Luigi Mangione makes a bold legal play as he hires powerhouse ex-DA who knows 'every judge' in NY

Luigi Mangione has taken on a powerful New York attorney to represent him as he faces charges over Brian Thompson’s death.  

Accused of fatally shooting high-ranking individuals on the streets of New York City, the murder suspect has gained national attention since authorities apprehended him following a five-day evasion from the police.

Recent developments indicate that he is swapping his previous lawyer, Thomas Dickey, for Karen Friedman Agnifilo, a former assistant district attorney renowned for her involvement in prosecuting the Harvey Weinstein case in New York.

Regarded as a seasoned professional in the New York state court system, one source revealed to CNN that Friedman Agnifilo is extensively familiar with the courthouse, knowing every judge, clerk, and corridor within.

‘She’s got as much experience as any human being, especially in the state court.’ 

CNN had previously employed Friedman Agnifilo as a legal analyst. 

Friedman Agnifilo left Cyrus Vance Jr.’s Manhattan DA office after seven years in 2021 to go and work in private practice, including at Geragos & Geragos, the high-powered LA firm that currently represents the Menendez brothers. 

She studied political science and government before getting her Law degree at Georgetown. 

Luigi Mangione is hiring a powerful New York attorney Karen Friedman Agnifilo to represent him as he faces murder charges for being the alleged assassin of the UnitedHealthcare CEO

Luigi Mangione is hiring a powerful New York attorney Karen Friedman Agnifilo to represent him as he faces murder charges for being the alleged assassin of the UnitedHealthcare CEO

The accused killer of top brass Brian Thompson, who was shot dead in the streets of New York City, captivated the country after he was captured by authorities following a five-day run from police

The accused killer of top brass Brian Thompson, who was shot dead in the streets of New York City, captivated the country after he was captured by authorities following a five-day run from police

Friedman Agnifilo also co-hosts a podcast called MissTrial, with former New York Congresswoman Kathleen Rice and ex-federal prosecutor E. Danya Perry. 

It comes as multiple crowdfunding attempts have been made to raise money for his defense, according to ABC News. 

Mangione, 26, has been accused of killing UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, 50, outside of a New York City hotel on December 4.

He was arrested in Pennsylvania on firearms charges and had an actioned-packed day in court Tuesday fighting extradition to the Big Apple.

While Mangione is working to extend his stay in the Keystone State, New York officials are hoping to get him back with what is called a governor’s warrant.  

It’s a warrant signed by the governor of a state where a fugitive flees after a crime. The governor in that state acts upon an official request from the governor of the state where the crime occurred.

In this case, New York Gov. Kathy Hochul is expected to seek a governor’s warrant from Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro, but the process could take more than a month.

On Wednesday, New York City Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch said police have matched a gun found on Mangione with the shell casings recovered at the scene and his fingerprints with a water bottle and energy bar wrapper found nearby.

Friedman Agnifilo (pictured right) is a former assistant district attorney who helped prosecute the Harvey Weinstein case in New York

Friedman Agnifilo (pictured right) is a former assistant district attorney who helped prosecute the Harvey Weinstein case in New York

UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson was shot and killed outside Manhattan's Hilton Hotel

UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson was shot and killed outside Manhattan’s Hilton Hotel 

Other evidence includes handwritten documents found in his possession casting his alleged crime as a legitimate response to what he viewed as corporate greed, some media outlets have reported.

Mangione lashed out himself on Tuesday as he was led into a courthouse, shouting in part, ‘…completely out of touch and an insult to the intelligence of the American people!’

The former Ivy League student had been apprehended with a 3D-printed pistol and black silencer, as well as a manifesto condemning the American healthcare system.

Mangione also had a spiral notebook in which he wrote a ‘to-do list,’ ahead of the grizzly shooting, CNN reported.

In it, he allegedly toyed with the idea of using a bomb to kill Thompson – but he decided against the prospect because it ‘could kill innocents,’ and determined a shooting would be more targeted.

He also reportedly mused that it couldn’t get any better than ‘to kill the CEO at his own bean-counting conference,’ as Thompson was set to disclose the financial gains the company made this year.

Authorities have said Mangione’s three-page manifesto is currently being investigated, which they have labeled a ‘claim of responsibility.’

The document is a different piece of evidence from notebook – where he flirted with the idea of bombing Midtown to kill the millionaire healthcare boss.

