Grinches Gonna Grinch: Appeals Court Overturns an Injunction Against Small Business CTA BOI Compliance

Amid concerns about the potential appointment of yet another inadequate secretary of labor, freelancers and small businesses find themselves up against an additional burdensome law from a greedy Congress and the Department of the Treasury. The Corporate Transparency Act (CTA) was made official by then-President Trump on January 1, 2021, discreetly included in the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) to mask its negative implications. This legislation mandates that any business entity registered with their state secretaries (such as LLCs, S corps, and C corps) must submit a report on beneficial ownership information (BOI) to the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN).

The CTA includes significant reforms to anti-money laundering laws and is intended to help prevent and combat money laundering, terrorist financing, corruption, and tax fraud.  The CTA establishes a beneficial ownership reporting requirement for corporations, limited liability companies, and other similar entities formed or registered to do business in the United States. 

This supposed “anti-money laundering and terrorist financing” law has the unintended consequences of disproportionately targeting single-entity owners (like independent professionals) and small business owners who hire less than 100 employees, opening us up to fraud, onerous penalties, and invading our right to privacy. In fact, the majority of us were not even aware of the law or that we would be subject to penalties if we do not file with FinCEN by January 1, 2025

Merry Christmas and Happy Hannukah!

Financial expert, entrepreneur, and author Carol Roth testified before Congress in April and warned:

The Constitution of the United States protects the natural rights of all Americans, including against federal government overreach. While preventing financial crimes is a worthwhile endeavor, your methods cannot do so in a way that infringes upon Americans’ natural rights or assumes that they are guilty without due process. 

It is not only an invasion of privacy, but it also creates additional burdens and challenges for small business owners. And, once again, by exempting big businesses from this reporting rule, it specifically and unfairly targets and penalizes small business owners with a different standard and set of rules. 

Small businesses overall are not shell companies – they are the backbone of the economy. 

If FinCEN has concerns about money laundering, cartel activity or otherwise, they should be using the courts to receive information on those specific cases and entities.

But as in the case with the Biden-Harris final Independent contractor rule, Congress’ push to institute the PRO Act by any means necessary, and much of the regulatory overreach coming from the National Labor Relations Board, our government treats small business less like the backbone of the economy, and more like the gum underneath their shoe.

Thanks to Roth’s advocacy and a lawsuit brought by the National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB) to block the enforcement of this law through Texas Top Cop Shop, Inc., et al. v. Garland, et al., the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas granted a preliminary injunction in early December which blocked the CTA BOI reporting requirements from going into effect. 

But an adversarial government never sleeps. Note the dateline, two days before Christmas: These are really some evil sons of biscuits.

While the deadline for filing was extended to January 13, 2025, this still places independent professionals and small businesses back at square one, with a sword of Damocles hanging over our heads during this holiday season. Where’s the goodwill toward men?

“Because of this decision, small business owners must scramble to meet the reporting requirements of this egregious statute. Enforcing a Jan. 1 deadline for compliance will mean massive chaos for our nation’s small businesses,” said Beth Milito, Executive Director of NFIB’s Small Business Legal Center. “The district court, in granting the preliminary injunction, rightly recognized that the BOI reporting requirements would have devastating consequences for small business owners. Make no mistake, NFIB is already working to quickly appeal this terrible decision and provide our Main Streets with a reprieve from this harmful mandate.”

NFIB and other organizations continue to work to block the enforcement of this law. The Center for Individual Rights has the injunction be restored and the appeals court rules by January 6, ahead of the new FinCEN deadline. Whether through this and other court decisions or the “Repealing Big Brother Overreach Act,” which will be before the 119th Congress, this law needs to be rescinded.

Also, our friends @SCorpAssn  noted the ruling in the @NSBAAdvocate case could come soon (appeal arguments happened in September) and there’s another case in Michigan may rule soon.

Please stay vigilant on the CTA BOI.

Also please keep asking the Trump admin to make a statment of non-enforcement of penalties (and even better, getting rid of it entirely).

