Karen Read judge sued over 'buffer zone' keeping protesters away from courthouse

Four protesters have filed a lawsuit against Judge Beverly Cannone concerning a “buffer zone” that they argue unfairly distances them from the courthouse where Karen Read’s retrial for murder and other charges is taking place in Massachusetts.

The lawsuit claims that Judge Cannone implemented the order primarily to suppress criticism aimed at her, citing that the only documented protests have been conducted by the plaintiffs holding signs criticizing her.

These plaintiffs, Jason Grant, Allyson Taggart, Lisa Peterson, and Samantha Lyons, are residents of Massachusetts. The legal action also includes Geoffrey Noble, the superintendent of the state police, and Michael d’Entremont, the police chief in Dedham, where the courthouse is situated.

In their lawsuit, they are asking a federal court to declare the “buffer zone” an unconstitutional “prior restraint” on free speech and an injunction, plus legal fees.

Karen Read giving John O'Keefe a kiss on the side of his head.

Karen Read giving John O’Keefe a kiss on the side of his head in an undated photograph. (Courtesy of Karen Read)

Read is charged with second-degree murder, manslaughter and leaving the scene of a deadly accident. She could face up to life in prison if convicted of the top charge.

Read denied the charges, pleaded not guilty and claimed that she is being framed as part of a police cover-up.

Officer John O’Keefe poses for his official headshot

Officer John O’Keefe poses for his official headshot. O’Keefe’s girlfriend, Karen Reed, is currently on trial for a second time on murder and other charges after he was found dead outside of a Massachusetts home in January 2022. (Boston Police Department)

Cannone warned potential jurors at the start of jury selection Tuesday not to be influenced by protesters outside.

Critics of Karen Read with signs

Critics of Karen Read gather outside the courthouse in Dedham, MA on Friday, June 28, 2024. Read is facing three charges, including second-degree murder of her Boston police officer boyfriend John O’Keefe in January 2022. (Patriot Pics/Backgrid for Fox News Digital)

“John Adams said that we are a government of laws, not of men, and that the law must be deaf to the clamoring of the public,” she said, referring to the Founding Father with deep Boston roots.

“He meant that while the public opinion about a given subject may ebb and flow, the law must be steady, reliable, and even-handed.”

You May Also Like
Teen accused of killing New Jersey police officer to be charged as adult, new US attorney says

New US attorney announces that teenager charged with murder of New Jersey police officer will face adult charges

The acting U.S. Attorney for New Jersey, Alina Habba, has declared that…
Trump's Treasury Secretary issues blistering six-word warning to countries threatening tariff revenge

The US Treasury Secretary warns countries considering retaliatory tariffs in a fierce six-word statement.

Scott Bessent, the Treasury Secretary, cautioned other countries against taking hasty actions…
Illinois homeschool bill would create a 'pipeline to the criminal justice system for parents': Dem lawmaker

Democratic lawmaker claims Illinois homeschool legislation could lead to parents being funneled into the criminal justice system.

A proposed legislation in Illinois has the potential to bring about significant…
GM will dramatically increase car production in US after Trump tariffs

General Motors (GM) to significantly boost car manufacturing in the United States following implementation of Trump’s tariffs

General Motors on Thursday announced it will dramatically increase vehicle production in…
Ex-Duke football murder suspect keeps returning home after arrests thanks to soft-on-crime judges: police rep

Former Duke football player repeatedly arrested and released due to lenient judges, says police representative

An ex-Duke University football player is said to have admitted to killing…
Hootie and the Blowfish fans stunned to learn the true meaning of the band's iconic name

Fans of Hootie and the Blowfish surprised by discovery of band’s iconic name’s real significance

During a night of revelry at university in the mid-1980s, Hootie and…
What Time Is ‘Doctor Odyssey’ On Tonight? How To Watch Ava Phillippe, Paris Jackson, And Charlotte Lawrence’s New Episode

When Does ‘Doctor Odyssey’ Air Tonight? Ways to Watch the Latest Episode Starring Ava Phillippe, Paris Jackson, and Charlotte Lawrence

Time to set sail for another episode of Doctor Odyssey, this time…
'Elon Derangement Syndrome' Gets Taken Up a Notch As Leftists Launch Site Targeting Tesla Owners

“DNC Chairman’s Remarks Spark Concerns Over Potential Violence Towards Tesla”

Approaching the three-month mark since the formation of the Department of Government…
Job cuts were up 205% in March 2025; most came from the federal government, report by Challenger, Gray and Christmas

March 2025 Sees Surge in Job Layoffs with Federal Government Leading the Way, According to Challenger, Gray and Christmas Report

CHICAGO (WLS) — The number of jobs cut in March was up…
National Burrito Day 2025: How to score free food from Chipotle, QDOBA, Moe's, and more

How to get free food from Chipotle, QDOBA, Moe’s, and other restaurants on National Burrito Day 2025

Fans nationwide can celebrate National Burrito Day at one of several beloved…
Georgia and Alabama suspects make plea in sextortion scam that led to suicide of Michigan teen

Suspects from Georgia and Alabama plea in sextortion case linked to suicide of Michigan teenager

This article addresses the topic of suicide. If you or someone you…
Lithuanians bid farewell to 4 US soldiers who died during training exercise

Lithuanians pay their respects to 4 US soldiers who lost their lives during a training exercise

VILNIUS, Lithuania — Thousands of people in Lithuania, including political and religious…