yoran warned the jury on Tuesday that their verdict should not rely upon whether they themselves would be grateful for Penny’s intervention, or weigh testimony from his loved ones that he is a ‘good man.’

‘What is so tragic about this case, is that even though the defendant started out doing the right thing… a man died,’ she said.

‘He was given all the signs he needed to stop. He ignored them. He must be held accountable for that.’

She continued: ‘You’re not here to decide whether you’d want to ride alone on the train with Jordan Neely.

‘That is not what this case is about. The only thing you need to determine here is whether or not the evidence here proves the defendant killed Jordan Neely.’

Penny is pictured holding Jordan Neely in a chokehold on a NYC subway train on May 1 2023

Penny is pictured holding Jordan Neely in a chokehold on a NYC subway train on May 1 2023 

Neely was a Michael Jackson impersonator who was known and recognized in Times Square (pictured in 2009)

Neely was a Michael Jackson impersonator who was known and recognized in Times Square (pictured in 2009)

Yafna also noted that Penny is a Marine Corps veteran, arguing that he should have had a clearer understanding of the risks of his actions given his military experience.

She implored the jury to find Penny guilty of manslaughter – a charge which carries a maximum term of 15 years behind bars, describing in great detail how Neely ‘clawed at his own neck with his nails’ as he fought against the chokehold in those crucial first few minutes, before ultimately urinating on himself and losing consciousness.

But the jury must now decide whether to charge Penny with manslaughter or criminally negligent homicide charges. 

To convict, prosecutors say that Penny’s use of lethal force must be considered unjustifiable and that he acted recklessly when he subdued Neely.

If they decide Penny’s actions did not amount to manslaughter, the jury will then consider the lesser charge of criminally negligent homicide. 

Both charges are felonies. Neither carries mandatory prison time, but both carry the possibility of it – up to 15 years for manslaughter, or four for criminally negligent homicide. 

The jury also asked to review body camera footage from when New York Police Department officers arrived on the scene as EMS workers tried to revive Neely

The jury also asked to review body camera footage from when New York Police Department officers arrived on the scene as EMS workers tried to revive Neely

Deliberations are expected to continue Thursday, as protesters continue to gather outside the Manhattan courthouse to decry Penny and declare their support for a manslaughter charge.

But some of the protesters have become aggressive, defense attorney Thomas Kenniff said on Wednesday, describing how one man followed Penny to a car that was waiting for him after the trial one day and started banging on the doors.

The same man, he said, was ‘repeatedly berating Mr. Penny with violent and homophobic slurs’ when he arrived at court on Wednesday.

Kenniff noted that the man had been in the courtroom audience and asked Wiley to bar the man from future proceedings.

Wiley – who said he saw the confrontation from his office window – declined, noting that the public has a right to access court proceedings.

He said that court officers occasionally ‘limited people’s access’ because of their conduct inside the courtroom, but he was not inclined to eject anyone over their outside behavior.

At that point, Penny’s lawyers expressed their concern that the jury may hear the protesters, but Wiley noted that he told the jurors to ignore anything they may hear from outside.

‘At this point, I think that we will assume that they’re following their instructions,’ the judge said.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like
Biden lights 30-foot White House Christmas tree... and everyone is saying the same thing

Biden illuminates 30-foot White House Christmas tree… and everyone agrees on one thing

President Biden had a hair-raising experience as the White House’s annual Christmas tree…
'Christmas Star' to grace the night sky this weekend; crescent moon and possibility of more displays of the Northern lights

Don’t Miss the ‘Christmas Star’ in the Night Sky this Weekend; Look Out for the Moon and Potential Northern Lights Shows

A trifecta of stargazing events could be visible in space in the…
UPDATED: Shooter of United Healthcare CEO Used Fake ID to 'Become a Ghost' Before Attack; Backpack Found

UPDATED: Assailant of United Healthcare CEO Goes Under the Radar with Fake ID, leaving Backpack Behind

“He attempted to disappear as a ghost, essentially, and the strategy he…
‘Outlander’ Stars Caitriona Balfe and David Berry Explain Why Claire and Lord John Grey’s Sex Scene was “Vulnerable,” “Raw,” and Even “Beautiful”

The actors of ‘Outlander’, Caitriona Balfe and David Berry, share insights on why Claire and Lord John Grey’s intimate scene was described as “vulnerable,” “raw,” and “beautiful.”

Outlander Season 7 Episode 11 “A Hundredweight of Stones” could be deemed…
US jobs report shows 227,000 added jobs in November in bounce-back from October slowdown

Increase of 227,000 jobs in US job market during November following a slowdown in October is indicated in latest jobs report

WASHINGTON — In November, the American job market showed improvement by adding…
WATCH: 'Call Her Daddy' Podcast Host Roasts Kamala Harris Over Infamous Interview

“View the ‘Call Her Daddy’ Podcast Host Critiquing Kamala Harris for Infamous Interview”

Despite Kamala Harris largely fading from the spotlight after her defeat to…
The Pope's new wheels! His Holiness is gifted a 'G-Wagon popemobile' made especially for him - and it's all-electric

New Electric Popemobile Gifted to His Holiness Pope Francis: A Special ‘G-Wagon’ Just for Him

Pope Francis has a new set of wheels to roll around the…
Donald Trump breaks his silence on Pete Hegseth's fight to be his defense secretary

Donald Trump speaks about Pete Hegseth’s efforts to become his defense secretary

Donald Trump has thrown his full support behind his defense secretary nominee…
Glamorous female lawmaker, 30, 'bullied male aide into sex then made him run her errands'

“A 30-Year-Old Female Lawmaker Allegedly Coerced a Male Aide into Sexual Acts and Tasked Him with Errands”

A glamorous Washington state lawmaker bullied a male aide into sex, then…
‘Outlander’s Caitriona Balfe Breaks Down Season 7 Episode 11: “Do Any of You Ever Really Believe That We Would Kill Off Jamie Fraser?”

“Outlander’s Caitriona Balfe Analyzes Season 7 Episode 11: Does Anyone Truly Believe We Would Kill Off Jamie Fraser?”

Season 7 Episode 11 of Outlander titled “A Hundredweight of Stones” focuses…
Where Is Heather Morgan, AKA Razzlekhan, From Netflix’s ‘Biggest Heist Ever’ Now?

Current Location of Heather Morgan, Also Known as Razzlekhan, from the Netflix Show ‘Biggest Heist Ever’

Another day, another Netflix true-crime documentary about crypto-criminals. This week’s doc is…
Over half of Chicago City Council members calling on Mayor Brandon Johnson to find more ways to cut costs as budget deadline looms

Majority of Chicago City Council members urging Mayor Brandon Johnson to identify additional ways to reduce expenses as budget deadline approaches

CHICAGO (WLS) — Time is running out for Chicago City Council to…