NFIB sounds the alarm on the ripple effect this could cause. We need this lump of coal in our Christmas stockings to be gone.

More than 32 million small businesses throughout the country will once again be subjected to this burdensome statute, including the nearly 300,000 NFIB member businesses represented in this lawsuit. NFIB supports the Repealing Big Brother Overreach Act, legislation that would repeal the CTA and permanently relieve small businesses of the beneficial ownership requirements.

You May Also Like
Myanmar, Thailand earthquake today: Death toll jumps to more than 1,600 as more bodies recovered from the rubble

Death toll rises to over 1,600 in Myanmar and Thailand following today’s earthquake, with more bodies found in the debris

BANGKOK — The ruling military in Myanmar reported through state television on…
Everything To Know About ‘Sunrise on the Reaping,’ The Latest ‘Hunger Games’ Movie Installment

The Complete Guide to ‘Sunrise on the Reaping,’ The Newest Movie in ‘The Hunger Games’ Series

There is a unique situation surrounding the announcement of the film adaptation…
Chilling audio between Gene Hackman's daughter and a cop deciding what to do with actor's dogs

“Gene Hackman’s Daughter’s Conversation with Police about Actor’s Dogs: A Revealing Tape”

Elizabeth Hackman, the grieving daughter of Gene Hackman, has reached out to…
‘The Pitt’ Star Shawn Hatosy Says It’s “Nice” Dr. Abbot is There For “Robby’s Lowest Moments”: “You Get a Character Who’s a Colleague, Who’s an Equal”

Shawn Hatosy from ‘The Pitt’ appreciates Dr. Abbot’s support for Robby in tough times: “It’s great to have a colleague and equal by your side.”

MAX‘s The Pitt has been in crisis mode for the past two…
ABC News correspondent Rachel Scott wins prestigious Gracie Award for excellence in journalism.

Rachel Scott, a correspondent for ABC News, is honored with the esteemed Gracie Award for outstanding achievement in the field of journalism.

LOS ANGELES — The Alliance for Women in Media Foundation has announced…
Stryker armored vehicles deploy to US-Mexico border under Trump administration

Deployment of Stryker armored vehicles to the US-Mexico border during Trump administration

EL PASO, Texas – As of this week, eight-wheeled armored fighting vehicles…
Kelvin Harrison Jr. explores 'Mufasa's' musical influences, including Lin-Manuel Miranda's 'Hamilton'

Kelvin Harrison Jr. delves into the musical inspirations of ‘Mufasa’, such as Lin-Manuel Miranda’s ‘Hamilton’

LOS ANGELES — After its nearly 3-month-long run in theaters, “Mufasa: The…
Massive 7.7 magnitude earthquake rocks Thailand, Burma, collapsing buildings and killing more than 150

Strong 7.7 magnitude earthquake hits Thailand and Burma, causing buildings to collapse and resulting in over 150 deaths

Thailand and Burma were hit by a powerful 7.7 magnitude earthquake, resulting…
Scientists reveal why the Myanmar earthquake is so bad - and warn the worst may be yet to come

Researchers explain the severity of the Myanmar earthquake and caution that worse could follow

Thousands are feared dead after a massive 7.7 magnitude earthquake hit Myanmar…
Shana Cloud, wife of missing North Carolina Green Beret Clinton Bonnell, charged with murder after body found in pond

Shana Cloud, the wife of missing Green Beret Clinton Bonnell from North Carolina, has been accused of murder following the discovery of a body in a pond.

In Fayetteville, North Carolina, a Green Beret’s vanishing has turned into a…
‘Mid-Century Modern’s Emotional Episode 9 Pays Tribute To The Late Linda Lavin

Episode 9 of Mid-Century Modern features a touching tribute to the late Linda Lavin

Following the unexpected passing of Linda Lavin at the age of 87…
Astonishing excuse death row prisoner has given for why he should not be executed

Unbelievable reason death row inmate has provided for avoiding execution

A motion has been filed by attorneys representing a death row inmate…