Karen Read jury selection: Dozens in pool already have an opinion on the case

Jury selection began on Tuesday for the second trial of Karen Read, who is facing charges of murder and other offenses for an alleged hit-and-run incident that resulted in the death of her boyfriend, Boston Police Officer John O’Keefe, during a blizzard in January 2022.

The 45-year-old’s first trial ended with a hung jury, and the judge later rejected multiple requests to dismiss the case.

This time around, nearly half of the first group of potential jurors told the judge they already have an opinion on the case.

Cannone on Monday ruled that Read’s defense cannot try and blame Albert’s nephew, Colin Albert, for the crime. 

A close-up of Karen Read smiling next to John O'Keefe wearing a white backwards hat.

Karen Read and John O’Keefe pose for an undated photograph. (Karen Read)

The defense has proposed other potential third-party suspects, including Brian Albert and ATF Agent Brian Higgins, both of whom were present at the bar and subsequent gathering.

According to the judge, the defense is not allowed to mention these individuals during the opening statements. However, they are permitted to present evidence during the trial that they believe implicates these individuals instead of Read.

Brian Albert wears a blue shirt, yellow tie and dark jacket on the witness stand

Witness Brian Albert testifies during the first trial of Karen Read at Norfolk County Superior Court, Friday, May 10, 2024, in Dedham, Mass.  (AP Photo/Charles Krupa, Pool)

Cannone also sided with prosecutors and blocked testimony from a former FBI agent named Michael Easter, who was expected to scrutinize alleged missteps from police in the investigation.

The lead investigator, former Massachusetts State Trooper Michael Proctor, was fired last month after an investigation into lewd text messages he sent about Read while probing O’Keefe’s death, which were read in court during her first trial.

Although he is no longer a trooper, his name is on the witness list the second time around – along with 149 other people. 

You May Also Like
Former DC teacher arrested, charged with soliciting child pornography: DOJ

DC Teacher Arrested and Charged with Soliciting Child Pornography, According to DOJ

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! A former schoolteacher from…
Ukraine Conflict Escalation and U.S. Involvement

Increased Tensions in Ukraine and the Role of the U.S.

Last Updated on June 3, 2025 Steve Bannon, former White House chief…
Boulder suspect spent a year planning Molotov cocktail attack on pro-Israel march: docs

Documents show Boulder suspect plotted Molotov cocktail attack on pro-Israel march for a year

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! Court documents have revealed…
Milwaukee man accused of framing illegal immigrant in Trump assassination threat, officials say

Official reports claim a Milwaukee man framed an illegal immigrant in a threat to assassinate Trump

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! A man in Milwaukee…
ICE raid Chicago: Video shows 2 men arrested at 18th and Carpenter Street in Pilsen, FBI and Chicago police confirm

Chicago ICE raid caught on video: 2 men taken into custody at 18th and Carpenter Street in Pilsen, confirmed by FBI and Chicago police

CHICAGO (WLS) — Two men were arrested in Chicago’s Southwest Side by…
Mount Etna news: Volcanic activity in Sicily erupts in a fiery show of smoke and ash miles high

Breaking News: Mount Etna in Sicily erupts with high columns of smoke and ash

MILAN — Sicily’s Mount Etna put on a fiery show Monday, sending…
FX's new show 'Adults' follows five friends living together and tackling adulthood with a hilarious twist

The TV series “Adults” on FX portrays the lives of five buddies facing the challenges of growing up while adding humor to the mix

FX’s new series, “Adults,” explores the humorous adventures of a group of…
Olympic gymnast Mary Lou Retton's family issue deeply worrying update after her humiliating arrest

Mary Lou Retton’s family expresses concern after her embarrassing arrest at the Olympics

There are concerns for the safety of Mary Lou Retton, a US…
Blake Lively makes shock move and drops 'intentional infliction of emotional distress' claim against Justin Baldoni

Blake Lively surprises everyone by deciding to withdraw her claim of ‘intentionally causing emotional harm’ against Justin Baldoni

Blake Lively has made the decision to retract her accusation that Justin…
SCOTT JENNINGS: The despicable truth about the explosion of terrorism in America... that liberals will never dare say

The harsh reality of the rise of terrorism in America that liberals avoid discussing

In the midst of the Left’s exaggerated outcry over perceived fascism, totalitarianism,…
Escaped zebra caught on camera running along busy Tennessee roadway as chaos forces lane closures

Zebra on the loose filmed running on crowded road in Tennessee causing lane closures

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! A zebra remains on…
Inside the group making conservatives 'cool'... as they take down woke 'bulls**t' and stand up for working Americans

Exploring the group that aims to make conservatives appealing by challenging woke culture and supporting the working class

In Washington, D.C., a youthful conservative group is marking a significant achievement…