Luigi Mangione's star defense attorney makes bombshell claim about alleged UnitedHealthcare CEO shooter's 'manifesto'

An attorney representing accused UnitedHealthcare CEO assassin Luigi Mangione has made a bombshell claim about his alleged manifesto.

Karen Agnifilo argued in recently submitted court papers that the police disclosed writings that they claimed were authored by the now 26-year-old individual and characterized them as a ‘manifesto,’ which in turn caused alarm as a means to validate the terrorism accusation made by prosecutors.

Shortly after Mangione’s apprehension at a McDonald’s in Pennsylvania, following a five-day quest for the masked perpetrator who shot Brian Thompson outside a hotel in New York City, the writings were made public.

Allegedly, he was discovered with a 9-millimeter gun and silencer, attire identical to what the shooter wore in surveillance videos, and a journal detailing a plan to ‘whack’ a CEO of an insurance company, as indicated in legal documents.

But Agnifilo now says there is ‘absolutely no evidence’ to suggest her client wrote the so-called manifesto as she called out prosecutors for sharing the message.

‘Since the inception of this case, law enforcement has consistently leaked writings purported to be written by Mr. Mangione, while also prejudicially labeling these writings a “manifesto” to the media,’ she argued.

‘By releasing these writings to the public and calling them a manifesto, law enforcement is responsible for causing the very public alarm that they are now trying to attribute to Mr. Mangione, which is the basis for charging him with the enhanced charge of murder in the first degree as an act of terrorism.

‘There is absolutely no evidence that Mr. Mangione ever released the writings that law enforcement is attributing to him publicly; any publishing was done by law enforcement,’ she continued.

Karen Agnifilo, an attorney representing accused UnitedHealthcare CEO assassin Luigi Mangione, argued that police leaked writings they said belonged to the now 26-year-old and labeled them a 'manifesto' - thereby spreading fear in an effort to justify prosecutors' terrorism charge

Karen Agnifilo, an attorney representing accused UnitedHealthcare CEO assassin Luigi Mangione, argued that police leaked writings they said belonged to the now 26-year-old and labeled them a ‘manifesto’ – thereby spreading fear in an effort to justify prosecutors’ terrorism charge

‘By painting Mr. Mangione as a “terrorist” and releasing a purported “manifesto,” law enforcement is intending to prejudice Mr. Mangione and cause the public alarm and fear that they now attribute to him,’ Agnifilo argued.

‘This is problematic and fatal to the government’s charge of murder in the first degree, which requires said murder to be in furtherance of an act of terrorism “intended to intimidate or coerce a civilian population,” and insofar as it is law enforcement that is responsible for said intimidation.

‘This behavior by law enforcement is wildly irresponsible, as they are spreading a message to the public intended to incite individuals who may as a result believe Mr. Mangione held purported viewpoints.’

Investigators have claimed that Mangione, an Ivy League computer science graduate from a prominent Maryland family, was propelled by anger at the US health care system.

They pointed to the alleged manifesto, which included a number of grievances against UnitedHealthcare.

‘To save you a lengthy investigation, I state plainly that I wasn’t working with anyone. This was fairly trivial: some elementary social engineering, basic CAD, [and] a lot of patience,’ the document read, according to the Daily Beast. 

It went on to say he had ‘respect’ for federal investigators, and apologized for causing any ‘traumas,’ but seemed to defend his alleged actions.

‘Frankly these parasites had it coming,’ the manifesto wrote. 

It also noted that the United States had the ‘most expensive healthcare system in the world,’ but blasted the system for making America only the 42nd in life expectancy.

UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson was gunned down outside of a New York City hotel

UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson was gunned down outside of a New York City hotel

Mangione was allegedly found with a 9-millimeter pistol and silencer, clothing that matched the apparel worn by the shooter in surveillance footage

Mangione was allegedly found with a 9-millimeter pistol and silencer, clothing that matched the apparel worn by the shooter in surveillance footage

Mangione is now facing a slew of charges in the Big Apple, and is also facing lesser charges of false identification and weapons charges in Pennsylvania.

His attorney in that case has similarly claimed cops illegally took a personal notebook out of Mangione’s bag and dubbed it a manifesto to taint public opinion about his client.

‘The Altoona Police Department illegally seized a notebook which allegedly contained numerous personal writings covering a plethora of personal experiences of [Mangione],’ attorney Thomas Dickey wrote in court documents earlier this month. 

‘This characterization of [Mangione’s] alleged personal experiences and writings is incorrect, improper, and without justification and has no probative value… [that] was done so solely for the purpose to prejudice [Mangione] and put him in a negative light before the public; all in an effort to prejudice any potential jury pool.’ 

The lawyer also claimed officers ‘lacked reasonable suspicion to engage in such activity’ and approached Mangione at the McDonald’s ‘based on a hunch.’ 

‘[Altoona police] had no independent corroborating evidence that [Mangione] was in fact the suspect sought in New York, prior to, or at the time of their stop and/or the investigatory detention of,’ said the court documents.

‘Any reasonable person, innocent of any crime, would have thought that he was being restrained if he had been in the Defendant’s shoes.’

Dickey said the officers abused their power and violated Mangione’s constitutional rights.

‘[The cops] combined actions [at the McDonalds were] designed to not only exhibit their authority and control over [Mangione], but to also to restrict and totally curtail his liberty,’ the filings said.

