GAME ON: Trump Takes a Hammer to Birthright Citizenship, Says 'People Have Wanted This For Decades'

Within days of assuming office, President Donald Trump signed an executive order that has sparked widespread misinterpretation, particularly being labeled as “ending birthright citizenship”. This simplification overlooks the complexity surrounding the understanding of citizenship within the 14th Amendment.

Section 1 of the amendment holds significant importance, as it states, “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.”

Trump’s executive order aims to narrow the legal interpretation of this statement. The order instructs the government to withhold legal recognition of citizenship in cases where the individual’s mother was unlawfully present in the U.S. and the father was not a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident at the time of the individual’s birth, or when the mother’s presence was lawful but temporary, and the father was not a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident at the time of the individual’s birth.

In other words, if the parents are not in the United States legally, then the child is not automatically granted citizenship. 

Trump in Court

The executive order was immediately challenged in court in several states, with groups like the ACLU latching themselves onto the cause, and the Trump administration has already lost in at least one federal court. The judge in that case strongly rebuked Trump’s actions.

“I’ve been on the bench for over four decades,” Senior U.S. District Judge John C. Coughenour said. “I can’t remember another case where the question presented is as clear as this one. This is a blatantly unconstitutional order.”

Coughenour (probably) has a point. The president cannot unilaterally reinterpret an amendment, especially on a question that the Supreme Court had previously settled. But the Trump administration isn’t seeking to just unilaterally change things. It appears his team wants to take this all the way back to the Supreme Court. 

But why?

What Is “Legal”?

The Supreme Court answered the question of birthright citizenship in the late 1800s, in United States v. Wong Kim Ark. Wong Kim Ark was born to parents who were legal residents, though not U.S. citizens, living in San Fransisco at the time. The family left America, though Wong came back and was denied entry into the country.

He sued, claiming he was a citizen, and the case went before the Court. Here is what they found:

  • Fourteenth Amendment Interpretation: The amendment’s language—”born in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof”—was meant to ensure that all persons born on U.S. soil (except specific exclusions) were granted citizenship.
  • Historical Intent: The Court emphasized that the amendment aimed to settle citizenship questions definitively, particularly for children born to foreign parents residing legally in the U.S.
  • Legal Precedents: The Court cited various precedents and interpretations of “jurisdiction,” concluding that Wong Kim Ark was fully subject to U.S. jurisdiction and thus a citizen.

The question comes down to one particular phrase in the amendment: “subject to the jurisdiction thereof.” The Court interpreted it, like most do, to mean that everyone born in the U.S. was automatically “subject to the jurisdiction thereof,” making them legal citizens. Some legal scholars, who agree with the Trump administration, argue that it means only those who are “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” (meaning those whose families are legally in the United States) are recognized as citizens.

The Path Forward

The Trump administration could push this ahead, fighting to keep the issue alive all the way to the Supreme Court, forcing the current Court to re-evaluate what the previous Court ruled. 

There are really two ways that the change to our interpretation of birthright citizenship can happen. The first is through an act of Congress, which will probably never happen. The second is to get the Supreme Court to amend or overturn its previous ruling, which is difficult but not impossible. 

There are two objectives here:

  1. Get the Supreme Court to reverse the previous position that “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” applies to everyone born in the United States.
  2. Recognize that, under this interpretation, Wong Kim Ark’s parents were “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” because they were legal residents in the United States.

If the Trump administration can convince the Justices to narrowly re-define the legal interpretation of the 14th Amendment, then his executive order will, in fact, have worked – even if the process by which he got there skirted the lines of constitutionality in the first place.

Can He Do It?

Trump’s problem is that he has essentially, two years to get things done. The midterm elections could result in Democrats retaking the House or Senate, and if that is the case, then he loses the opportunity to get much more of his agenda accomplished. Getting Congress to devote time to birthright citizenship takes away from his ability to get other things done, so he has to take the long way around – through the courts, that is.

