Woman Accused of Poisoning Christmas Dinner Causing the Deaths of Two Sisters and Niece – Authorities to Investigate Deceased Husband’s Body

The woman who baked a ‘poisoned’ Christmas cake that killed her two sisters and a niece has been pictured for the first time.

Zeli Terezinha Silva dos Anjos, 61, from Torres, Brazil, prepared a traditional Christmas cake for a festive family meal on December 23.

However, her sisters Maida, 58, and Neuza, 65, and Neuza’s daughter Tatiana, 43 all died shortly after eating the cake.

Three other family members, including Zeli herself and a 10-year-old boy, fell ill and were also hospitalised.

Now, it has emerged that traces of the toxic metal arsenic were present in the bodies of the three women killed.

Police have also announced plans to exhume the body of Zeli’s husband Paolo Luiz who reportedly died in September of food poisoning.

Zeli is believed to have spoken to the police who have yet to determine whether the victims were purposely poisoned.

The 10-year-old boy, who is believed to be Tatiana’s son, is thought to be in a stable condition.

Seven family members at Zeli’s home in Brazil were enjoying cake. However, one unnamed person did not partake in eating the cake.

The cake, a yearly tradition reportedly baked by Maida’s sister, Zeli Terezinha Silva dos Anjos, 61, is currently in the hospital according to a family friend.

It is believed Zeli, pictured, ate two cake slices and was the first one to be taken to hospital after becoming severely ill

The Christmas cake, pictured, eaten by the three women before they died

After blood tests, doctors discovered arsenic in the blood of some individuals, a toxic substance that causes symptoms like nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea.

What is in a Christmas Cake? 

A Christmas cake is a rich cake traditionally served without any decoration or just garnished with candied fruits.

It is often mistaken for the Portuguese King Cake, a yeast sweet cake. 

The Brazilian recipe uses cane sugar and has icing over the top with the candied fruits. 

What are the ingredients?

The ingredients for this cake are butter, eggs, brown sugar, orange juice or milk, range zest, Port wine, flour, baking powder, ground cinnamon, nutmeg, black raisins and exotic candied fruit cut into small cubes.

Source: saborbrasil.it 

Officer Marcos Vinicius Veloso, who is leading the case, said there are no records of inheritance disputes or rows between family members. 

It is believed Zeli ate two cake slices and was the first one to be taken to hospital after becoming severely ill – where she remains in stable condition.

She has reportedly told police she bought some the ingredients on Monday before the gathering.

Police have not yet determined whether the victims were poisoned.

According to the Hospital Nossa Senhora dos Navegante, Tatiana and Maida both died from cardiac arrest, while, Neuza died from ‘shock after food poisoning’. 

According to the police officer on the case, arsenic was found in Neuza’s body as well as two other victims who survived.

Neighbours in the area will be interviewed by officers.

A friend of one of the people who died told a local news channel it was a traditional cake that the family made every year.

Police have carried out an examination of the food eaten by the family and other items in the house, and many of them were expired.

A police statement to local network, Globo, said: ‘We even have information that there was mayonnaise there that had expired a year ago.

‘There were expired products in the residence. A bottle was found, a medicine, which should have had capsules inside it and there were no capsules – there was a white liquid and this white liquid will also be examined.’

This comes after last year a woman was accused of killing her in-laws after she allegedly poisoned her relatives with wild mushrooms in Australia.

Maida Berenice Flores da Silva, 58, pictured, died after having the traditional cake on December 23

Tatiana Denize Silva dos Anjos, 43, pictured, died following having the Christmas cake on December 23

Neuza Denize Silva dos Anjo, 65, pictured, was rushed to hospital in critical condition before also dying the following day

Maida Berenice Flores da Silva, 58, a teacher, also after she ate the Christmas cake on December 23 during the family get-together

The horror poisoning happened in the city of Torres in the state of Rio Grande do Sul in the south coast of Brazil

In July 2023, five family members gathered for a quiet meal in a small town deep in rural Australia.

A day later, all four guests fell ill. Within a week, three would be dead, the fourth fighting for his life and the 48-year-old woman who cooked the lunch questioned by police amid claims she deliberately poisoned her relatives with wild mushrooms.

Yet Erin Patterson, who did not suffer any ill effects from the meal, insists she loves her family and had no idea the mushrooms she served were death caps – the most poisonous mushrooms in the world.

Speaking outside her home where the fatal lunch happened, she said: ‘I didn’t do anything. I loved them and I’m devastated that they’re gone.’ 

Police have seized a food dehydrator from the house that’s believed to have been used to prepare the mushrooms.

The deeply unusual case has gripped the country, baffled police and left a closely-knit community desperately seeking answers.

Patterson, 48, is said to have invited her former partner Simon Patterson to her home for the meal on July 29 with his parents Gail and Tom Patterson, 70, along with Gail’s sister Heather Wilkinson and her husband Ian, 68.

Simon was meant to come but could not make it ‘at the last minute’. Police said the couple had split ‘amicably’ – suggesting the lunch would not have been unusual. 

Simon, who lived with his parents for a year after the split before moving out, previously spent 21 days in intensive care after suffering ‘serious gut problems’ in May 2022. Exactly when he split from his wife is unclear. 

The Pattersons’ two children were also present at the lunch but ate different meals to the adults and did not experience any illness. They’ve reportedly been taken into care. 

All four guests became ill after eating the meal. It’s not clear what dish was served but it included hand-picked mushrooms. 

Police said the victims’ symptoms were consistent with those caused by death cap mushrooms – the world’s most dangerous fungi which grows in the wild in Victoria. 

Erin Patterson hosted a meal that led to all four of her guests falling ill and three dying  

Gail and Don Patterson died after eating the mushrooms. Ms Patterson was previously married to their son, Simon

Ian Wilkinson and Heather Wilkinson (both pictured) became severely ill after they ate wild mushrooms. Mrs Wilkinson died on Friday while her husband remains in a critical condition in hospital

The property where the deadly lunch occurred at Leongatha, in Victoria’s Gippsland region 

Mushrooms seen on the family home at Leongatha in Victoria’s Gippsland region

The four went to hospital the next day as their condition worsened, with the two sisters, aged 70 and 66, dying on Friday. Don, 70, died on Saturday night.

Ian, 68, remains in a critical condition in hospital and is believed to be waiting for a liver transplant.

Detectives say they are unsure if Ms Patterson ate the same food as her guests. 

They noted she was separated from her husband – the Pattersons’ son – but said it had been an ‘amicable’ split. 

‘At this point in time, the deaths are unexplained,’ said homicide squad investigator Dean Thomas. ‘It could be very innocent, but we just don’t know.’