True crime reporters blocked outside courthouse where Karen Read is on trial file First Amendment lawsuit

Two New England true crime reporters have initiated legal action against Massachusetts State Police for purportedly preventing them from reporting outside the courthouse during Karen Read’s second murder trial related to John O’Keefe’s death.

Their grievance arises from a court-mandated “buffer zone” aimed at separating protesters, yet the journalists claim that they encountered interference from the police within this zone, even though it was not intended for individuals not involved in protesting.

The legal action identifies Massachusetts State Police Superintendent Geoffrey Noble and MSP Sgt. Michael Hardman, along with two additional unidentified state troopers.

“You don’t have media credentials. You’ve got to go behind the buffer zone, OK, or you’re going to be subject to arrest,” Hardman allegedly told him. “Go follow them. You’re being told right now.”

Karen Read

Karen Read supporters rally on the front steps of the Registry of Deeds building. (John Tlumacki/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)

“I’m not media?” Derosier, a Massachusetts resident, asked, according to the lawsuit.

“No, you’re not,” Hardman allegedly replied.

Both men recorded the interactions and included them in court filings with the lawsuit.

“I think the reporters are probably on solid legal ground,” said Andrew Stoltmann, a Chicago-based attorney who has handled First Amendment cases in the past and teaches at Northwestern University’s School of Law. 

“The judge has absolute powers in his courtroom to prevent parties or witnesses from talking about the case, but trying to gag a reporter that’s not in the courtroom is constitutionally very, very suspect for both the judge and the police officers who are trying to enforce it.”

Jury selection is underway for Read’s second trial. The first ended in a mistrial July 1 after jurors could not agree on a verdict.

She faces charges of murder, manslaughter and leaving the scene of a deadly hit-and-run for allegedly backing her Lexus SUV into O’Keefe in January 2022 and leaving him on the ground to die during a blizzard.

She has pleaded not guilty and denied the allegations, and her defense is arguing she was framed.

You May Also Like
Suspicious incendiary device found near Blue Ridge Parkway prompts evacuation

Evacuation ordered due to a suspicious explosive device discovered close to Blue Ridge Parkway

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! Park rangers from the…
Trump admin opens bombshell investigation into aging Biden's final days in office and prolific use of autopen

Investigation Launched by Trump Administration into Biden’s Use of Autopen in Final Days

President Trump’s administration is looking into Joe Biden’s use of an autopen…
Trump touts Kid Rock's latest Nashville restaurant after ICE raids briefly shut down musician's steakhouse

Kid Rock’s Nashville restaurant promoted by Trump after ICE raids pause operations

President Donald Trump endorsed Kid Rock’s lastest Nashville restaurant in a Monday…
New mugshot released of Boulder terror attack suspect Mohamed Sabry Soliman

Illegal immigrant suspect previously employed in healthcare and as a rideshare driver before Boulder terror attack.

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! The individual from Egypt…
For What They’ve Done to Joe Biden, Someone Needs to Go to Prison

Someone Should be Jailed for the Wrongdoings Against Joe Biden

After all the gaslighting, taunting, and outright cover-ups, we’re finally seeing the…
Ukraine Conflict Escalation and U.S. Involvement

Increased Tensions in Ukraine and the Role of the U.S.

Last Updated on June 3, 2025 Steve Bannon, former White House chief…
Dating apps tied to kidnapping of US citizens in Mexico, embassy says, prompting security alert for travelers

US embassy issues security alert for travelers due to dating apps linked to kidnapping incidents in Mexico

The U.S. embassy in Mexico on Monday said it has confirmed reports…
Mount Etna news: Volcanic activity in Sicily erupts in a fiery show of smoke and ash miles high

Breaking News: Mount Etna in Sicily erupts with high columns of smoke and ash

MILAN — Sicily’s Mount Etna put on a fiery show Monday, sending…
The 'truth' about Blake Lively's therapy notes... and why she really dropped bombshell claim against Justin Baldoni

Blake Lively’s therapy notes revealed: The real reason behind her shocking accusation against Justin Baldoni

In the ongoing conflict between It Ends With Us co-stars Blake Lively…
North Carolina parents charged after son is struck and killed by SUV while walking with older brother

Parent in North Carolina are accused after their son is hit and fatally injured by a Sports Utility Vehicle as he walks with his older sibling

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! A 7-year-old boy was…
Jamie Foxx reveals exactly how he feels about Diddy amid rapper's sex trafficking trial

Jamie Foxx shares his thoughts on Diddy during the rapper’s trial for sex trafficking

Jamie Foxx has spoken out again about Diddy, making it clear what…
CBS stalwart reveals 'the truth' about edited Kamala Harris interview that Trump is suing the network over

CBS veteran discloses details of altered interview with Kamala Harris that Trump is suing the network for

Lesley Stahl, a veteran correspondent for CBS, expressed her frustration with the…