Top lawyer tears into Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg for trying to 'strong-arm' Daniel Penny jury with bombshell court move

A prominent attorney has criticized Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg for his management of the Daniel Penny case. Penny faced a manslaughter charge for fatally putting Jordan Neely, a mentally ill homeless individual, in a chokehold on May 1, 2023.

During Penny’s trial, which took place on Friday, the presiding judge, acting on the prosecution’s request, dismissed the primary charge. This decision permitted the jurors to deliberate on a lesser offense after failing to reach a unanimous verdict on the manslaughter charge.

Judge Maxwell Wiley’s decision will now let jurors deliberate a charge of criminally negligent homicide, which carries a lighter punishment.   

But former U.S. assistant attorney Andy McCarthy has accused Bragg of using ‘strong-arm’ tactics to sway the jury. 

McCarthy criticized Bragg for introducing a contentious recklessness charge in the indictment. This addition was perceived as a strategy to offer the jury a middle-ground option, potentially increasing the likelihood of a conviction, even if it does not entail a prison sentence.

Writing in National Review, McCarthy wrote, ‘Bragg added a baseless recklessness charge to the indictment so the jury would have two counts, increasing the odds of conviction by giving the jury something to compromise on.’ 

Trial testimony revealed that Neely, who was reportedly under the influence of drugs, had entered a subway car in a psychotic episode, threatening passengers.

Initially, the jury could only deliberate on the secondary charge of criminally negligent homicide if they cleared Penny of manslaughter on grounds other than justifiable force.

Jurors have been deliberating since Tuesday on whether to convict Daniel Penny, pictured, over Jordan Neely's death

Jurors have been deliberating since Tuesday on whether to convict Daniel Penny, pictured, over Jordan Neely’s death 

Former U.S. assistant attorney Andy McCarthy, pictured, has accused District Attorney Alvin Bragg of using 'strong-arm' tactics to sway the jury

Former U.S. assistant attorney Andy McCarthy, pictured, has accused District Attorney Alvin Bragg of using ‘strong-arm’ tactics to sway the jury

Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg is a Democrat who has reduced violent crimes from felonies to misdemeanors

Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg is a Democrat who has reduced violent crimes from felonies to misdemeanors

However, after jurors reported being deadlocked multiple times, Assistant Manhattan District Attorney Dafna Yoran successfully requested the dismissal of the top charge.

This move now allows the jury to focus solely on the lesser charge, which carries a maximum sentence of four years.

McCarthy expressed frustration with this development, stating on Fox News, ‘Today, the jurors have been Allen-charged to try to strong-arm them into deciding the count despite indicating, after three days, that they were deadlocked.’

He also criticized the prosecution in National Review, arguing that the case lacked the elements needed for a recklessness charge.

‘This was not remotely a recklessness case, where it could be said that Penny wantonly disregarded an obvious risk of death,’ he wrote. 

Jurors have been deliberating since Tuesday on whether to convict Penny over Neely’s death. 

If the jury still cannot reach a unanimous decision there is a risk that the case will fall apart and be declared a mistrial. If that happens, it will then be up to the prosecution to retry the case in front of a new jury. 

The difference between the two charges is whether Penny behaved recklessly vs negligently when he put Neely in the chokehold. 

Penny held Neely in a chokehold on the subway car floor while others assisted on May 1, 2023

Penny held Neely in a chokehold on the subway car floor while others assisted on May 1, 2023

Daniel Penny

Jordan Neely

The May 2023 incident sparked uproar in America – BLM says it was the racist killing of a mentally ill black man by an overzealous white military faithful

after jurors reported being deadlocked multiple times, Assistant Manhattan District Attorney Dafna Yoran successfully requested the dismissal of the top charge.

after jurors reported being deadlocked multiple times, Assistant Manhattan District Attorney Dafna Yoran successfully requested the dismissal of the top charge. 

McCarthy pointed out that Penny had adjusted Neely’s position to help him breathe, cooperated with police, and was unaware Neely had died during the incident.

‘There is evidence that Penny moved Neely into a position that would make breathing easier, waited for the police to come and fully cooperated with them, and did not even know Neely was dead when he voluntarily spoke to police and explained what happened — that he wasn’t trying to hurt Neely, just subdue him until the police arrived.

‘Now, after the jury could not find Penny guilty of recklessness after four days — and how disturbing it is that one or more jurors were apparently in favor of doing so — the judge is letting Bragg remove the recklessness count from the case. It will go down as an acquittal for Penny on that charge, so he is no longer facing a potential 15-year prison term. For the jury, however, it makes the hard work of the last four days pointless,’ McCarthy explained.

