Elgin cold case: Car linked to missing woman Karen Schepers unknowingly found in Fox River by fire crews in 2022, not recovered

ELGIN, Ill. (WLS) — The recovery of a vehicle from the Fox River this week has been linked to the 1983 cold case of missing woman Karen Schepers. The vehicle was initially discovered in 2022 but was not retrieved at that time, officials revealed on Thursday.

The video in the player above is from a previous report.

A person was fishing in 2022 when they located the vehicle and reported it to authorities.

Elgin fire crews responded to the scene.

“The dive team noticed what seemed to be a small vehicle submerged in the water,” a section of a news release from the Elgin police stated. “A diver went into the river and touched a tire. The small size of the tire caused the diver to assume prematurely that the object in the water was likely an ATV (all-terrain vehicle) or UTV (utility-task vehicle). No further action was taken.

Elgin police were only made aware of the fire department’s 2022 operation after the successful extraction of the vehicle this week.

Elgin police and fire officials issued an apology Thursday after the new development.

“After a thorough review, I have come to the conclusion that more steps should have been taken in 2022, including a detailed underwater inspection of the vehicle,” a comment from Elgin Fire Chief Robb Cagann mentioned.

This is a breaking news update. The following is from a previous report.

Skeletal human remains have been found inside a car linked to a decades-old cold case, the Kane County coroner confirmed on Tuesday evening.

Chopper 7 was over the scene as crews removed the 1980 canary yellow Toyota Celica from the Fox River on Tuesday just before 3 p.m. following hours of work.

Search teams with a nonprofit group called the Chaos Divers found the car, believed to have been submerged for 42 years, near the Slade Avenue boat launch on Monday.

“I want to stress that this is an extensive recovery process and it is expected to take some time ensuring the structural integrity of the vehicle remains intact,” said Elgin Police Chief Ana Lalley.

Chopper 7 was over the scene as crews removed a car connected to a decades-old cold case from the Fox River on Tuesday.

A license plate match made during Monday’s initial search confirmed investigators’ suspicions. It belonged to Karen Schepers, an Elgin woman who disappeared more than 40 years ago.

Karen was 23 years old when she was last seen attending a party with coworkers at a bar in Carpentersville in the early hours of April 16, 1983. Neither Karen nor her 1980 Toyota Celica were seen again, until now.

“We were pushing against a brick wall for 42 years, and now, it’s starting to give,” said Gary Schepers, one of Karen’s eight siblings.

Gary spoke with ABC7 over the phone on Tuesday, after crews recovered Karen’s car.

“It adds questions more than it answers them,” Gary said. “The only search I know of that was done in 1983 was my dad, who was an airline pilot, rented a plane and flew over the area, hoping he could spot her yellow car.”

But police said Karen’s car was not easily seen from above. Instead, all this time, it was submerged in the Fox River. ABC7’s news partners at the Daily Herald shared photos of the teams using sonar technology to locate the now-faded vehicle.

“I wish they looked in the river and found her car 42 years ago,” Gary said.

Gary and other family members are now left wanting to know how the car ended up in the river and whether the human remains found inside are Karen’s.

Elgin police said the next steps will be to compare Karen’s DNA samples or dental records to the remains located in the vehicle. This process could take up to several weeks.

This all comes after the cold case was revived early this year in a podcast launched by the Elgin Police Department called Somebody Knows Something.

Elgin police chief gives an update after a car belonging to a missing woman from 1983 was found in the Fox River.

“We’re hoping to use this podcast to help the family understand where Karen is and what happened to her,” a speaker in the podcast said.

Karen’s family has participated in the podcast, reflecting on her disappearance.

“It changes everything. For many years, when I would see people that would have similar characteristics, I would stop. If I was in a crowded place like an airport or something, and I’d always be looking. Is there anyone that looks like her?” said Susan Trainer, Karen’s sister.

“You don’t feel like you can go forward until you fix this. So you’re still, waiting for something to happen,” said Elizabeth Paulson, Karen’s 90-year-old mother.

The seven-episode podcast is, according to police, what led them to receive multiple tips that helped to pinpoint her vehicle’s location.

