Judge blocks Trump's order banning birthright citizenship despite most Americans backing the move

President Donald TrumpĀ“s executive order terminating the constitutional protection of birthright citizenship was temporarily halted by a federal judge on Thursday, who deemed it ‘blatantly unconstitutional.’

Trump inked the order on his first day in office, declaring it would applyĀ regardless of the parentsĀ“ immigration status.

Despite a Supreme Court precedent over 100 years old upholding birthright citizenship, this order marked Trump’s first executive action to face a legal challenge without the backing of outside groups or multiple states.

U.S. District Judge John C. Coughenour, appointed by Ronald Reagan, made this decision even though nearly half of respondents, 48 percent, expressed support for revoking birthright citizenship, with 26 percent strongly in favor, as per a poll by J.L. Partners for DailyMail.com.

By contrast, 32 percent said they opposed it, 23 percent strongly.

The federal judge ruled in the case brought by the states of Washington, Arizona, Illinois and Oregon, which argue the 14th Amendment and Supreme CourtĀ case law have cemented birthright citizenship.

The delay will put the order on ice until the judge can hear oral argument. But the 84-year-old made his first impression clear, granting a motion assuming the likelihood that plaintiffs will prevail.

‘I have been on the bench for over four decades. I canā€™t remember another case where the case presented is as clear as it is here ā€¦This is a blatantly unconstitutional order,’ he said.

Washington State AG Nick Brown and top law enforcement officers of other Democratic-run states had sought the 14-day stay.Ā 

The case is one of five lawsuits being brought by 22 states and a number of immigrants rights groups across the country. The suits include personal testimonies from attorneys general who are U.S. citizens by birthright, and names pregnant women who are afraid their children wonĀ“t become U.S. citizens.

President Donald Trump signed an order he says would end birthright citizenship for children born to parents who aren’t here legally. It drew an immediate legal challenge

Signed by Trump on Inauguration Day, the order is slated to take effect on Feb. 19. It could impact hundreds of thousands of people born in the country, according to one of the lawsuits. In 2022, there were about 255,000 births of citizen children to mothers living in the country illegally and about 153,000 births to two such parents, according to the four-state suit filed in Seattle.

Even when he signed it, Trump appeared to acknowledge its constitutionality wasn’t certain.

‘We think we have good ground,’ he said when asked about it would withstand constitutional challenge while inking the order in a marathon signing session Monday night shortly after taking office. ‘You could be right. We’ll find out,’ Trump said.

The U.S. is among about 30 countries where birthright citizenship – the principle of jus soli or ‘right of the soil’ – is applied. Most are in the Americas, and Canada and Mexico are among them.

The lawsuits argue that the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution guarantees citizenship for people born and naturalized in the U.S., and states have been interpreting the amendment that way for a century.

The Supreme Court ruled in 1898 that children born to foreign parents inside the U.S. are citizens, citing the 14th Amendment.

The post-Civil War amendment states that ‘All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside.’

Mexican migrants, Laura Elizabeth and her son Matias keep warm by a fire while waiting to be apprehended by U.S. Customs and Border Patrol officers after crossing over a section of border wall into the U.S. on January 05, 2025 in Ruby, Arizona

Mexican migrants, Laura Elizabeth and her son Matias keep warm by a fire while waiting to be apprehended by U.S. Customs and Border Patrol officers after crossing over a section of border wall into the U.S. on January 05, 2025 in Ruby, Arizona

Under the 14th Amendment all persons 'born or naturalized in the United States' are citizens

Under the 14th Amendment all persons ‘born or naturalized in the United States’ are citizens

Trump’s order asserts that the children of noncitizens are not subject to the jurisdiction of the United States, and orders federal agencies to not recognize citizenship for children who don’t have at least one parent who is a citizen.

A key case involving birthright citizenship unfolded in 1898. The Supreme Court held that Wong Kim Ark, who was born in San Francisco to Chinese immigrants, was a U.S. citizen because he was born in the country. After a trip abroad, he faced being denied reentry by the federal government on the grounds that he wasnĀ“t a citizen under the Chinese Exclusion Act.

But some advocates of immigration restrictions have argued that case clearly applied to children born to parents who were both legal immigrants. They say it’s less clear whether it applies to children born to parents living in the country illegally.

