Jefferson Griffin vs Allison Riggs Decision | North Carolina judges rule in favor of Republican candidate in Supreme Court race

RALEIGH, N.C. — An appeals court in North Carolina ruled in favor of the trailing Republican candidate on Friday in an extremely close state Supreme Court election. This ruling has the potential to change the outcome of the nation’s sole undecided race of 2024.

With a 2-1 decision, a panel from the Court of Appeals at the intermediate level determined that there was an error in allowing ballots – potentially tens of thousands of them – to be included in the count. The court granted some of these voters approximately three weeks to provide additional details or risk having their ballots invalidated.

The ballots in question are reportedly in favor of Democratic Associate Justice Allison Riggs, who, following two recounts, maintained a 734-vote advantage over Republican Jefferson Griffin in a contest that saw more than 5.5 million ballots cast.

Check the Griffin List to see if your ballot is one being contested

The judges on Friday found that the State Board of Elections got it wrong in December when it dismissed Griffin’s election protests. The ruling is expected to be appealed to the Supreme Court.

Griffin’s post-election protests challenged over 65,000 ballots in three different categories. Griffin currently serves on the Court of Appeals and has recused himself from deliberations within the court, where some of his colleagues ruled favoring him.

The prevailing opinion declares that the board should have found that ballots from within each of the three categories shouldn’t be counted because they failed to comply with state law or the state constitution. The decision also reverses the decision of a trial judge who upheld the board’s actions in February.

“Free elections under … the North Carolina Constitution include the right to an accurate counting of votes,” said the opinion backed by Judges John Tyson and Fred Gore, both registered Republicans. “Griffin has a legal right to inquire into this outcome through the statutorily enacted and post-election procedures available to him.”

In two of those categories of challenged voters, the judges directed that the state board give voters in two of the categories 15 business days to provide their missing information or photo identification. If the information is provided in time, then those ballots would still count, the opinion reads.

Griffin’s attorneys have said previously that removing the challenged ballots would favor their client and likely make him the winner. The ballots challenged on the ID mandate, for example, largely came from Democratic-leaning counties. But it’s unclear how many voters would provide the information the judges say are necessary for the ballots to be counted.

In the third category – involving overseas voters who have never lived in the U.S. – their ballots should not count, according to Tyson and Gore.

Lawyers for Riggs and the board have said the ballots were cast lawfully based on state laws and rules that have been applied to elections for years and can’t be altered retroactively. Riggs’ allies have held rallies across the state demanding Griffin concede, saying he was trying to overturn the results of a fair election.

Court of Appeals Judge Toby Hampson, a registered Democrat writing a dissenting opinion, said that Griffin hadn’t identified a single voter who was ineligible to vote in the November elections under the laws and rules governing the election.

“To accept Petitioner’s indiscriminate efforts to call into doubt the votes of tens of thousands of otherwise eligible voters, without any showing any challenged voter was disqualified under existing law from voting, is to elevate speculation and surmise over evidence and reason,” he wrote.

The eight-year term on the highest court in the ninth-largest state was supposed to begin in early January. Riggs has meanwhile remained serving in her seat. She’s also recused herself from preliminary deliberations in the protests that have already been heard by the Supreme Court.

Five of the six remaining justices on the Supreme Court who will likely review the Court of Appeals ruling are registered Republicans. Lawyers for Riggs and the board have already signaled they will take the case to federal court should they lose in state court and Griffin takes the tally lead.

Voter reactions

For voters like Robyn Caplan-Forman, it’s created a lot of confusion. She moved to Durham from New York 2 years ago and thought everything was good when she voted early in Durham County last year.

She said she was shocked after finding out her name was on the list of challenged voters. She found the information herself and said she was never notified like some people were via postcard.

Caplan-Forman was never given a reason, and thinks it’s because she has a hyphenated name that didn’t match.

In light of today’s ruling, she and other voters are now left wondering what to do..

“This is going to cause so much confusion. There is no process in place for us to prove that our ballots are legitimate. And there is no process in place to contact the 65,000 people that are on that list,” Caplan-Forman said.

