Karen Read defense floats theory that ‘jealous’ Brian Higgins fought John O’Keefe before death

Officer John O’Keefe poses for his official headshot

John O’Keefe (Boston Police Department)

Jackson also shared a video that purportedly shows Brian Higgins visiting the Canton Police Department headquarters approximately an hour after the reported time of O’Keefe’s death.

The surveillance footage captures Higgins in the company of a group of individuals at the Waterfall Bar and Grille, where Read and O’Keefe were also present on January 28. Higgins then attended an after-party at 34 Fairview Road, a residence owned by another Boston police officer named Brian Albert.

O’Keefe was discovered dead outside the following morning.

During the trial, several witnesses provided testimony indicating that they overheard Read repeatedly uttering the words, “I hit him,” on the morning when Read, along with two former acquaintances, discovered O’Keefe’s lifeless body buried under a pile of snow on Albert’s property.

Karen Read in court for a retrial for the death of John O’Keefe.

Karen Read sits with her defense team during her trial, May 8, 2025, in Dedham, Mass. (Charles Krupa/AP Pool)

After sending jurors to lunch Monday, Cannone held a quick voir dire hearing and ultimately said she would not allow Jackson to question Bukhenik about what he knew about the relationship between Proctor and relatives of Albert, including one of his brothers, Chris, who was also at the Waterfall on Jan. 28.

Read could face up to life in prison if convicted of the top charge, second-degree murder. She is also accused of manslaughter and leaving the scene of a deadly accident. 

Police have not accused Higgins of a crime, and prosecutors say Read is the only suspect in O’Keefe’s death.

You May Also Like
4th round of US-Iran talks ends as Trump set to embark on historic Middle East tour

US and Iran conclude 4th round of talks while Trump prepares for important trip to the Middle East

JERUSALEM—With President Donald Trump set to leave for the Middle East on…
Can Pope Leo's Dolton, Illinois roots help rebrand village after controversy surrounding former Mayor Tiffany Henyard's tenure?

Could Pope Leo’s connection to Dolton, Illinois assist in reshaping the village’s image following issues with ex-Mayor Tiffany Henyard?

DOLTON, Ill. (WLS) — From brawls to blessings, it has been quite…
Brooklyn no longer sees his old friends and 'does whatever Nicola Peltz asks', insiders tell KATIE HIND, as they reveal how David and Victoria are horrified at their daughter-in-law's 'plans' for their son and the Beckham name

Inside Sources Share Concerns about Brooklyn Beckham’s Changed Behavior and Allegiance to Nicola Peltz, Causing Upset for David and Victoria Beckham

Just a few months following their lavish £3 million wedding ceremony, Brooklyn…
Trailblazing director Ron OJ Parson talks 'Hymn' at Chicago Shakespeare Theater on Navy Pier

Director Ron OJ Parson discusses ‘Hymn’ at Chicago Shakespeare Theater on Navy Pier

CHICAGO (WLS) — Ron OJ Parson is best known for his trailblazing…
Remains found in Syria do not include those of Austin Tice, family says

Family states that remains found in Syria do not belong to Austin Tice

The family of Austin Tice, a journalist and a veteran of the…
‘Heart Eyes’ Ending Explained: Who Is the Killer?

Understanding the Conclusion of ‘Heart Eyes’: Revealing the Identity of the Murderer

If love has left you with emotional scars, take solace in knowing…
Jayden Perkins death: Murder trial continues for Crosetti Brand; boy killed in Edgewater stabbing that injured pregnant mother

Continuation of Murder Trial for Crosetti Brand in the Death of Jayden Perkins, a Boy Killed in Edgewater Stabbing that also Injured Pregnant Mother

CHICAGO (WLS) — The trial of a Chicago man accused of killing…
Stephen A. Smith Hits Back at Barkley's Dig at His Presidential Aspirations: ‘I Believe I Could Win’

Stephen A. Smith responds to Barkley’s criticism of his ambition to become president: ‘I think I have what it takes to win’

The conversation started when Barkley was a guest on OutKick’s “Don’t @…
Florida State University alleged mass shooter appears in mugshot with disfigured face after hospital release

Florida State University Accused Gunman Revealed in Mugshot with Altered Appearance Following Hospital Discharge

Phoenix Ikner, the alleged shooter at Florida State University, displayed a disfigured…
Dr. Carla Hayden, Librarian of Congress, fired by Donald Trump administration; Todd Blanche named interim Library of Congress head

Donald Trump administration dismissed Dr. Carla Hayden, the Librarian of Congress; Todd Blanche appointed as the temporary head of Library of Congress

Dr. Carla Hayden, a prominent leader of color, has become a target…
Trump says he'll set 30-day deadline for drugmakers to lower the cost of prescription drugs

Trump plans to give drug companies a 30-day limit to reduce prescription drug prices

President Donald Trump said he will set a 30-day deadline for drugmakers…
American hostage Edan Alexander released by Hamas after more than 580 days in captivity

Hamas releases American captive Edan Alexander after over 580 days

Hamas released the last living American hostage Monday, after he spent more…