TrumpĀ“s executive order prompted attorneys general to share their personal connections to birthright citizenship. Connecticut Attorney General William Tong, for instance, a U.S. citizen by birthright and the nationĀ“s first Chinese American elected attorney general, said the lawsuit was personal for him.

‘There is no legitimate legal debate on this question. But the fact that Trump is dead wrong will not prevent him from inflicting serious harm right now on American families like my own,’ Tong said this week.

One of the lawsuits aimed at blocking the executive order includes the case of a pregnant woman, identified as ‘Carmen,’ who is not a citizen but has lived in the United States for more than 15 years and has a pending visa application that could lead to permanent residency status.

‘Stripping children of the `priceless treasureĀ“ of citizenship is a grave injury,’ the suit says. ‘It denies them the full membership in U.S. society to which they are entitled.’

You May Also Like
Pope Francis rebukes Trump administration over migrant deportations, warns 'it will end badly'

“Pope Francis Criticizes Trump Administration for Migrant Deportations, Cautions of Negative Consequences”

ROME — In a significant statement, Pope Francis criticized the Trump administration’s…
American teacher Marc Fogel freed from Russia, White House says

The White House announces that American educator Marc Fogel has been released from Russian custody.

An American teacher named Marc Fogel, who was wrongly held in Russia,…
Israel slams Palestinian 'deception scheme' over claim it halted terror rewards program

Israel criticizes Palestinians for alleged deceit in ending program that rewards terrorists

JERUSALEMā€”The president of the Palestinian Authority (PA) has reportedly given in to…
Kanye West's Yeezy website goes DOWN after fierce backlash to star promoting 'vile' swastika T-shirts during the Super Bowl

Yeezy website crashes due to backlash over Kanye West promoting controversial swastika T-shirts during the Super Bowl

Kanye West’s website has gone down amid fierce backlash to the rapper…
ā€˜Itā€™s Always Sunny in Philadelphiaā€™ EP Megan Ganz Says The Gang Is Going Crazy After the Eagles Super Bowl Win: ā€œAt Least One Of Them Is Probably In Jail For Punching A Police Horseā€

“After Eagles Super Bowl Win, One ‘Itā€™s Always Sunny in Philadelphia’ EP Reveals The Gang’s Wild Reaction”

Following the Philadelphia Eaglesā€™ impressive victory against the Kansas City Chiefs in…
Trump says ceasefire deal should be canceled if Hamas doesn't release all hostages by Saturday

Trump calls for cancellation of ceasefire deal if Hamas fails to release all hostages by Saturday

JERUSALEM (AP) – — President Donald Trump stated that the ceasefire agreement…
Danes launch petition to buy California, turn Disney into 'Hans Christian Andersenland'

Danes start petition to purchase California, transforming Disney into ‘Hans Christian Andersenland’

There is a petition gaining support for a proposal to buy California…
Brother of Parkland shooter arrested in Virginia for allegedly trespassing at three schools

Brother of the Parkland Shooter Arrested in Virginia for Allegedly Entering Three Schools without Permission

The brother of the Parkland gunman Nikolas Cruz was arrested last week…
New Jersey driver awarded $13M after state troopers mistakenly believed her stroke was sign of intoxication

New Jersey Driver Wins $13 Million Settlement Following Misunderstanding of Stroke as Intoxication

A driver from New Jersey received an almost $13 million settlement after…
Turks and Caicos shooting: Funeral to be held Tuesday for Cook County Deputy Shamone Duncan

Cook County Deputy Shamone Duncan’s Funeral Set for Tuesday Following Turks and Caicos Shooting

CHICAGO (WLS) — Tuesday is the funeral for a Cook County Sheriff’s…
FBI Officials File Class Action Lawsuit Against Trump's DOJ To Block Identification Of Agents Led January 6, Mar-a-Lago Investigations

FBI Officials Sue Trump’s DOJ in Group Lawsuit to Stop Revealing Agents in January 6 and Mar-a-Lago Probes

Last Updated on February 10, 2025 Two groups of FBI agents have…
R.I.P. Peter Navy Tuiasosopo: ā€˜NCIS,ā€™ ā€˜Street Fighterā€™ Actor Dead At 61

Actor from ‘NCIS’ and ‘Street Fighter,’ Peter Navy Tuiasosopo, passes away at age 61

Veteran television and film star Peter Navy Tuiasosopo, known for Street Fighter…