NYC murder: Woman charged after superintendent found dead, body wrapped in garbage bags inside Queens apartment

NEW YORK CITY — A woman has been charged in the death of a New York City superintendent reportedly killed while attempting to collect late rent.

Sandra Coto Navarro, aged 48, faces charges of murder, tampering with evidence, and illegal possession of a weapon in connection to the incident. Following the charges, she was observed with handcuffs on her wrists and a smirk on her face.

Neighbors at Navarro’s Queens apartment building were stunned by the allegations she is now facing.

“She was always sweet honestly. She was very, very sweet. I’m just a little surprised by this whole thing,” one neighbor said.

Authorities believe the superintendent, identified as 55-year-old Jose Portillo, was struck over the head and stabbed in the neck and leg.

Portillo’s body was discovered in garbage bags and stuffed under a bed Wednesday.

Officials say Navarro and her husband owed about $24,000 in back rent and they had not paid in years.

According to the police, the superintendent’s employer dispatched him to the residence to collect overdue rent. Concerned after not hearing from the superintendent, the employer alerted the authorities for a welfare check.

Police investigations, including surveillance footage analysis, revealed that Navarro’s husband was at his workplace throughout the day. He returned home just 20 minutes before the police arrived and cooperated by disclosing the victim’s whereabouts. The husband, however, will not face any charges in this case.

The medical examiner said Portillo’s cause of death was homicidal violence.

People who live at the apartment building on 70th Avenue said he used to be the gardener and then became the super — he was a friendly man who would stop to talk to people.

Many in the neighborhood said they knew him and relied on him for years.

Copyright © 2025 WABC-TV. All Rights Reserved.

You May Also Like
Nicola Peltz and her 'desperate thirst for fame': Insiders say David and Victoria are 'done' with their daughter-in-law and reveal why another ultra-famous family were so quick to ditch the billionaire heiress: KATIE HIND

Insiders reveal why David and Victoria Beckham are fed up with Nicola Peltz and how another famous family distanced themselves from the billionaire heiress: Insights from KATIE HIND

When Nicola Peltz began dating her much younger boyfriend Anwar Hadid, she…
Lauren Sanchez and Jeff Bezos' wedding plans raise eyebrows as fresh details emerge about unusual venue

Unconventional Venue for Lauren Sanchez and Jeff Bezos’ Wedding Sparks Interest

Lauren Sanchez and Jeff Bezos are expected to walk down the aisle…
British cardinal reveals Pope Leo's reaction upon being elected and suggests he 'won't be afraid of tyrants' after notoriously secretive papal conclave

British cardinal shares Pope Leo’s response to his election and predicts he will confront tyrants fearlessly following a highly secretive papal conclave

A British cardinal involved in the secretive papal conclave has revealed how…
Florida man, 89, and his dog mauled to death by black bear in state's first fatal attack

An 89-year-old man and his dog killed by a black bear in Florida’s first deadly bear attack

Confirming reports, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) announced on…
Jeffrey Rupnow, father of 15-year-old Natalie Rupnow, who killed 2 at Madison, Wisconsin religious school, faces felony charges

Jeffrey Rupnow Appears in Court for Felony Charges Related to Daughter’s Involvement in Madison School Incident

MADISON, Wis. — The father of a 15-year-old girl who killed a…
Cindy Crawford’s Kids Reveal What It’s Like to Follow a Supermodel Mom

Insight into Life with Supermodel Mom Cindy Crawford from Her Children

While Kaia Gerber has recently been getting a lot of attention for…
Chicago City Council members aim to give financial watchdog boost amid clash over Chicago budget

“Chicago City Council Looks to Empower Financial Watchdog Amid Budget Dispute”

CHICAGO (WLS) — The clash over Chicago’s 2025 budget left many alderpersons…
Watch: Skynet Comes to Life? Out of Control Chinese Robot Appears to Attack Workers

Video: Does Skynet exist? Chinese robot goes berserk and seems to assault employees

The advancement of artificial intelligence and robots is causing worry among many…
Jordon Hudson, 24, almost quit Miss Maine pageant amid furor over her treatment of boyfriend Bill Belichick, 73

24-year-old Jordon Hudson considered leaving Miss Maine pageant due to controversy surrounding her relationship with 73-year-old boyfriend Bill Belichick

Jordon Hudson, a contestant aiming to be Miss Maine, faced criticism for…
Incarcerated California serial 'Scorecard Killer' Randy Kraft potentially linked to decades-old death in Oregon, police say

California Serial Killer Randy Kraft, known as the ‘Scorecard Killer,’ possibly connected to old Oregon murder, say law enforcement officers

A man was discovered deceased next to the 5 Freeway in Oregon,…
Former Trump advisors wage Balkan campaign as MAGA moves into Europe

Trump’s ex-advisors promote MAGA in Europe’s Balkan region

Former campaign advisors of President Donald Trump are currently working on a…
Pakistan, India suggest possible de-escalation amid both countries' missile strikes

Pakistan and India propose potential decrease in tension following missile attacks

Pakistan’s foreign minister mentioned on Saturday that his country would be open…