Biden Commuted Their Death Sentences, but They're Refusing It—Why?

If you were drowning and someone tossed you a lifeline, you would grab it, wouldn’t you? 

While circumstances can influence outcomes, there are instances where individuals may choose to go against the expected norm. This is exemplified by the recent development involving two federal death row inmates whose death sentences were commuted to life imprisonment by President Biden, yet they have opted to reject this reprieve.

Shannon Agofsky, aged 53, and Len Davis, aged 60, currently housed at the U.S. Penitentiary in Terre Haute, Indiana, have decided not to sign the necessary documentation to acknowledge the President’s clemency offer. Court records indicate that their decision stems from the legal rights they maintain while on death row.

On December 30, the duo lodged urgent pleas in federal court seeking an injunction to prevent the modification of their death penalties. Their argument revolves around the premise that agreeing to the commutation would diminish the meticulous review process typically associated with death penalty appeals.

Heightened scrutiny is a legal process in which the courts examine cases like death penalty appeals closer for errors because these cases are a matter of life or death.

In other words, both inmates are still fighting their convictions in the appellate courts, and the removing of the increased scrutiny with which those courts would examine their appeals.

“To commute his sentence now, while the defendant has active litigation in court, is to strip him of the protection of heightened scrutiny,” Agofsky’s filing reads. “This constitutes an undue burden, and leaves the defendant in a position of fundamental unfairness, which would decimate his pending appellate procedures.”

Davis, a former New Orleans police officer, “has always maintained that having a death sentence would draw attention to the overwhelming misconduct” against the Justice Department, he wrote in his filing.

Shannon Agofsky was convicted of the 1989 murder of an Oklahoma bank president, Dan Short. Agofsky and his brother, Joseph Agofsky, kidnapped and murdered Short, then stole $71,000 from the bank Short ran. Shannon Agofsky’s brother was convicted of robbery and died in prison in 2013. Shannon remains on Death Row.

Len Davis was convicted of the murder of Kim Groves in 1994. Davis was a police officer, and Groves filed a complaint against him for the beating of a teenager.

Both men have applied to a judge to appoint a co-counsel to fight the commutations.

Three inmates were not included in the Biden commutation, as my colleague streiff noted in December:

The three men left on death row are Robert Bowers ( in 2018), Dylann Roof (Charleston, South Carolina, church shooting in 2015), and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev (2013 Boston Marathon bombing).

Four inmates in the military prison system awaiting the death penalty were likewise not included in the clemency.



Joe Biden claims to be personally opposed to the death penalty, but if his objection and these commutations were truly a matter of principle, they would have been done at the outset, not at the end of his presidency, and he would not have exempted anyone.

Donald Trump has vowed to restore the federal death penalty. The Constitution, in fact, specifically allows for the death penalty; the Fifth Amendment states (bolded part added):

No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offence to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.

The bolded portion implies that, with due process of law, a person may be “deprived of life, liberty or property.”

You May Also Like
Covenant School trans shooter plotted Nashville attack for years, kept notebooks with plans: final report

“Final Report: Shooter at Covenant School Had Been Planning Nashville Attack for Years and Kept Detailed Notebooks with Plans”

A homemade shirt made by Audrey Hale and found in her bedroom.…
California man to plead guilty to attempted assassination of Justice Kavanaugh

California Man Admits to Trying to Assassinate Justice Kavanaugh

The man accused of planning to murder Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh…
Shocker: Covenant School Shooter Final Report Released - Attack Was Plotted for Years

Surprising Revelation: Final Report on Covenant School Shooter Unveiled – Attack Was Planned Over Several Years

The Nashville police have published their conclusive findings regarding the investigation of…
Speaker Johnson suffers a defeat in his push to block parents in the U.S. House from proxy voting

Speaker Johnson faces a setback in his attempt to prevent parents in the U.S. House from voting by proxy.

WASHINGTON — House Speaker Mike Johnson suffered a significant defeat on Tuesday…
Suspected California Walgreens killer had 'grudge' against pharmacies, police say

Police indicate that the individual suspected of the Walgreens shooting in California harbored resentment towards pharmacies.

The suspected gunman who opened fire inside a California Walgreens on Tuesday…
Number of Tesla attacks soars past 50 as violence targeting Musk's company escalates

Tesla has been the victim of more than 50 attacks as violence against Musk’s company intensifies

The number of reported assaults on Tesla cars, dealerships, and charging stations…
Karen Schepers case: Family thanks community for help in solving 1983 Elgin cold case: 'Miracles do happen'

The Schepers Family Expresses Gratitude to Community for Solving 1983 Elgin Cold Case

ELGIN, Ill. (WLS) — The family of Karen Schepers is speaking out…
'Oklahoma City Bombing: One Day in America': New National Geographic docuseries gives unprecedented look at tragedy

New National Geographic series explores the Oklahoma City bombing in detail

PHILADELPHIA (WPVI) — Thirty years ago, the deadliest act of domestic terrorism…
Why three major countries were conspicuously left OFF Trump's massive tariffs list

The reason why three important countries were noticeably excluded from Trump’s extensive list of tariffs

President Donald Trump announced Wednesday his decision to impose extensive economic tariffs…
NANCY GRACE was so disturbed by bride-to-be's 'suicide' that she launched an investigation. Her findings were more chilling than she ever imagined

Nancy Grace investigates bride-to-be’s ‘suicide’ and uncovers shocking truths

I remember the first photo I saw of Ellen Greenberg with her…
Israeli military operation in Gaza expanding to seize 'large areas': 'Expanding to crush and clean the area'

– Israeli Military Operation in Gaza: Expansion to Secure Large Areas

Israel’s Defense Minister Israel Katz announced an expansion of the military offensive…
Measles outbreak: Medical experts warn against giving children Vitamin A as substitute for MMR vaccine

Medical professionals caution against using Vitamin A instead of the MMR vaccine for children during measles outbreak

HOUSTON, Texas — Medical experts are discussing a new concern related to…