Surveillance camera footage showed the gunman, suspected to be Mangione, shooting UnitedHealthCare CEO Brian Thompson at point blank range outside of a Hilton hotel in midtown Manhattan on December 4

Surveillance camera footage showed the gunman, suspected to be Mangione, shooting UnitedHealthCare CEO Brian Thompson at point blank range outside of a Hilton hotel in midtown Manhattan on December 4

In the manifesto, Mangione allegedly wrote about the grandiose size of UnitedHealthcare and how much profits it makes, and went on to condemn health insurance companies more broadly for placing profits over care.

Details about his writing come amid the backdrop of the UPenn graduate’s own experience with the medical world, as he had been struggling after a spinal injury. His elaborate online presence also showed he’d read multiple books on back pain.

‘To save you a lengthy investigation, I state plainly that I wasn’t working with anyone. This was fairly trivial: some elementary social engineering, basic CAD, [and] a lot of patience,’ he allegedly wrote in the manifesto, according to the Daily Beast.

He went on to say he had ‘respect’ for federal investigators, and apologized for causing any ‘traumas,’ but seemed to defend his alleged actions.

‘Frankly these parasites had it coming,’ the manifesto wrote.

It claimed that the United States had the ‘most expensive healthcare system in the world,’ but blasted the system for making America only the 42nd in life expectancy.

You May Also Like
WNBA news: Chicago Sky host Indiana Fever for first-ever women's basketball game at United Center

Chicago Sky to host Indiana Fever in historic women’s basketball game at United Center

CHICAGO — The Chicago Sky are hosting the Indiana Fever Saturday for…
Gory details of Elon Musk's 'rugby tackle' of Scott Bessent spill out as White House leaks escalate

Elon Musk’s aggressive behavior towards Scott Bessent revealed as White House leaks increase

Fresh information has emerged about a scuffle that occurred at the White…
Tony Awards 2025 WORST dressed list: Katie Holmes and Cynthia Erivo hit red carpet in bizarre looks

Worst Dressed List at the 2025 Tony Awards: Katie Holmes and Cynthia Erivo Turn Heads in Unusual Outfits

The 2025 Tony Awards are full of eye-catching outfits, from extravagant feathers…
RedState Weekly Briefing: Drone Attacks, Dem Witness Implosions, and Media Malpractice

Weekly Recap: Drone Strikes, Democratic Witnesses in Turmoil, and Media Misconduct

Welcome to the RedState Weekly Briefing. Here, we summarize the most popular…
Chris Evans Says He Proposed to Wife Alba Baptista in Portuguese: “I Had Practiced All Week”

Chris Evans Reveals He Asked Alba Baptista to Marry Him in Portuguese After Preparation.

Captain America himself just proved he’s a real-life romantic hero. Chris Evans…
How radical California mayor's ingenious move to 'purge' homeless puts liberal hellholes to shame

California mayor’s innovative strategy to remove homeless people stirs controversy in progressive cities

Mayor Rex Parris proudly spoke about the cleanliness of his city’s homeless…
Runaway pet zebra named Ed captured, airlifted home to Rutherford County, Tennessee, police say

Ed, the runaway pet zebra, captured and airlifted home to Rutherford County, Tennessee by police

In Murfreesboro, Tennessee, a runaway pet zebra that had been loose for…
Trump Slams ‘Incompetent’ Newsom and Bass, Says Violent Protesters Will Be Banned From Wearing Masks

Trump Criticizes Newsom and Bass, Promises to Prohibit Mask-Wearing by Violent Protesters

President Trump has recently commended the National Guard for their efforts in…
LA ICE raid protests: California National Guard arrive in Los Angeles on Donald Trump's orders to quell immigration protests

California National Guard dispatched to Los Angeles amid ICE raid protests following President Trump’s orders

LOS ANGELES — The National Guard troops have arrived in Los Angeles…
Donald Trump arrives at UFC 316 with one-man entourage Dana White months after sitting cageside with Elon Musk

“A Night to Remember: Donald Trump Attends UFC 316 with Dana White as Sole Companion”

President Donald Trump was the guest of honor at UFC 316 in…
US–Russia flashpoint looms over Putin's plans for African naval base

“Putin Increases Focus on Security of ‘Ghost Fleet’ as NATO Conducts War Games in the Baltic Sea”

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! NATO navies are currently…
Our Chicago: Impact of planned U.S. Steel, Nippon Steel deal on Gary, Indiana plant and Midwest

Impact of U.S. Steel and Nippon Steel deal on Gary, Indiana plant and the Midwest

CHICAGO (WLS) — President Donald Trump recently announced a partnership between U.S.…