True crime reporters blocked outside courthouse where Karen Read is on trial file First Amendment lawsuit

Two New England true crime reporters have initiated legal action against Massachusetts State Police for purportedly preventing them from reporting outside the courthouse during Karen Read’s second murder trial related to John O’Keefe’s death.

Their grievance arises from a court-mandated “buffer zone” aimed at separating protesters, yet the journalists claim that they encountered interference from the police within this zone, even though it was not intended for individuals not involved in protesting.

The legal action identifies Massachusetts State Police Superintendent Geoffrey Noble and MSP Sgt. Michael Hardman, along with two additional unidentified state troopers.

“You don’t have media credentials. You’ve got to go behind the buffer zone, OK, or you’re going to be subject to arrest,” Hardman allegedly told him. “Go follow them. You’re being told right now.”

Karen Read

Karen Read supporters rally on the front steps of the Registry of Deeds building. (John Tlumacki/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)

“I’m not media?” Derosier, a Massachusetts resident, asked, according to the lawsuit.

“No, you’re not,” Hardman allegedly replied.

Both men recorded the interactions and included them in court filings with the lawsuit.

“I think the reporters are probably on solid legal ground,” said Andrew Stoltmann, a Chicago-based attorney who has handled First Amendment cases in the past and teaches at Northwestern University’s School of Law. 

“The judge has absolute powers in his courtroom to prevent parties or witnesses from talking about the case, but trying to gag a reporter that’s not in the courtroom is constitutionally very, very suspect for both the judge and the police officers who are trying to enforce it.”

Jury selection is underway for Read’s second trial. The first ended in a mistrial July 1 after jurors could not agree on a verdict.

She faces charges of murder, manslaughter and leaving the scene of a deadly hit-and-run for allegedly backing her Lexus SUV into O’Keefe in January 2022 and leaving him on the ground to die during a blizzard.

She has pleaded not guilty and denied the allegations, and her defense is arguing she was framed.

You May Also Like
'I know a lot of dangerous secrets about the Kennedys. I will shock the world': Marilyn Monroe's ominous words before she was found naked and dead in bed... so was she murdered to silence her?

What Marilyn Monroe said before her mysterious death: ‘I have many shocking secrets about the Kennedys. I could surprise the world.’

Buddy Greco, a jazz singer and pianist, is captivated by the beauty…
CNN's Scott Jennings rips liberal apart by using her own words against her

Scott Jennings from CNN criticizes a liberal by using her own words against her

CNN’s Scott Jennings ripped a liberal apart by using her own words…
2 arrested at LA home linked to Iranian 'human smuggling hub': CBP

CBP: Two people arrested at Los Angeles residence tied to Iranian ‘human smuggling center’

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! Federal officials apprehended two…
Boat catches fire near Cape Canaveral, passengers saved

Passengers rescued as boat catches fire close to Cape Canaveral.

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! First responders rescued four…
Stunning reason why mother gave marijuana edibles to 6-year-old daughter

Surprising explanation for why a mother provided cannabis-infused treats to her 6-year-old child

Deanna Sue Woods, 36, was sentenced to prison on Wednesday after allegedly…
Freak accident at the beach sends teen to ICU as mom warns of waterfront danger

Teen Hospitalized after Beach Accident: Mother’s Warning about Waterfront Dangers

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! A teenager remains in…
Watch: Angry Chuck Todd Chews Schumer Out Over Biden Cognitive Cover-Up: ‘You’re Part of the Problem!’

Chuck Schumer Delays Vote on Important Bill Using Childish Strategies at Schoolyard

Chuck Schumer, to put it kindly, is not. But the senator who…
'Shark Week' host warns beachgoers where and when predators are most likely to attack

Expert on ‘Shark Week’ advises beach visitors on when and where predators may strike

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! A wildlife expert and…
'Very close to a final product': Senate GOP's version of Trump's megabill nears finish line

Senate Republicans are almost done with their version of Trump’s significant bill.

With a week remaining until the July Fourth deadline for Congress to…
World's biggest celebrities turn out in force in outrageous outfits for Lauren Sanchez and Jeff Bezos' final wedding party... with a bizarre theme

“Top Celebrities Dress up in Extravagant Outfits at Lauren Sanchez and Jeff Bezos’ Last Wedding Bash with Unusual Theme”

Some of the early attendees at the final evening of Lauren Sanchez…
Chicago Pride Bowl LGBTQ+ flag football tournament held at Montrose Beach, presented by Metropolitan Sports Association, Bears

Metropolitan Sports Association Bears presents LGBTQ+ flag football tournament at Montrose Beach in Chicago for Chicago Pride Bowl

CHICAGO (WLS) — During Pride weekend in Chicago, the city hosted one…
Putin visits Kursk region for first time since booting Ukrainian forces from territory

Ukraine reports that Russia initiated its most extensive air assault of the conflict

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! Russia launched its biggest…