Israeli security experts argue ‘bad' deal with Hamas, but ‘no other way’ to free hostages

The news of Israel and Hamas finally agreeing to sign a deal was greeted with relief worldwide last Friday. This development offers hope for the release of the remaining hostages who have suffered under unbearable conditions for a long time. Additionally, it signals a potential end to the harsh 15-month conflict in Gaza.

The initial phase of the ceasefire and hostage swap deal will kick off on Sunday, with three out of the 33 hostages set for release being returned to Israel.

The negotiation for the exchange of the other 65 hostages, whether alive or deceased, is scheduled for the 16th day of the ceasefire. However, the actual repatriation of these individuals will commence in the second phase of the ceasefire, starting on the 43rd day of the agreement.

Israel hostages Bibas

Hanukkah candles are lit at places set at the festival table for the Bibas family, an Israeli family including 11-month-old baby Kfir, his four-year-old brother Ariel and their parents, Shiri and Yarden, who are being held hostage by Hamas in the Gaza Strip, in The Hostages and Missing Square, on December 9, 2023, in Tel Aviv, Israel.  (Photo by David Silverman/Getty Images)

“Many people don’t like it, because it is clear that Israel is losing the ability to destroy Hamas, as we promised,” Amidror said. “But we found ourselves in a situation that is the only way to get the hostages home.”

Israel hostages

A wall covered with photos of hostages held in the Gaza Strip after the deadly Oct. 7 Hamas attack calling for the release of the hostages on January 17, 2025, in Tel Aviv, Israel. On Wednesday, a ceasefire deal between Israel and Hamas was announced by mediators in the conflict. Formal approval from Israel’s cabinet was expected on Thursday, but delayed until Friday, although mediators insisted the deal was still expected to take effect on Sunday.  (Photo by Amir Levy/Getty Images)

Amidror explained that it became undeniably evident that as soon as Israeli forces made advances in areas near where hostages were held, they were then assassinated by Hamas guards.

“We understood that there is no military way to get them. And we had to make a decision, a very tough one – do we give up the hostages [lives], or we are making a deal?”

John Hannah, former National Security Advisor to Dick Cheney and a JINSA Randi & Charles Wax Senior Fellow, said it was a “tortuous decision, enormously painful, but one that the Israeli people have to make.”

Hannah said that while the decision is “incredibly divisive,” polls show that the majority of Israelis support returning the hostages over completely destroying Hamas. 

“Hamas is going to be able to claim that it survived,” Hannah said. “Israel will achieve one of its major war objectives, God willing, in the return of the hostages, but at the cost . . . [of] the annihilation of Hamas, both in its military and its governing components.”

Israeli airstrike in Gaza Strip

Smoke and flames rise following an Israeli airstrike in the Gaza Strip on November 2, 2023.  (Ali Jadallah/Anadolu)

“The best deal is the one which was not achieved,” Amidror said. “This is the deal.”

“There is no other way to release the hostages, and from within Israeli society, that was very important,” the retired Major General said. “Israel is a democracy, the government should hear what the people say.”

You May Also Like
Why three major countries were conspicuously left OFF Trump's massive tariffs list

The reason why three important countries were noticeably excluded from Trump’s extensive list of tariffs

President Donald Trump announced Wednesday his decision to impose extensive economic tariffs…
'Star Wars: Tales of the Underworld' brings back legendary bounty hunter and former Sith assassin 

‘Revisit the Legendary Bounty Hunter in “Star Wars: Stories from the Underworld”‘

LOS ANGELES — Are you a fan of Star Wars and looking…
Wisconsin election results today: Susan Crawford wins Wisconsin Supreme Court seat over Brad Schimel, cementing liberal majority

Susan Crawford defeats Brad Schimel in Wisconsin Supreme Court election, securing liberal majority

MADISON, Wis. — The candidate supported by the Democrats won the election…
Facts First: Scott Jennings Puts Cory Booker Speech Record in Perspective With Some Hard Truths for Dems

Presenting Information Clearly: Scott Jennings Highlights Cory Booker’s Speech History With Some Candid Realities for Democrats

During the Democrat Stuntapalooza in the first two months of President Donald…
Tourist vanishes after leaving Utah airport to backpack in mountains

Tourist goes missing after leaving Utah airport to hike in mountains

Authorities in Utah are searching for a missing tourist visiting from Finland…
Ohio State Highway Patrol investigating small plane crash, pilot dead

Investigation into small plane crash by Ohio State Highway Patrol, pilot fatalities reported

Ohio State Highway Patrol is investigating after a small plane crashed in…
Dolton, Illinois election results today: Democrat Jason House projected to replace Tiffany Henyard as Dolton mayor

Today’s election results in Dolton, Illinois: It is expected that Democratic candidate Jason House will take over as the new mayor of Dolton, succeeding Tiffany Henyard.

DOLTON (WLS) — Democrat Jason House is expected to win the Dolton…
Val Kilmer's haunting last post revealed after Batman star's death at 65

Val Kilmer’s voice weakens in his final ‘Batman’ post just two months before passing away at 65 after a prolonged illness

After a devastating years-long battle with throat cancer and deteriorating health, Val Kilmer has…
Travis Kelce reacts to brother Jason and Kylie's baby news as NFL star becomes an uncle for fourth time

NFL Star Travis Kelce Responds to Brother Jason and Kylie’s Baby Announcement, Welcomes Fourth Niece or Nephew

Travis Kelce has broken his silence on the birth of his fourth…
Suspected California Walgreens killer had 'grudge' against pharmacies, police say

Police indicate that the individual suspected of the Walgreens shooting in California harbored resentment towards pharmacies.

The suspected gunman who opened fire inside a California Walgreens on Tuesday…
Narciso Gallardo Fernandez, suspect in fatal Madera Walgreens shooting of Erick Velasquez, had 'grudge' against pharmacies: police

Police: Suspect in deadly Madera Walgreens shooting had a personal vendetta against pharmacies

MADERA, Calif. — A man walked into a Walgreens in California and…
‘Bosch: Legacy’ Season 3 Episode 1 Recap: Back in Bosch-ness

Recap of Episode 1 from Season 3 of ‘Bosch: Legacy’ – Returning to the World of Bosch

In the first season of “Bosch: Legacy,” Maddie Bosch, portrayed by Madison…