Boston lawyer found dead on houseboat as mystery woman faces murder charge

A 24-year-old woman accused of knifing a 65-year-old Boston lawyer to death on his houseboat before taking measures to dump his body out at sea found her protests drowned out in the courtroom during her arraignment Friday morning.

Joseph Donohue suffered multiple stab wounds before police found him around 11 p.m. Sunday wrapped up on his vessel after his son asked for a wellness check at a marine in Charlestown, according to authorities.

Suspect Nora Nelson, who appeared in court wearing white sweats and shackles, answered his door when officers arrived, Assistant District Attorney Rita Muse told the court during the hearing.

“When asked about Mr. Donohue’s whereabouts, she was evasive and unresponsive,” Muse said. “Her statements were contradictory, and frankly, she lied.”

Nora Nelson argues with a court officer

Murder suspect Nora Nelson, 24, is spoken to by a Boston bailiff after she repeatedly tried to speak up in court at her arraignment in the stabbing death of 65-year-old attorney Joseph Donohue. (WFXT)

Police arrested her at the scene on unrelated warrants. She was formally charged with Donohue’s murder Thursday after an autopsy found his cause and manner of death to be a homicide by stabbing. 

Without going into specifics, Muse told the judge that forensic evidence recovered from Donohue’s remains linked Nelson to the crime.

The defendant, who had her eyes turned downward as Muse spoke, appeared to wipe a tear from her eyes when the prosecutor told the judge there was probable cause to believe she had murdered Donohue.

Defense attorney Ian Davis asked for time to review discovery before filing a potential bail request. 

houseboat google maps

A Google Maps image shows several houseboats and yachts at the Boston marina where 65-year-old Joseph Donohue was found dead on his vessel Sunday. (Google Maps)

The court entered a not guilty plea on Nelson’s behalf before the judge granted the prosecution’s request to have her held without bail, prompting the defendant to speak up.

“No one ever told me that this –” Nelson began, before her voice was drowned out by others in the courtroom trying to cut her off. “This is the first time I’ve ever heard this –.”

She is due back in court on March 6.

The investigation is ongoing and Boston police are asking anyone with information on the case to call homicide detectives at 617-343-4470.

Donohue’s connection to his suspected killer was not immediately clear. Public records show he lived on the houseboat and has been licensed to practice law since the 1980s.

You May Also Like
Jewelers reveal staggering cost of 'engagement' ring Bill Belichick, 72, gave girlfriend Jordon Hudson, 24

How much did Bill Belichick’s engagement ring for his 24-year-old girlfriend really cost? Jewelers spill the beans

Bill Belichick and his girlfriend Jordon Hudson sparked rumors of an engagement…
Southern California Edison's equipment may have started major wildfire: CEO

Potential Blaze Originates from Southern California Edison Equipment, CEO Says

Southern California Edison, a power provider for about 15 million Californians, has…
Idaho murders suspect Bryan Kohberger’s mental health records given to prosecutors as he fights death penalty

Prosecutors receive mental health records of Idaho murder suspect Bryan Kohberger in death penalty case

Medical and mental health records for Bryan Kohberger, the suspect in a…
Anna Kendrick's 'secret feud' with Blake Lively as they clash over Another Simple Favor billing

Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively reportedly have a feud over billing for Another Simple Favor

According to insiders, Anna Kendrick is upset with Blake Lively for not…
‘Apple Cider Vinegar’s Grossest Scam? Black Salve

Is Apple Cider Vinegar’s Biggest Scam? Exploring Black Salve

Netflix’s Apple Cider Vinegar is a show designed to ultimately disgust you.…
Brian Jordan Alvarez's 'English Teacher' renewed for season 2 by FX

FX Renews Brian Jordan Alvarez’s Show ‘English Teacher’ for Second Season

HOLLYWOOD — “English Teacher” follows the life of a gay high school…
‘Selling The City’s Justin Tuinstra Says There Was No Awkwardness After Taking Eleonora Srugo’s Virgnity For The Second Time

“Selling The City’s Justin Tuinstra Shares How Comfortable It Was Reconnecting With Eleonora Srugo Intimately for the Second Time”

Just a little over a month ago, the show Selling the City…
Dark criminal past of 'Bourbon Street hustler' Danette Colbert linked to Super Bowl reporter's death

Historical criminal background of Danette Colbert from Bourbon Street connected to the demise of Super Bowl journalist.

The woman allegedly caught using a dead Super Bowl reporter’s credit cards…
Pushback possible as Chicago Council Finance Committee set to vote on Dexter Reed CPD shooting civil rights lawsuit settlement

Chicago Council Finance Committee to vote on Dexter Reed CPD shooting civil rights lawsuit settlement, potential resistance anticipated

In Chicago (WLS) — Before the Chicago City Council’s Finance Committee votes…
Moon grand canyons: Asteroid strike billions of years ago carved out 2 massive gorges, good news for NASA's next lunar mission

Ancient Asteroid Impact Created Huge Gorges on the Moon, Beneficial for NASA’s Future Moon Exploration

CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. — New research shows that when an asteroid slammed…
Critics Choice Awards 2025 red carpet: See all the celebrity looks

Discover the celebrity fashion at the 2025 Critics Choice Awards red carpet

In 2025, the Critics Choice Awards took place on Friday at the…
Parents of teacher found dead with 20 stab wounds offer theory on how she died after 'suicide' ruling reversed

Parents Seek Justice for Teacher Found Dead with 20 Stab Wounds: Dispute Suicide Ruling’s Reversal

After 14 years, the City of Philadelphia will reexamine the case of…