Mangione is now facing a slew of charges in the Big Apple, and is also facing lesser charges of false identification and weapons charges in Pennsylvania

Mangione is now facing a slew of charges in the Big Apple, and is also facing lesser charges of false identification and weapons charges in Pennsylvania

Mangione has pleaded not guilty to an 11-count indictment charging him with murder as an act of terrorism and weapons offenses

Mangione has pleaded not guilty to an 11-count indictment charging him with murder as an act of terrorism and weapons offenses

Mangione has pleaded not guilty to an 11-count indictment charging him with murder as an act of terrorism and weapons offenses.

If convicted, Mangione could face life in prison without parole. He is now jailed in a federal lockup in Brooklyn.

He has been fiercely backed by a slew of fans who have praised Mangione for his alleged actions and started a GiveSendGo pages to raise money for his legal defense.

Some have even made art depicting him as a saint, saying he is a hero who has taken a stand against America’s broken healthcare system. 

For Mangione’s upcoming 27th birthday, fans have also organized a ‘special’ donation fund – urging others to contribute $27 toward his legal fund as a ‘nice surprise and gift from us to him.’

He has been fiercely backed by a slew of fans who have praised Mangione for his alleged actions and started a GiveSendGo pages to raise money for his legal defense

He has been fiercely backed by a slew of fans who have praised Mangione for his alleged actions and started a GiveSendGo pages to raise money for his legal defense

Their goal is to take his controversial fundraising total from  $745,000 – where it currently stands – to $1million. 

While no amount of money will grant him bail, the fans hope the cash will be able to put together a convincing enough defense for an acquittal. 

The campaign is also asking fans to submit birthday wishes, fan art, memes and messages of support.

They are also planning to protest the conditions within the jail where he’s being held. 

The protest, according to the website, will aim to bring attention to ‘inhumane’ conditions inside the Metropolitan Detention Center,  and ‘demand justice’ for those behind bars. 

You May Also Like
‘Andor’ Series Finale Recap: Unstoppable Force

Summary of the Last Episode of the ‘Andor’ Series: An Unstoppable Power

Struggling may feel overwhelming at times, facing uncertainty and seemingly insurmountable obstacles.…
Cannes Film Festival 2025 red carpet: All the celebrity looks

Celebrity Fashion at Cannes Film Festival 2025: Must-See Red Carpet Outfits

It doesn’t get more glam than Cannes. The Cannes Film Festival will…
Honey Boo Boo risks reigniting feud with Mama June as she talks mother's drug past: 'It's the truth'

“Honey Boo Boo brings up Mama June’s drug past, potentially fueling past conflict”

Alana ‘Honey Boo Boo’ Thompson is risking reigniting her feud with her…
Chef José Andrés serves up a taste of Mexico in Manhattan's Hudson Yards

Chef José Andrés offers a sampling of Mexican flavors at Hudson Yards in Manhattan

MIDTOWN, Manhattan — Oyamel is a Mexican restaurant located in Hudson Yards,…
ESPN’s New Streaming Service Sets Launch For Fall 2025 — And You’ll Never Guess Its Name

ESPN’s upcoming streaming service is scheduled to launch in fall 2025, revealed the name. Can you guess what it is?

ESPN is prepping its stream team — and it’s almost game time.…
Pope Leo XIV makes first social media post, calling for peace

Pope Leo XIV shares a message on social media urging peace

Pope Leo XIV shared a message of peace in his debut social…
Ryan Reynolds looks tense after dodging questions about wife Blake Lively's legal battle with Justin Baldoni in his first TV interview since actress filed complaint

Ryan Reynolds appears stressed following his evasion of inquiries regarding his spouse Blake Lively’s legal dispute with Justin Baldoni during his initial television interview since the actress lodged a complaint.

Ryan Reynolds looked tense on Monday after dodging questions about his wife…
Will There Be a Season 4 of ‘Will Trent’?

Is There Going to Be a Season 4 of the Show ‘Will Trent’?

Our streaming schedules are about to be thrown into disarray because a…
TEASER: '9-1-1: Nashville' joins 'DWTS,' 'High Potential,' 'Abbott Elementary' and more in ABC's primetime fall lineup

Sneak Peek: ABC’s fall schedule includes ‘9-1-1: Nashville’ along with popular shows like ‘DWTS’ and ‘High Potential’

LOS ANGELES — Thursday nights on ABC just got hotter with “9-1-1:…
Nuclear watchdog urges 'trust but verify' that Iran engages in good-faith negotiations

Trump gives Iran ultimatum: Give up nuclear weapons or face severe sanctions

President Donald Trump addressed Iran in his first major speech in Saudi…
UN revisits 'killer robot' regulations as concerns about AI-controlled weapons grow

The UN is reviewing rules for ‘killer robots’ amid rising fears over AI-powered weaponry.

Several countries gathered at the United Nations (U.N.) recently to address a…
11 Fort Dearborn Elementary School students taken to hospitals after possibly eating laced cookies in Brainerd: sources, parents

Sources and parents report that 11 students from Fort Dearborn Elementary School were taken to hospitals following suspected consumption of spiked cookies in Brainerd.

CHICAGO (WLS) — Eleven students from a South Side elementary school have…