Despite McCarthy’s objections, he acknowledged the prosecution’s dual-charge strategy was having its intended effect. ‘Unfortunately, the strategy is working the way it’s designed to work,’ he remarked.

Judge Maxwell Wiley will now let jurors deliberate a charge of criminally negligent homicide, which carries a lighter punishment after the charge of manslaughter was dismissed

Judge Maxwell Wiley will now let jurors deliberate a charge of criminally negligent homicide, which carries a lighter punishment after the charge of manslaughter was dismissed

Manslaughter requires proving a defendant recklessly caused another person’s death, and carries up to 15 years. 

Criminally negligent homicide involves engaging in serious ‘blameworthy conduct’ while not perceiving such a risk and carries punishments ranging from probation to up to four years in prison.  

Penny’s lawyers have said he was protecting himself and other subway passengers from a volatile, mentally ill man who was making alarming remarks and gestures. Prosecutors said Penny reacted far too forcefully to someone he perceived as a peril, not a person. 

During the monthlong trial, the anonymous jury heard from witnesses, police, pathologists, a Marine Corps instructor who trained Penny in chokehold techniques, as well as Penny’s relatives, friends and fellow Marines. Penny chose not to testify . 

The case became a flashpoint in the nation’s debate over racial injustice and crime, as well as the city’s ongoing struggle to deal with homelessness and mental health crises in a transit system used by millions of New Yorkers every day.

You May Also Like
James Robinson, Angel Contreras charged in attempted murder of off-duty Chicago officer in 2024 Morgan Park shootout, police say

Angel Contreras and James Robinson accused of attempted murder of an off-duty Chicago officer during a shootout in Morgan Park in 2024, according to law enforcement officers.

CHICAGO (WLS) — Two men have been charged after an attempted robbery…
Virginia Giuffre, who accused Britain's Prince Andrew in Jeffrey Epstein sex trafficking scandal, has died

Virginia Giuffre, who accused Prince Andrew in Jeffrey Epstein sex scandal, has passed away

Virginia Giuffre, who previously accused Prince Andrew of sexually exploiting her as…
Doctor reveals the 5-second trick he never skips on cruise ships - and says it could save lives

Doctor shares life-saving 5-second trick he always uses onboard cruise ships

Before starting his holiday at sea, a travel expert shared a simple…
7 Shows Like ‘Ransom Canyon’ If You’re Craving More Soapy Sagas Or Small-Town Streams

7 TV Series Similar to ‘Ransom Canyon’ for those Wanting More Dramatic Stories or Shows Set in Small Communities

Get ready with your cowboy gear because Netflix has a hot new…
Eruption warning updated for massive volcano as 300,000 Americans prepare for disaster

Update: 300,000 Americans Prepare for Disaster as Massive Volcano Eruption Warning Issued

Alaska’s Mount Spurr has experienced 66 earthquakes in the last week, signaling…
Will There Be A ‘You’ Season 6 On Netflix? Everything We Know

What We Know About the Possibility of ‘You’ Season 6 on Netflix

After debuting on Lifetime six years ago, the hit show You has…
Michelle Obama Reveals Why She Skipped Trump’s Inauguration – and It’s As Self-Absorbed As You’d Imagine

Reasons Michelle Obama Skipped Trump’s Inauguration – It’s Just Like You’d Think

Michelle Obama finally revealed why she failed to attend President Trump’s second…
Massive blow to Trump as Japanese car giant moves manufacturing OUT of US in tariff twist

Huge setback for Trump as Japanese car company shifts production AWAY from US due to tariffs

President Donald Trump’s tariffs just cost America a chunk of Canadian business.…
George Santos to be sentenced for fraud, identity theft; prosecutors seeking 7-year prison sentence

George Santos Faces Sentencing for Fraud and Identity Theft – Prosecutors Push for 7-Year Prison Term

NEW YORK — Disgraced former U.S. Rep. George Santos, who lied about…
Karen Read says she poured extra shots into her cocktails before John O'Keefe's death

Karen Read admits to adding extra shots to cocktails prior to John O’Keefe’s death

Sometimes, Karen Read might take things into her own hands, like when…
Beyonce mercilessly mocked as tickets for 'flop' Cowboy Carter tour reach same price as a McDonald's meal

Beyonce ridiculed as ticket prices for failed Cowboy Carter tour drop to cost of a meal at McDonald’s.

Beyonce has been ridiculed by music fans after tickets for her struggling…
Selma Blair shares unbelievable health update amid years-long MS battle

Selma Blair provides incredible update on her health after battling MS for years

Selma Blair shared a positive update on her battle with Multiple Sclerosis,…