Total Genius: Son Tries to Drop Off Dad's Dead Body at NY Sheriff's Office, Is Promptly Arrested

Do you remember the humorous Bud Light “Real Men of Genius” advertisements? These ads were typically quite amusing. Although murder is a serious matter, a recent news story about a man in New York made me think of the theme of those commercials or even the infamous Darwin Awards.

The man in question was arrested for murder after attempting to deliver his deceased father’s body to a sheriff’s office, a situation compounded by the fact that the body had two gunshot wounds.

Sheriff Thomas Dougherty of Livingston County, New York, disclosed that 30-year-old Richard Fluegel Jr. brought the body of his father, Richard Fluegel Sr., to the sheriff’s office at the Livingston County Government Center on Monday.

Definitely too weird for “Forensic Files.”

“Livingston County is a safe place,” Sheriff Dougherty told the media, adding: 

This kind of stuff doesn’t happen. We don’t have people just show up and say they have a dead body with them and they’d like to turn in. It’s not common.

Dougherty seemed incapable of understanding what had happened as he repeated, in different words:

That’s very abnormal, as you can imagine. I have never heard of that in my career here. I don’t think a lot of law enforcement agencies have people doing that. It’s a very unique situation where someone calls and says ‘Yeah, I’m here and I want to turn in a body.’

Much less that the body was of the father of the man who tried to “turn it in.”

Ultimately, his family files a missing person report and on early Monday morning — so now you are into the 9th [hour] hour — it entered into our realm at the Livingston County Sheriff’s Office because, using technology, they were able to locate the vehicle in the village of Dansville.

Dougherty said a search warrant was issued in Livingston County, and Fluegel Sr. lived in an adjacent county. He added:

Why did he come down here? Meaning dad come down here and meet son, and then what interaction occurred? How did we end up in this place with a really unfortunate, tragic story? It’s one of those things that doesn’t make a ton of sense to the family — doesn’t make a lot of sense to us, and so that’s our job is to determine what happened.



A preliminary hearing was set for Monday.

A Couple of Thoughts

While it’s way too early to speculate, as is often the case with untold numbers of murders across the country, I can’t help wondering about what would cause a son to kill his own dad. A family history that finally boiled over? An out-of-control temper? Alcohol or drug abuse gone terribly bad? 

Whatever the reason, stories like this one, while they’re all too common, sometimes cause me to think about those of who are blessed by the love of family members, and how much we love them.

I’m sure I’ll say again, but Merry Christmas, everyone.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like
Did Prince Harry rush into marrying Meghan because they both felt her biological clock was ticking? The eager prince brushed off his brother William's warning to take it slow because she was already 35, claims book

Prince Harry’s hasty marriage to Meghan driven by her age, according to book

When a royal couple gets engaged before they really get to know…
Chicago shooting: 11-year-old boy speaks out after being shot by road rage driver following Northwest Side crash | ABC7 EXCLUSIVE

“11-Year-Old Boy Shares his Experience of Being Shot by Road Rage Driver in Chicago | ABC7 Exclusive Interview”

CHICAGO (WLS) — An 11-year-old boy was shot after a traffic crash…
OpenAI whistleblower found dead in San Francisco apartment from apparent suicide attempt

Whistleblower from OpenAI discovered deceased in San Francisco home following a suspected suicide effort

This story discusses suicide. If you or someone you know is having…
Texas police arrest 9 suspects allegedly involved in 4 cases near suburban mall in shoplifting blitz operation

Police in Texas apprehend 9 suspects linked to 4 shoplifting incidents near a mall in a coordinated operation.

Police in Austin, Texas, have arrested nine individuals suspected of being involved…
Gerald Radford, charged in alleged hate crime shooting of gay man John 'Walt' Lay, in Tampa, Florida, claims self-defense

Shooting in South Austin, Chicago today: Man injured in South Mayfield Avenue gunfight near car with off-duty cops

An investigation is underway by the Civilian Office of Police Accountability following…
Brutal way loyal GM worker, 60, was laid off after 38 years of service sparks outrage across America

Outrage spreads in America over the harsh layoff of a devoted 60-year-old GM employee with 38 years of service

The brutal way a loyal General Motors worker was unceremoniously laid off…
MAGA: Harvard President Privately Concedes University Must 'Rethink Messaging' After Trump Win

Harvard President Acknowledges Need to Review Communication Strategy following Trump’s Victory

In this episode of “The No-Longer-Hallowed Halls of Academia”… Harvard University president…
iHeartRadio Z100’s Jingle Ball 2024 red carpet: Katy Perry, Meghan Trainor plus more

“Highlights from iHeartRadio Z100’s Jingle Ball 2024 Red Carpet: Katy Perry, Meghan Trainor, and More”

Well-known personalities such as Katy Perry, Meghan Trainor, and Shaboozey showcased their…
‘The Way Home’ Moves Back To Hallmark Channel In Streaming Reversal Following Fan Backlash

“Hallmark Channel Reverses Streaming Decision for ‘The Way Home’ After Fan Criticism”

The Way Home is heading back … home. The popular series was…
Mother of suspect in UnitedHealthcare CEO killing spoke with FBI the night before her son's arrest: report

Report: FBI spoke with mother of suspect in UnitedHealthcare CEO killing the night before her son’s arrest

The FBI questioned the mother of Luigi Mangione, the suspect in the…
American couple killed in Mexico, found shot in pickup truck: officials

Officials report that an American couple was shot and killed in Mexico while in a pickup truck

Two Americans from California are dead after being found shot in a…
2 close-calls at Chicago O'Hare airport involving United Airlines flights in 1 day: 'This is normal?'

“Is it usual to have 2 near-misses at Chicago O’Hare involving United Airlines flights in one day?”

CHICAGO (WLS) — At O’Hare airport, there were two close calls in…