He certainly could pull it off. He has just the right Supreme Court makeup to have a chance. The originalists on the Court will undoubtedly take a look at the fact that the original intent of the 14th Amendment was to apply to people legally in the U.S. (a fact that is in the congressional record, if you go and read up on what the authors of the amendment were discussing at the time). But it’s still a tall order.

Should He Do It?

In all honesty, I’m not convinced it’s the battle we should have right now. There are more immediate and critical needs in the fight to fix the immigration issue than to tackle birthright citizenship. However, it is something he promised, and he wants to deliver on it. 

It’s one of those long-game plans. This will have very little impact in the near future, but could work long-term to dissuade birth tourism in the U.S. For immigration hawks, it’s a vital piece of the strategy to reshape how America controls its borders and protects its citizenry.

You May Also Like
Reporter's Notebook: Aftershock from a political 'earthquake' as Le Pen barred from presidential run in 2027

Impact of Political Upheaval: Le Pen Excluded from 2027 Presidential Election

Recent events in France have caused aftershocks, described by a political analyst…
Volcano begins erupting in southwestern Iceland; nearby town, Blue Lagoon spa evacuated

Volcano erupts in southwest Iceland; Blue Lagoon spa town evacuated

A volcano began erupting in southwestern Iceland on Tuesday, just hours after…
Charges dropped against Robert Johnson 29 years after wrongful conviction for Chicago murder

Robert Johnson acquitted after 29 years of wrongful imprisonment for Chicago murder

CHICAGO (WLS) — It has been one month since a Chicago man…
Megyn Kelly issues scathing takedown of liberal journalist over reaction to her sister's death

Megyn Kelly Criticizes Liberal Journalist for Insensitive Response to Her Sister’s Death

Megyn Kelly has blasted a liberal tech reporter, calling her a ‘bad person’…
Dave Coulier confirms he is cancer free, 'Full House' co-stars celebrate

Dave Coulier announces he has beaten cancer, cast members of ‘Full House’ rejoice

Dave Coulier is officially cancer free. The actor and comedian revealed his…
Karen Read and John O'Keefe: Inside evolution of Boston murder mystery since July mistrial

Karen Read and John O’Keefe: Exploring the development of Boston murder case following July trial pause

Karen Read, who is accused of killing her boyfriend, a Boston cop,…
Glamorous married teacher turns gray as she's arrested for raping boy, 15, while confused husband watches

Elegant married educator arrested for assaulting 15-year-old boy, leaving her husband shocked.

Shocking footage from a police body camera shows the moment a married…
Rat birth control coming to Chicago's Wicker Park, Bucktown neighborhoods after being named rattiest city in America by Orkin

New rat birth control program to launch in Chicago’s Wicker Park and Bucktown neighborhoods following Orkin’s rattiest city designation

CHICAGO (WLS) — For the tenth consecutive year, Orkin dubbed Chicago the…
Morgan Wallen Rejected ‘SNL’ Sketch Before Controversial Walk Off, Forcing The Show To Cast Boy Band Star Instead: Report

Morgan Wallen Declined ‘SNL’ Sketch Leading to Replacement by Boy Band Star: Report

Morgan Wallen’s recent performance on ‘Saturday Night Live’ has been overshadowed by…
Missing Los Angeles firefighter's body found by divers off California coast

Rescuers recover body of missing firefighter off California shoreline

The body of a Los Angeles firefighter who went missing while off…
David Beckham poses with Tom Brady, Lionel Messi and Inter Miami WAGs at his star-studded 50th birthday party

“Star-studded 50th Birthday Party: David Beckham with Tom Brady, Lionel Messi, and Inter Miami WAGs”

David Beckham celebrated his upcoming 50th birthday with star-studded guests like Lionel…
Reese Witherspoon’s Lookalike Daughter Ava Phillippe Boards ‘Doctor Odyssey’ For Her Acting Debut: See The Photos

Ava Phillippe, daughter of Reese Witherspoon, takes on her first acting role in “Doctor Odyssey” – Check out the pictures

Move over, mom and dad, there’s a new star on the scene……