Lalley said the podcast has involved the community and allowed people to come forward with any leads.

“Our detectives have received a lot of leads in terms of information coming in,” Lalley said. “They are focusing on some theories, potentially what could have happened to her and I think the most important thing to is that we are not going to lock in and we are not going to lock out a theory.”

On Tuesday, among those who gathered to watch the vehicle being pulled out was Fernando Sanchez, who recalls the stories told by those in the neighborhood dating back to when he was a young boy.

“Back then we heard, rumor, you know, people knew about, somebody ran into with their car in the river,” Sanchez said.

Now, the family of the once-computer programmer still must wait while the Kane County coroner works to identify the remains found inside the car.

“The feeling, today, is not that much different from the feeling the day-before yesterday. I still don’t know where she is. I still don’t know what happened to her,” Gary said.

Police said the car was taken to a secure storage location for further investigation.

Copyright © 2025 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

You May Also Like
Milwaukee Judge Hannah Dugan adds former Bush solicitor general to defense team

Former Bush administration legal representative joins defense team of Milwaukee Judge Hannah Dugan

Milwaukee Judge Hannah Dugan, facing charges for allegedly hiding an illegal immigrant…
Texas hospitals hit with $122 million bill for illegal immigrants' care in single month

Texas hospitals faced a $122 million bill for providing healthcare to illegal immigrants in just one month

Texas hospitals were left on the hook for nearly $122 million in…
Kamala Harris expected to sharply criticize Donald Trump's policies in San Francisco speech

Kamala Harris set to strongly condemn Donald Trump’s decisions during speech in San Francisco

SAN FRANCISCO — The previous Vice President Kamala Harris is set to…
Trump at 100 Days: The impact of tariffs on the cost of fresh fruit

The Effects of Trade Tariffs on the Price of Fresh Fruits After 100 Days of Trump’s Presidency

PHILADELPHIA — Despite our political differences, most of us can acknowledge the…
What Time Is Trump on TV Tonight? How To Watch ‘President Trump The First 100 Days’

“When will President Trump be on TV tonight and how can I watch ‘President Trump: The The First 100 Days’?”

Where to Stream: President Trump the First 100 Days: The Interview in…
From Inauguration Day to the Vatican, a look back at Trump’s first 100 days: Photos

Reflecting on Trump’s Initial 100 Days: A Journey from Inauguration Day to the Vatican in Photos

On January 20, 2025, Donald Trump was sworn in as the 47th…
Pete Hegseth accidentally roasts Noem and Rubio as he shuts down 'woke' Pentagon program

Pete Hegseth unknowingly criticizes Noem and Rubio while ending controversial Pentagon initiative

US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has decided to terminate a program that…
Idaho judge slams Bryan Kohberger's 'hollow' attempt to dodge death penalty in latest blow to defense

Judge in Idaho criticizes Bryan Kohberger’s ineffective attempt to avoid death penalty in another setback for the defense

The defense team of Bryan Kohberger in Idaho had a plea denied…
Off-duty female cop booked after violent home invasion burglary: police

Female off-duty police officer arrested following a violent break-in at a residence, according to authorities

An off-duty cop in New Jersey was charged and jailed after she…
Trump's eyebrow-raising response on whether Americans can expect price spikes as he downplays economic fears

Trump’s Surprising Answer on Potential Price Increases for Americans While Minimizing Concerns About the Economy

Despite facing criticism and experiencing a highly uncertain stock market since implementing…
CT police quash New England serial killer rumors, arrest man after woman found dismembered in suitcase

Connecticut police dispel rumors of a serial killer in New England, apprehend a man following discovery of dismembered woman in a suitcase

Authorities in Groton, Connecticut, revealed on Monday that a man has been…
Khloé Kardashian's intense weight loss secrets revealed after she dropped 40lbs WITHOUT Ozempic as star shows off killer new bikini body

Learn how Khloé Kardashian lost 40lbs without Ozempic, revealing her weight loss secrets as she flaunts her amazing new bikini body.

Khloé Kardashian sent fans into a frenzy with her killer new bikini…