Police hunt 'Haggler After Midnight' mugger targeting certain victims in bizarre crime spree

The New York Police Department is actively searching for a knife-wielding robber who rides a moped and has earned the nickname “Haggler After Midnight” due to his unique method of thievery. The suspect, whose robberies are becoming increasingly bold and violent, has struck at least 11 times.

Starting in early November, the perpetrator has chosen victims in Brooklyn and Queens, focusing on Hispanic males aged 20 to 40 who are returning home from work during the early morning hours, according to law enforcement.

Deputy Chief John Mastronardi at the department’s Crimes against Persons Unit told WNBC that the mugger negotiates in both English and Spanish. 

“He’s got a strange M.O. – he likes to haggle with his victims, so we call him the ‘Haggler After Midnight,’” he said. “Oftentimes if a victim produces a property that they’re going to give up, he says ‘No, no, no, I don’t want that, want that.’ So he gets to choose.”

His most recent attack on Dec. 10 was his boldest yet, Mastronardi said. 

“In the last [incident], the male approached one of our victims and put a knife to his throat,” the detective said. 

Thus far, none of the suspect’s victims have been injured.

Crime Stoppers is offering a cash reward for any information that leads to the man’s capture.  

You May Also Like
Ryan Seacrest, 50, sparks health concerns as fans fear over his 'frail' appearance

Fans are worried about Ryan Seacrest, 50, as they are concerned about his ‘thin’ look and his health.

Ryan Seacrest sparked concern from fans after sharing his latest Instagram post.…
Update: Horrifying Details Emerge About Alleged Capital Jewish Museum Shooter and His Victims

County Sheriff Identifies Coeur d’Alene Killer with No Apparent Criminal Record

More details are coming to light regarding the shooter who lured firefighters…
Military-trained dad accused of killing daughters nears 3 weeks living in wilderness amid manhunt

Authorities struggle to find survivalist father as search intensifies: Emotions running high

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! The search for the…
‘The Old Guard’ Recap: What To Remember From ‘The Old Guard’ Before You Watch ‘The Old Guard 2’

Recap of ‘The Old Guard’: Key Points to Recall Before Watching ‘The Old Guard 2’

It’s been a long five years, but The Old Guard 2 release…
Wednesday Morning Minute: Happy Liberation Day!

Tuesday Morning Recap: A Unique Pride Month

TOP O’ THE MORNIN’ Red-Hot at RedState  CNN is still under fire…
Ravinia Festival 2025 concert lineup includes Chicago this weekend in Highland Park

Chicago will be performing at Ravinia Festival in 2025 this weekend at Highland Park.

HIGHLAND PARK, Ill. (WLS) — The group Chicago will be at Ravinia…
The courtroom picture that says everything as Diddy jury reach verdict on four charges and deliberate fifth

“Diddy Jury Deliberates Verdict on Four Charges with Telling Courtroom Image”

Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs’ mask finally slipped as jurors announced they reached a…
See the winners of the International Aerial Photographer of the Year Competition: Photos

View the champions of the Global Aerial Photographer of the Year Contest: Images

The winners of the first International Aerial Photographer of the Year competition…
Donald Trump's 'colossal mistake' BLASTED by Obama and Bush during surprise reunion that left Bono in tears

Obama and Bush criticize Donald Trump’s significant error during unexpected meeting that made Bono emotional.

Barack Obama and George W. Bush, along with USAID staff, have come…
'Project Runway' Season 20 returns July 31 with Heidi Klum, Law Roach & 12 designers competing

“Get ready for ‘Project Runway’ Season 20 featuring Heidi Klum, Law Roach, and 12 talented designers – premieres on July 31!”

The fashion competition returns with Heidi Klum, Law Roach, and more of…
Crews respond to massive explosions at fireworks facility in California

Emergency crews react to large explosions at fireworks plant in California

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! A fireworks facility in…
Supermarket heir, 62, dies of 'natural causes' at stunning $1.3m mansion

62-year-old supermarket heir passes away from natural causes at luxurious $1.3 million mansion

A local supermarket heir has died at just 62 years old from…