Luigi Mangione assassination case signals DOJ shift on death penalty in blue states, expert says

Luigi Mangione’s defense team has requested a federal judge to eliminate the possibility of the death penalty in his case before he is formally charged with federal offenses related to the killing of Brian Thompson, the CEO of UnitedHealthcare. Thompson was fatally shot from behind outside a New York City hotel last year.

Prosecutors have objected to the defense’s request, arguing that it is premature to address the removal of the death penalty as Mangione has not yet been indicted or arraigned. Additionally, they have not officially indicated their intention to pursue capital punishment.

However, despite the lack of formal notice, Attorney General Pam Bondi announced on April 1 that she had instructed prosecutors to seek the death penalty. The defense team criticized the announcement and the method in which it was made through an Instagram post. They contended that the language used in the post implied Mangione’s guilt before a trial, which could prejudice the ongoing grand jury proceedings. The deadline for filing an indictment is approaching, adding further complexity to the situation.

On Wednesday, Mangione’s attorneys, Karen Friedman Agnifilo and Avi Moskowitz, shot back, accusing the government of violating their client’s right to due process by allegedly violating rules about commenting on a pending case outside the courtroom.

Luigi Mangione is escorted by NYPD into a van after being extradited from Pennsylvania for the murder of United Healthcare CEO, Brian Thompson.

Luigi Mangione is escorted from an NYPD helicopter in New York City Dec. 19, 2024. (Rashid Umar Abbasi for Fox News Digital)

Central to the issue is the death penalty announcement, which appeared on the Justice Department’s Instagram in a quote attributed to Bondi, which they said was prejudicial to the jury pool.

Mangione’s defense said waiting for an indictment would mean waiting too long.

“Once a prejudiced grand jury returns a death-eligible indictment, it is simply too late,” they argued. 

But the defense faces an uphill battle with those arguments of selective prosecution, according to Neama Rahmani, a Los Angeles-based former federal prosecutor who has been following the case.

UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson and the alleged killer

UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, left, was shot and killed in midtown Manhattan on his way to a shareholder conference. Surveillance cameras captured the ambush. (Businesswire; NYPD Crimestoppers)

“It didn’t work for Donald Trump. It didn’t work for Hunter Biden and it won’t work for Mangione,” he told Fox News Digital. “It’s a very difficult and high legal burden to meet.”

He predicted that the Justice Department under Bondi, a Trump nominee, may begin to more aggressively seek ways to impose the death penalty for crimes committed in blue states that don’t have capital punishment on the books. 

“Bigger picture, this may reflect a shift in DOJ policy where they will seek the death penalty in blue states that have a moratorium on or have an outright ban on capital punishment,” he said.

Trump has previously said he wants to expand the federal death penalty to cover more crimes and end a moratorium on federal executions put in place by former President Joe Biden.

Luigi Mangione appears in Manhattan Supreme Court in New York City

Luigi Mangione appears in Manhattan Supreme Court in New York City Dec. 23, 2024.  (Curtis Means for DailyMail/Pool)

Thompson, 50, was a father of two visiting New York City for a publicly announced shareholder conference. Mangione is accused of stalking him, then ambushing him outside the conference. He faces numerous charges, including terror-related murder, and allegedly wrote at length about his disgust with the health insurance industry.

Mangione faces charges in New York, Pennsylvania and federal court. He has pleaded not guilty.

You May Also Like
Pope Leo XIV's has deep roots on Chicago's South Side and south suburbs, including teaching at St. Rita High School

Pope Leo XIV has strong connections to Chicago’s South Side and surrounding suburbs, where he worked as a teacher at St. Rita High School

CHICAGO (WLS) — Pope Leo and his family have a long history…
New Movies on Streaming: ‘Warfare,’ ‘The Luckiest Man In America,’ + More

Streaming Now: Discover the Latest Films – ‘Warfare,’ ‘The Luckiest Man In America,’ and More

This weekend, there are new movies to enjoy on Video on Demand…
Pope Leo XIV: How his views compare to those of Pope Francis

A Comparison of the Views of Pope Leo XIV and Pope Francis

Cardinal Robert Prevost was selected as the next Pope after Pope Francis…
New cold front? Kashmir standoff raises specter of US-China proxy fight

Potential clash between United States and China through involvement in Kashmir conflict raises concerns of a new cold front.

The tensions between India and Pakistan regarding the disputed region of Kashmir…
Earth-shattering event that happened while four Americans were locked away from the world for three months that NONE could believe happened

Unbelievable event occurred while four Americans were isolated from the world for three months

A new game show has been introduced by Fox News that involves…
Trump and Kemp Strategize for Georgia Senate Race—Here’s What’s at Stake in 2026

Trump and Kemp Plan for Georgia Senate Race – Understanding the Importance of the 2026 Election

The upcoming 2026 midterm elections may seem far away, but the competition…
Madonna accidentally reveals unusual $23K item in bathroom of her mansion that only the very rich have

Madonna stumbles upon a strange $23,000 object in her mansion bathroom that only wealthy individuals own

Madonna revealed an interesting medical device in the bathroom of her opulent $40M…
Justin Bieber reveals 'the truth' about his wellbeing and admits he's 'asking God for help' in worrying post

Justin Bieber shares insights on his health and confesses to seeking divine assistance in a concerning message

Justin Bieber finally revealed the truth about his wellbeing in a string…
Kanye West claims Kim Kardashian left daughter North, 11, ALONE while attending Met Gala in shock legal attack

Kanye West dismisses viral legal demand as a hoax in letter to Kim Kardashian

A surprising new development has unfolded in the ongoing saga involving Kanye…
Tufts University student detained by ICE granted bail by federal judge

Federal judge grants bail to Tufts University student detained by ICE

Rümeysa Öztürk, a Tufts University student, was recently granted bail by a…
Blake Lively is iced out by ANOTHER A-list bestie whose 'loyalty is to Taylor Swift'... as insiders reveal her brutal Game of Thrones barb

Blake Lively feels excluded by ANOTHER close friend from the A-list circle, who is more loyal to Taylor Swift, according to sources who also share a mean comment made by Lively about Game of Thrones.

It seems that Blake Lively is finding herself increasingly isolated as even…
'Deny Reality': Karoline Leavitt Confirms White House Policy For Pronoun Displaying Journalists

Video: Karoline Leavitt strongly criticizes reporter questioning the extent of Trump’s authority

During a White House Press briefing on Friday, Leavitt faced a series…