'Dating Game' serial killer's rise to fame was key to his downfall, arresting officer reveals for first time

The individual responsible for apprehending serial killer Rodney Alcala, who served as the basis for the recent Netflix special “Woman of the Hour,” shared the authentic account depicted in the popular film and how Alcala’s participation in a dating show from the 1970s ultimately led to his apprehension. 

Referred to as the “Dating Game killer”, Alcala gained this moniker after his appearance on a television program called “The Dating Game” as Bachelor No. 1 in 1978 while actively engaging in his series of killings.

“Despite possessing a notably high IQ… the issue with individuals like him, I believe, is that the majority of their intelligence is not directed towards fostering personal connections… or similar aspects… instead, it is entirely focused on seeking out his next victim and formulating ways to manipulate women and girls,” Craig Robison, the chief investigator in the Alcala case at the Huntington Beach police department, conveyed to Fox News Digital during his inaugural public discussion of the investigation. “If we had not intervened, he would undoubtedly still be pursuing these actions.”

Robison is also a retired California prosecutor and judge. Since judges in the state are not permitted to speak on “pending” cases, he has never spoken publicly about the investigation previously and was even prohibited from testifying during the serial killer’s third trial. Robison said the case was considered “pending” from Alcala’s arrest up until he died in prison in 2021. 

In this March 30, 2010 file photo, convicted serial killer Rodney Alcala listens as victim-impact statements are read in a Santa Ana, Calif.

In this March 30, 2010 file photo, convicted serial killer Rodney Alcala listens as victim-impact statements are read in a Santa Ana, Calif. (AP)

Alcala died of natural causes on July 24, 2021, while awaiting execution in California. He was 77 at the time of his death. 

Though it took over 30 years to sentence Alcala for his crimes, he remained incarcerated from the time Robison arrested him in 1979 up until his death. 

“Huntington Beach back at the time, I think maybe they had 150 police officers, but it was a small, much smaller community than it is today…locals were able to catch this guy with all of this intelligence and put him behind bars,” Robison said. “That’s what started his complete undoing, was his arrest that we made in July of 1979.”

You May Also Like
Real estate star gives grim prediction for the future of LA as he reveals why homeowners will NEVER return after fires

Real estate professional offers a bleak outlook on LA’s future, citing reasons why homeowners may not return after fires

A Los Angeles realtor believes a staggering 70 percent of Pacific Palisades…
‘Severance’ Star Tramell Tillman Says Patricia Arquette Is ‘Terrifying’ When In Character: “She’s Fantastic”

Tramell Tillman from ‘Severance’ Describes Patricia Arquette as Scary in a Good Way: “She’s Amazing”

Patricia Arquette’s portrayal of Ms. Harmony Cobel in Severance doesn’t just impress…
Billionaire's plans for a sprawling resort on the edge of tiny idyllic village leaving locals in uproar

Local residents enraged as billionaire unveils massive resort project on outskirts of peaceful village

Wall Street billionaire Joe Ricketts has shared his plans for the 33-acre…
Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce celebrate Chiefs’ AFC Championship win: All the pics from the post-game ceremony

“Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce Celebrate Kansas City Chiefs’ AFC Championship Win: A Recap of the Post-Game Celebration in Photos”

In 2025, the Buffalo Bills faced off against the Kansas City Chiefs…
Pete Hegseth Stamps Out One USAF DEI Mutiny but Others Await

Pete Hegseth stops a rebellion in the US Air Force but more are on the horizon

The Air Force announced on Sunday that a unit of pioneering female…
Fan theory emerges about how Taylor Swift the 'superstitious queen' helped Travis Kelce secure trip to Super Bowl

Taylor Swift’s superstitious habits may have assisted Travis Kelce in reaching the Super Bowl, suggests a fan theory.

Taylor Swift’s supporters strongly believe that the singer’s ‘superstition’ played a role…
Trump issues shock threat to 90,000 new IRS staff as he reveals where they may end up working under him

Trump threatens to reassign 90,000 new IRS employees to different locations under his leadership

Donald Trump has suggested that the nearly 90,000 recently hired Internal Revenue…
Israel, Hamas reach deal to release hostages and allow Palestinians to return to Gaza Strip

Agreement reached between Israel and Hamas for hostage release and Palestinian return to Gaza Strip

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office announced Sunday that an agreement has…
In ‘Hail Mary’ move, ICC prosecutor files surprise application as Senate set to vote on sanctioning court

ICC prosecutor makes unexpected move with ‘Hail Mary’ application as Senate prepares to vote on court sanction.

Some critics believe that Karim Khan, the controversial prosecutor of the International…
Well, This Is Different: Kristi Noem Sworn in As DHS Secretary—at a Supreme Court Justice's House

Unusual Turn of Events: Kristi Noem Takes Oath as DHS Secretary at Home of Supreme Court Justice

That was the scenario on Saturday night when Kristi Noem, the former…
Middle East war: Israel blocks thousands from returning home to northern Gaza over ceasefire dispute

Israel prevents thousands from going back to northern Gaza due to disagreement over ceasefire in the Middle East conflict

DEIR AL-BALAH, Gaza Strip — On Sunday, Israel prevented thousands of Palestinians…
When Is Super Bowl 2025? Channel, Start Time, Where To Watch Super Bowl 2025 Online

“Super Bowl 2025 Date, Time, and How to Watch Online”

The Super Bowl returns to New Orleans as the Caesars Superdome will…