Americans were told a 'multi-racial boom' would radically change the nation. Experts say it was a 'lefty' plot

Five years ago, there was a noticeable change in America’s racial and ethnic composition, with a significant decrease in the number of individuals identified as ‘white’.

The 2020 census data from the US Census Bureau revealed a remarkable 276 percent increase in the multiracial population, while the percentage of white individuals decreased from 72.4 percent to 61.6 percent over the span of a decade.

However, it now appears that this shift was primarily influenced by the classification methods employed by government demographers, rather than reflecting any substantial alterations in the demographic makeup of the total population of 331,449,281 individuals recorded in the census.

A pair of Princeton sociologists who studied the ‘multiracial boom’ have found it was ‘mostly an illusion’ that did not reflect any shifts in racial or ethnic identity across the population.

Experts told DailyMail.com that, while there are many ways to measure race and ethnicity, the changes in the 2020 count were likely influenced by a ‘lefty’ effort to undercount white people.

The US Census Bureau for the first time in 2020 provided space on the census form for people to write in their families’ origins, which guided how the agency categorized them.

Defining who is black, white, multiracial, or any other category, is not straightforward

Defining who is black, white, multiracial, or any other category, is not straightforward  

The Census Bureau in 2020 tried out new ways to measure race and ethnicity

The Census Bureau in 2020 tried out new ways to measure race and ethnicity  

People who were classified as being two or more races jumped from 2.9 percent to 10.2 percent of the population from 2010 to 2020. 

The increase was most noticeable among Hispanics.

The share of the white alone population dropped from 72.4 percent to 61.6 percent, stoking fears about unchecked immigration and the decline of America’s white majority.

But Paul Starr, a top Princeton sociology professor, says the new methods led to incorrect results.

Anyone who marked themselves as black or as white on the 2020 form, but then wrote that they were of Latin American origin was reclassified by a computer algorithm as ‘multiracial,’ he says.

The same went for people who self-identified as white only, but then wrote that their origins were from an African country.

‘When people identify themselves as single-race, the Census Bureau should not correct them by using the additional information they provide about their origins,’ Starr told DailyMail.com.

‘Origins and identity are two different things.’

He added: ‘Clearly, there are white people with origins in Latin America or South Africa, and when they list those origins on a Census form, they are not saying they are mixed race.’

Starr, together with colleague Christina Pao, published his 17-page analysis in Sociological Science in December.

Starr said: ‘The procedure was misleading, and the public was misled about the extent of racial change.’

In 2020, an ostensibly white American with one grandfather from Chile could have been counted as 'multiracial'

In 2020, an ostensibly white American with one grandfather from Chile could have been counted as ‘multiracial’ 

Officials said their new methods did a better job of capturing how people identify their race and ethnicity

Officials said their new methods did a better job of capturing how people identify their race and ethnicity 

When the figures were released in mid-2021, bureau officials said the new method did a better job of capturing how people identify their race and ethnicity in the 21st century.

But they acknowledged that some of the dramatic growth likely came from their changes.

For the first time, empty spaces were left on the 2020 census form so that respondents could write in their ‘origins,’ such as ‘German’ or ‘Jamaican,’ when answering the race question.

The detailed answers guided the bureau in classifying the respondents and members of their households into race and ethnicity categories.

‘These improvements reveal that the US population is much more multiracial and diverse than what we measured in the past,’ bureau officials said at the time.

The official numbers on multiracial people are important because they impact political district boundaries, civil rights enforcement, labor data, health statistics and federal funding.

The Princeton researchers said the bureau mistakenly mixed up ancestry with identity and national origin with race.

They urged the bureau to abandon using ‘origins’ to categorize people in future counts.

The issue flew under the radar because of other distractions surrounding the 2020 census, including the introduction of a citizenship question, data-privacy concerns, and the difficulty of gathering data in a pandemic.

David Bernstein, a professor at George Mason University and author of Classified: The Untold Story of Racial Classification in America, says the changes likely reflected a push by left wing ideologues at the bureau.

The 2020 census was ‘pushed in a less sensible way,’ Bernstein told DailyMail.com.

Researchers have been asking the bureau since 2021 to rerun the 2020 data using 2010 methods so that an ‘apples to apples’ comparison of demographic changes can be made, says historian Margo Anderson.

The 2020 count showed the white share of population dropping from 72.4 percent to 61.6 percent

The 2020 count showed the white share of population dropping from 72.4 percent to 61.6 percent

Paul Starr, a top Princeton sociology professor, says the 2020 count was 'misleading'

Paul Starr, a top Princeton sociology professor, says the 2020 count was ‘misleading’

The bureau hasn’t done so yet.