Under the court’s decision, rather than simply tossing out all the impacted ballots, voters would need to be notified and be given 15 days to show proof of identity.

But when that clock would start is up in the air, since Riggs is appealing the case.

One man who sat on the highest court himself, former Justice Bob Orr, says this ruling is confusing and puts an unfair burden on voters who were following the rules.

“If they miss the deadline or they don’t have that documentation, their votes, at least at this point under this decision, will be disqualified…but then there’s the process of actually figuring out, well, who did they vote for and subtracting that from that. The totals in this race,” Orr said.

He’s also worried about the ramifications for future elections, especially in a purple state like North Carolina, where elections are routinely close.

“I do worry that this litigation is setting a precedent for trying to undermine the integrity of elections,” Orr said.

While The Associated Press declared more than 4,400 winners in the 2024 general election, the state Supreme Court election is the only race that is still undecided.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Copyright © 2025 WTVD-TV. All Rights Reserved.

You May Also Like
Get To Know Delaney Rowe: B.J. Novak’s Girlfriend Is An Actress Turned TikTok Influencer

Meet Delaney Rowe: The Actress Who Became a TikTok Star and is Dating B.J. Novak

B.J. Novak has reportedly found love off screen. Sources informed People that…
The Return of Eric (With)Holder

The Comeback of Eric Holder

When Democrats resurface after a long absence to comment on current events,…
UPS layoffs: Package delivery company to cut 20,000 jobs, close 73 facilities as it reduces amount of Amazon shipments it handles

UPS to cut 20,000 jobs and close 73 facilities due to decrease in Amazon shipments

UPS is looking to slash about 20,000 jobs and close more than…
Major mishap on US aircraft carrier as $70 million F/A-18 fighter jet goes overboard

$70 million F/A-18 fighter jet lost in a major incident on US aircraft carrier

An F/A-18 fighter jet slipped off the hanger deck of an aircraft…
What Time Is Trump on TV Tonight? How To Watch ‘President Trump The First 100 Days’

“When will President Trump be on TV tonight and how can I watch ‘President Trump: The The First 100 Days’?”

Where to Stream: President Trump the First 100 Days: The Interview in…
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney sends blistering message to Donald Trump just moments after being re-elected in shock comeback

Mark Carney, Canadian Prime Minister, strongly criticizes Donald Trump immediately after winning surprise re-election.

In his victory speech following the federal election on Monday, Canada’s Prime…
Karen Read crash expert admits he sent notes to defense, broke sequestration order in first trial

Crash expert confesses to sending notes to defense and violating sequestration order in initial trial, says Karen Reed.

During Karen Read’s defense, a crash reconstructionist is set to play a…
Anger as invasive Chinese creature that can climb 13ft walls is found in iconic Pacific Northwest beauty spot

Discovery of Chinese Climbing Creature in Popular Pacific Northwest Beauty Spot Sparks Anger

In the Pacific Northwest, a highly invasive crab species with the ability…
Pentagon whistleblower fears execution after revealing bombshell UFO program secretly studying alien tech

Fear of execution looms for Pentagon whistleblower who exposed hidden UFO program investigating alien technology

The whistleblower behind a stunning report submitted to Congress – exposing what he…
What Time Does ‘The Rookie’ Come On Tonight?

When does the show ‘The Rookie’ air tonight?

We have some good news for fans of ABC’s The Rookie: The…
Garner Amber Alert canceled: Alondra Michelle Benitez De Jesus, Grecia Salome kidnapped, found safe in Wake Forest, NC

Amber Alert for Alondra Michelle Benitez De Jesus and Grecia Salome canceled after they were found safe in Wake Forest, NC

GARNER, N.C. — (UPDATE): Alondra De Jesus and her daughter, Grecia Benitez,…
Jimmy Kimmel Speculates Where Bill Belichick Met His 24-Year-Old Girlfriend – Either “On The Swing Set” Or “At A Daddy-Daughter Dance”

Did Bill Belichick Meet His 24-Year-Old Girlfriend at a Swing Set or a Daddy-Daughter Dance? Jimmy Kimmel Speculates

During a recent recording of Jimmy Kimmel Live, Jimmy Kimmel surprised his…