Police hunt 'Haggler After Midnight' mugger targeting certain victims in bizarre crime spree

The New York Police Department is actively searching for a knife-wielding robber who rides a moped and has earned the nickname “Haggler After Midnight” due to his unique method of thievery. The suspect, whose robberies are becoming increasingly bold and violent, has struck at least 11 times.

Starting in early November, the perpetrator has chosen victims in Brooklyn and Queens, focusing on Hispanic males aged 20 to 40 who are returning home from work during the early morning hours, according to law enforcement.

Deputy Chief John Mastronardi at the department’s Crimes against Persons Unit told WNBC that the mugger negotiates in both English and Spanish. 

“He’s got a strange M.O. – he likes to haggle with his victims, so we call him the ‘Haggler After Midnight,’” he said. “Oftentimes if a victim produces a property that they’re going to give up, he says ‘No, no, no, I don’t want that, want that.’ So he gets to choose.”

His most recent attack on Dec. 10 was his boldest yet, Mastronardi said. 

“In the last [incident], the male approached one of our victims and put a knife to his throat,” the detective said. 

Thus far, none of the suspect’s victims have been injured.

Crime Stoppers is offering a cash reward for any information that leads to the man’s capture.  

You May Also Like
Working mom Karoline Leavitt sets heart-warming task for her White House staff... and spills on the Trump family sisterhood in her most intimate interview yet

A working mother, Karoline Leavitt, assigns a touching assignment for her White House team, and reveals insights into the sisterly bond within the Trump family in her most personal interview to date.

A first-time mom and President Trump’s redoubtable White House press secretary, 27-year-old Karoline Leavitt…
Grieving moms dig with ‘bare hands’ to unearth the dark truth behind their missing and murdered children

Moms search tirelessly to uncover the truth about their missing and murdered children

Cheryl Holsonbake drove for two hours in the scorching summer heat to…
Below Deck star reveals hidden battle with cancer... and the sign he ignored because he was 'naive'

Below Deck celebrity discloses secret struggle with cancer… and the symptom he overlooked due to his lack of awareness.

For thirty years, Captain Jason Chambers has been navigating luxurious yachts around…
Disturbing reason Beyonce is putting 13-year-old Blue Ivy center stage on her tour: CAROLINE BULLOCK dares to say what everyone's thinking

Exploring the Controversy: Why Beyonce is Featuring 13-Year-Old Blue Ivy Prominently in her Tour – Insights by CAROLINE BULLOCK

She’s been Sasha Fierce and Mrs Carter but it’s her latest guise…
Putin proposes direct peace talks with Ukraine to end war

“Putin suggests holding direct peace negotiations with Ukraine as a solution to end conflict”

Russian President Vladimir Putin suggested direct discussions with Ukrainian officials on Sunday…
Lauren Sanchez and Jeff Bezos' wedding plans raise eyebrows as fresh details emerge about unusual venue

Unconventional Venue for Lauren Sanchez and Jeff Bezos’ Wedding Sparks Interest

Lauren Sanchez and Jeff Bezos are expected to walk down the aisle…
California 'Teacher of the Year' sentenced to 30 years for sexual abuse of students

California educator honored as ‘Teacher of the Year’ receives a 30-year prison sentence for sexually abusing students

A former California “Teacher of the Year” was sentenced on Friday to…
‘Saturday Night Live’ Opens With Trump Signing Ridiculous Executive Orders: “Old Men Can Now Date Far Younger Women”

Will ‘SNL’ Air a New Episode Tonight? Check Out the 2025 ‘Saturday Night Live’ Schedule and How to Watch on NBC/Peacock

Saturday Night Live came back from its break last week (May 3)…
When Is ‘The Last of Us’ Season 2 Episode 5 Release Date? When Do New TLOU Episodes Come Out on HBO?

“When Will The Next Episode of ‘The Last of Us’ Season 2 Be Released on HBO?”

The Last of Us Season 2 continues to follow Ellie (played by…
Our Chicago: Donald Trump administration's US Department of Justice terminates grants to violence prevention organizations

Trump’s Justice Department in Chicago stops funding for groups working to prevent violence

CHICAGO (WLS) — The U.S. Department of Justice has recently stopped providing…
Putin savages Ukraine with drone attack hours after announcing Istanbul 'peace talks' that Trump called a 'potentially great day'

Putin launches drone attack on Ukraine shortly after announcing ‘peace talks’ in Istanbul that Trump praised as a ‘promising development’

Shortly after announcing peace negotiations that were praised by US President Donald…
Two injured after military vehicle crashes over highway retaining wall, plunges 30 feet onto road below

Military vehicle accident leaves two people injured as it falls 30 feet from highway wall onto road

A military Humvee pulling a trailer veered off Interstate 90 in Bellevue,…