‘It’s 2025 and people have been asking since 2021, ‘What the hell did you do?’ said Anderson, who served on a National Academies panel that reviewed the quality of the census.

‘There is a lot of frustration there because we can’t know.’

The bureau has historically struggled to classify multiracial people, says Susan Graham, an advocate for multiracial representation in official statistics.

Respondents weren’t allowed to check more than one race until the 2000 census.

‘Was the 2020 Census subjected to a fictitious multiracial boom? Possibly,’ Graham said.

‘As always, answers only get more confusing when the federal government goes back and tries, one more time, to get it right.’

Race and ethnic categories used by the federal government are changing further to combine questions about race and ethnicity instead of asking about them separately.

A Middle Eastern and North African category also is being added which will reduce the number of respondents identifying as white.

Not all demographers think the bureau’s methodological change was significant.

‘I don’t think it’s that big of a deal for most people using the data,’ said William Frey, a demographer at The Brookings Institution.

‘I think that the Census Bureau is trying hard to get this right.’

You May Also Like
Incarcerated California serial 'Scorecard Killer' Randy Kraft potentially linked to decades-old death in Oregon, police say

California Serial Killer Randy Kraft, known as the ‘Scorecard Killer,’ possibly connected to old Oregon murder, say law enforcement officers

A man was discovered deceased next to the 5 Freeway in Oregon,…
Canada's Carney Thinks He Has a Secret Weapon to Stop the '51st State' Talk, but It Shows Trump Was Right

Bank of England’s Carney Believes He Has a Strategy to Prevent Talk of Canada Becoming the ’51st State’, but It Proves Trump’s Claims.

It seems one country’s newly elected prime minister is taking a new…
The issue that could tear Trump's base apart... and why the president hasn't made up his mind

An unresolved problem that might divide Trump supporters and the reason behind the president’s indecision

The debate among Republicans is centered around the extent to which they…
British cardinal reveals Pope Leo's reaction upon being elected and suggests he 'won't be afraid of tyrants' after notoriously secretive papal conclave

British cardinal shares Pope Leo’s response to his election and predicts he will confront tyrants fearlessly following a highly secretive papal conclave

A British cardinal involved in the secretive papal conclave has revealed how…
The State of Michigan's Growing Budget Must Be the Priority of Whoever Replaces Gretchen Whitmer in 2026

Focusing on Michigan’s Increasing Budget Should Be the Top Concern for the Future Leader after Gretchen Whitmer in 2026

Truly never too soon, Is It? Before delving into the main topic…
Meghan Markle dances the night away at Beyonce's Cowboy Carter tour in Los Angeles - as Prince Harry awkwardly shuffles in a cowboy hat

“Meghan Markle enjoys Beyonce’s Cowboy Carter tour in LA while Prince Harry dons a cowboy hat”

Meghan Markle and Prince Harry were seen at the fifth night of…
Tom Cruise makes rare comment about ex Nicole Kidman as girlfriend Ana de Armas seen solo after couple's trip

Tom Cruise gives rare statement about former wife Nicole Kidman while Ana de Armas spotted alone following vacation with the couple.

Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman have been divorced for more than two…
Cape Coral, Florida man gored by bison at Lake Village, near Yellowstone Lake, in year's first attack at Yellowstone National Park

Man from Cape Coral, Florida injured by bison in Lake Village near Yellowstone Lake, marking the first attack at Yellowstone National Park this year.

YELLOWSTONE NATIONAL PARK, Wyo. — A Yellowstone National park visitor from Florida…
I felt fit, healthy and was running 10km a day before I started experiencing a strange feeling in my legs. I had stage four lung cancer and I'd never smoked

Experiencing a Puzzling Leg Sensation Despite Health and Fitness Levels; Developing Stage Four Lung Cancer as a Non-Smoker

It’s commonly assumed that people diagnosed with lung cancer must have been…
Cindy Crawford’s Kids Reveal What It’s Like to Follow a Supermodel Mom

Insight into Life with Supermodel Mom Cindy Crawford from Her Children

While Kaia Gerber has recently been getting a lot of attention for…
Taylor Swift Subpoenaed as Witness in Blake Lively, Justin Baldoni Suit

Taylor Swift asked to testify as a witness in legal case involving Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni

Taylor Swift has been subpoenaed in the escalating legal dispute between It…
Disturbing reason Beyonce is putting 13-year-old Blue Ivy center stage on her tour: CAROLINE BULLOCK dares to say what everyone's thinking

Exploring the Controversy: Why Beyonce is Featuring 13-Year-Old Blue Ivy Prominently in her Tour – Insights by CAROLINE BULLOCK

She’s been Sasha Fierce and Mrs Carter but it’s her latest guise…