Jeopardy! contestant weighs in on Ken Jennings' strict ruling that caused his painful loss

Jeopardy! player Mehal Shah is still moving forward from the bitter blow of losing out on a place in the Tournament of Champions semifinals.

Thursday’s quarterfinal episode saw the contestant go through a devastating loss all because of one single syllable. 

Shah had been playing against Tennessee political organizer Will Stewart and Ohio-based systems administrator Ryan Manton.

The software engineer from Washington could have advanced to the next round, but his mistake in spelling the phrase ‘Annus Horribilis’ caused host Ken Jennings to consider his answer wrong.

Following the airing of the episode, Shah made his way to the Jeopardy! Reddit forum to air his grievances about the painful moment.

Despite what some might have expected, he supported the show’s ruling and wrote: ‘The show was 100 percent right to rule the way they did. 

Jeopardy! player Mehal Shah is still moving forward from the bitter blow of losing out on a place in the Tournament of Champions semifinals

Jeopardy! player Mehal Shah is still moving forward from the bitter blow of losing out on a place in the Tournament of Champions semifinals

Thursday's quarterfinal episode saw the contestant go through the devastating loss all because of one single syllable

Thursday’s quarterfinal episode saw the contestant go through the devastating loss all because of one single syllable 

‘If anyone disagrees, they can tell me why “Mimi Dolphins” would be a valid answer to the Final Jeopardy clue “It’s Mehal’s least favorite football team.”‘

He revealed how Jennings spoke to him after filming ended and stated that ‘delivering rulings like that is the least favorite part of his job.’

Shah acknowledged that he trusted the host entirely and mentioned, ‘I felt really disappointed when he explained why he marked me wrong, and I’m not happy with how frustrated I seemed.

‘I wasn’t mad at the judges at all, even though my face may look frustrated.’

He continued: ‘In the post game chat, I remarked that I had a ruling go in my favor in [Champions Wildcard] Semis that was arguably the difference in the game there – Polyharmonic was worth a swing of $4,000.’

With his Jeopardy! journey at an end, the player had nothing but praise about his overall experience.

‘What a long, strange journey it’s been for me. I’m so glad to have met my fellow competitors and the excellent Jeopardy staff,’ he noted. 

Shah continued: ‘Even though I’m leaving in defeat, I feel like I accomplished most of my Jeopardy! related goals that I made before I went on the first time. 

The correct answer was annus horribilus, and Shah was the only contestant who knew the phrase

The correct answer was annus horribilus, and Shah was the only contestant who knew the phrase

However, he put the wrong spelling and due to the fact the typo also removed a syllable from the answer, it was counted as wrong

However, he put the wrong spelling and due to the fact the typo also removed a syllable from the answer, it was counted as wrong

He emphasized his peace about it all as he concluded: ‘So ends this wonderful side quest. 

‘As I rejoin my main plotline, I bring wonderful memories, new allies, a $60 Delcom Buzzer that I will loan to anyone in Seattle who gets the call, and a greater appreciation of the wider world. I wish you all a happy postseason – may all your Daily Doubles be true.’

When the trio of contestants had been heading into Final Jeopardy, Stewart and Mantion were in the lead while Shah trailed behind.

In the category ‘Latin Phrases,’ the Final Jeopardy clue was: ‘After Camillagate, a fire at Windsor Castle & marriage problems in her family, Queen Elizabeth II dubbed 1992 this.’

The correct answer was annus horribilus, and Shah was the only contestant who knew the phrase.

However, he put the wrong spelling and wrote: ‘What is an Annus Horriblis?’   

Due to the fact the typo also removed a syllable from the answer, it was counted as wrong.

Shah had wagered $7,001, which meant if he had remembered the other ‘i’, then he would have been the victor.

Following the airing of the episode, Shah made his way to the Jeopardy! Reddit forum to air his grievances about the painful moment

Following the airing of the episode, Shah made his way to the Jeopardy! Reddit forum to air his grievances about the painful moment

Despite what some might have expected, he supported the show's ruling and wrote: 'The show was 100 percent right to rule the way they did'

Despite what some might have expected, he supported the show’s ruling and wrote: ‘The show was 100 percent right to rule the way they did’

Fans on Reddit had mixed feelings though many shared their understanding about why the answer was ruled incorrect.

