This Has Got to Be the Strangest Argument Against School Choice I’ve Ever Heard

There are many arguments that opponents of school choice use to argue against legislation aimed at empowering parents to choose where and how their children are educated. But this one is one of the most bizarre that I’ve come across in quite a while.

In an op-ed for The Tennessean, author Jess Davis argues that the state should focus on fixing its infrastructure before allocating resources to expand its school voucher program. In the piece, she brings up how Tennessee’s infrastructure challenges have a disproportionately negative impact on rural and underserved communities that prevent them from accessing quality education.

“We’ve got more than 900 bridges in this state that are structurally deficient and countless roads that make driving a daily test of endurance,” Davis writes, also asking, “How can we talk about educational choice when we haven’t fixed the roads that take kids to school in the first place?”

“This isn’t just a rural problem — it affects all of us. When I hear people talking about expanding school vouchers, my mind immediately goes to how hard it is for families in some parts of Tennessee even to get their children to school safely.”

Davis appears to be responding to news that Tennessee state lawmakers and Gov. Bill Lee are planning a big push for school choice next year. In November, they unveiled the Education Freedom Act of 2025, which would grant 20,000 school vouchers worth $7,075 to families to pay for education costs for their children.

“What good is a voucher if you can’t get to a school or don’t have reliable internet for remote learning? Many communities across the state are still rebuilding essential roads and bridges destroyed by disasters like Hurricane Helene.”

The author goes on to point out that Arizona’s universal voucher program “led to a $1.4 billion budget shortfall, impacting vital state programs like education and health care.”

Employing a similar program in Tennessee “is costly and risks diverting resources from crucial infrastructure needs,” Davis argues. “Without addressing these fundamental needs, Tennessee risks further deterioration that could isolate communities and hinder educational access across the state.”

According to Davis, without reliable roads and internet service, vouchers would mostly benefit families who might already have better access to resources. “If we don’t fix these fundamental issues, vouchers will only serve those who already have access, while others are left behind,” she writes.

There are several flaws in Davis’ arguments. For starters, her points hinge on the notion that infrastructure and education are interconnected, and one cannot succeed without dealing with the other. She seems to believe that the state has to choose between fixing infrastructure and providing educational freedom to parents, which isn’t necessarily the case, especially in a state with a $22.7 billion budget.

Yes, infrastructure is essential, but this is not a zero-sum game. There is no valid reason why Tennessee can’t do both – especially if they take a DOGE-like approach to cutting wasteful and unnecessary spending. Moreover, she does not account for the possibility that allowing more options for parents could alleviate the strain on government-run schools by diversifying where students are educated.

The Education Freedom Act has plenty of provisions that could help struggling families as it would provide 10,000 scholarships for eligible students whose family household income is less than 300 percent of the amount required for free or reduced-price lunches. This would go a long way toward addressing economic disparities and allow children from low-income families to receive quality education.

In the end, Davis’ arguments appear to be a way to use infrastructure to delay legislation that could greatly benefit Tennessee’s children. After all, would she truly start supporting school choice after Tennessee fixes its infrastructure?

Probably not. She and others who oppose these measures would likely come up with yet another issue that must be addressed before empowering parents and students. In the end, these are weak arguments that fail to make a valid case against educational freedom. If this is the best they can come up with, proponents of school choice might have some serious victories ahead.

You May Also Like
Former ABC7 Chicago anchor, reporter Suzanne Rico's podcast 'The Man Who Calculated Death' to be considered at Ambies awards

Suzanne Rico, a past ABC7 Chicago anchor and reporter, has her podcast ‘The Man Who Calculated Death’ up for consideration at the Ambies awards.

CHICAGO (WLS) — Podcasts have exploded in popularity over the last several…
Megyn Kelly issues scathing takedown of liberal journalist over reaction to her sister's death

Megyn Kelly Criticizes Liberal Journalist for Insensitive Response to Her Sister’s Death

Megyn Kelly has blasted a liberal tech reporter, calling her a ‘bad person’…
Gaunt, dazed and hollow-eyed Justin Bieber films disturbing livestream triggering Hailey Bieber drama

Justin Bieber looks tired and thin while shooting unsettling livestream that leads to drama with Hailey Bieber

Justin Bieber continued to spark fan fears with a disturbing livestream video…
Wow! Trump Signs Anti-Scalping EO - With Kid Rock at His Side

Trump Signs Executive Order Against Scalping, Joined by Kid Rock

Remember the days when you were a kid and wanted to attend…
Survivors still being found from Burma earthquake, but hopes begin to fade as deaths exceed 2,700

More survivors discovered after earthquake hits Burma, but as the death toll surpasses 2,700, optimism diminishes.

The NUG, formed by lawmakers who were removed from power in 2021,…
Florida woman points pellet gun at kids fishing near backyard, threatened to 'blow their heads off': officials

Florida Woman Allegedly Pointed Pellet Gun at Children Fishing Nearby in Backyard and Threatened to Shoot Them: Authorities

A woman in Florida was arrested after she allegedly pointed a pellet…
Morgan Wallen Rejected ‘SNL’ Sketch Before Controversial Walk Off, Forcing The Show To Cast Boy Band Star Instead: Report

Morgan Wallen Declined ‘SNL’ Sketch Leading to Replacement by Boy Band Star: Report

Morgan Wallen’s recent performance on ‘Saturday Night Live’ has been overshadowed by…
Charges dropped against Robert Johnson 29 years after wrongful conviction for Chicago murder

Robert Johnson acquitted after 29 years of wrongful imprisonment for Chicago murder

CHICAGO (WLS) — It has been one month since a Chicago man…
Gisele Bundchen, 44, is a bra-free beauty as she is seen in first campaign since welcoming third child

Gisele Bundchen, 44, looks stunning without a bra in her latest campaign after giving birth to her third child

Gisele Bundchen’s first ad campaign since welcoming her third child debuted on…
What’s next in the Russia, Ukraine ceasefire talks?

Germany reports that negotiations with the US on Russia-Ukraine conflict are at a standstill, while China holds a contrasting view

There is growing tension surrounding the U.S.’s attempts to mediate a resolution…
ALISON BOSHOFF: 'Grief-stricken' Prince Harry feels 'like he's had one of his fingers cut off' amid charity chaos, as his friends reveal 'he's in total shock'

Prince Harry, feeling devastated, compares his loss to having a finger severed in the midst of charity turmoil, as friends share his state of utter disbelief

Prince Harry has not issued any public statements regarding the recent controversy…
Rat birth control coming to Chicago's Wicker Park, Bucktown neighborhoods after being named rattiest city in America by Orkin

New rat birth control program to launch in Chicago’s Wicker Park and Bucktown neighborhoods following Orkin’s rattiest city designation

CHICAGO (WLS) — For the tenth consecutive year, Orkin dubbed Chicago the…