Referring to the official rule that an incorrect spelling doesn’t automatically mean an answer is incorrect, one fan explained that it must be ‘phonetically correct and not add or subtract any extraneous sounds or syllables.

‘Leaving out the middle “i” in “horribilis” drops a syllable. The show was correct to rule against Mehal’s response.’

Another  noted: ‘Ugh, one of those “tough but ultimately fair” rulings for the FJ response. I think the debate over this clue is more if it should have been in this ToC or Masters instead.’

You May Also Like
Boston Marathon bomber's widow's suburban life revealed as she steps out with new man on attack anniversary

Widow of Boston Marathon bomber seen living in suburbia with new partner on anniversary of attack

Katherine Russell, the widow of Boston Marathon bomber Tamerlan Tsarnaev, is now…
Wink Martindale, the genial game-show host and an early TV interviewer of Elvis Presley, dies at 91

Wink Martindale, the friendly game-show host who interviewed Elvis Presley on TV, passes away at 91

91-year-old Wink Martindale, the friendly host of popular game shows such as…
Paige DeSorbo Tells Drew Barrymore She Would “Love An Arranged Marriage”

Paige DeSorbo expresses interest in the idea of having an arranged marriage to Drew Barrymore.

The Giggly Squad has finally made its way to The Drew Barrymore…
The normal low-key lives of the Geldof sisters as they shun the spotlight following tragic past and how the family really survived the deaths of their mother Paula Yates and sister Peaches

How the Geldof sisters maintain a low-key life and cope with the tragic losses of their mother Paula Yates and sister Peaches

Last weekend, pregnant Tiger Lily Hutchence ‘secretly tied the knot with her…
DC transit police officer stabbed at train station as Sec. Sean Duffy arrives to talk safety: 'Unacceptable'

Transit Police Officer Stabbed at Train Station During Safety Talk with Sec. Sean Duffy: Unacceptable

Sean Duffy, the U.S. Transportation Secretary, witnessed a violent incident involving a…
ABC7 I-Team helps Midwest Wings Soccer Club get $11K back from abruptly-shuttered Ho-Chunk Southland Center in Lynwood, IL

ABC7 Investigation: Midwest Wings Soccer Club Recovers $11K from Closed Ho-Chunk Southland Center in Lynwood, IL

CHICAGO (WLS) — Coach Bill Dekker is the director of the Midwest…
Graciela Castellanos, accused of drowning daughter in Van Nuys neighborhood in Los Angeles, California, police say

Police in Los Angeles, California, report that Graciela Castellanos is suspected of causing the death of her daughter by drowning in the Van Nuys neighborhood.

VAN NUYS, LOS ANGELES — New details were revealed in the tragic…
Top 8 Garcelle Beauvais Moments From ‘RHOBH’ In Honor Of Her Final Episode

Celebrating Garcelle Beauvais: 8 Memorable Moments from ‘RHOBH’ as She Bids Farewell

It’s a bittersweet moment as Garcelle Beauvais bids farewell in her final…
Florida man accused of killing girlfriend and her mother, dismembering one of the bodies

Florida man charged with murdering his girlfriend and her mother, and cutting up one of the bodies

Authorities report that a man in St. Petersburg, Florida, is facing charges…
Chicago shooting: John Flemister, killed in shootout on Peoria Street in West Loop, remembered as beloved doorman who helped all

Remembering John Flemister: Beloved Doorman Killed in Shootout on Peoria Street in West Loop

CHICAGO (WLS) — A cherished doorman, who tragically lost his life this…
Terrifying look inside US town being overwhelmed by world's most infectious disease

A scary glimpse into a US town struggling with the most contagious disease in the world

In the dusty outskirts of Seminole, Texas — just past the cotton…
OBGYN details shocking impact your sleep schedule has on your period

How Your Sleep Schedule Can Affect Your Period: Insights from an OBGYN

If your menstrual cycle has been irregular or if you’ve been experiencing…