Man Gives Car Keys to Unknown Woman in Urgent Need, Next Day Her Husband Knocks on His Door – Story of the Day

A family man blindly gave the keys to his expensive car to an unfamiliar woman who begged him for help. The next day, her husband knocked on his door and revealed something that sent chills down his spine.

It is not often you meet people who would blindly trust their expensive car with a total stranger. With car thefts on the surge, it is always wise to ensure you never leave your car around strangers.

However, there are a few exceptions, like Scott Davis, 33, who didn’t think twice when an unknown woman approached him for his car keys, citing an “emergency.”

The Charleston-based family man didn’t see what was coming ahead of his heedless decision. Instead of questioning the woman further, he gave her the keys to his expensive Toyota Camry. But it turned out to be an unforgettable nightmare when her husband knocked on his door the next day with some startling news…

Scott and his wife Rebecca were shopping with their kids in the local supermarket on a busy Saturday evening. Since it was their day off, they decided to stock their pantry with groceries for the entire week.

“And how do you know my wife? Wait a minute…what’s going on?” Scott gasped in shock.

“Hey, honey, careful with the bags,” Scott said as he followed his wife to their car. They carried big shopper bags while their kids, Dave and Maria, hopped behind with their lollipops.

“I think we will run out of fuel,” Scott said. “We will fill it up on the way, okay? And if you want to visit the parlor meanwhile, I can wait.” Just as he was about to unlock his car, an unknown young woman in a red hoodie came running to him, crying for help.

“Please help me,” the woman sobbed. “Please give me your car keys. There is an emergency.”

Scott and Rebecca were puzzled. They looked at each other in disbelief and wondered what the woman was talking about.

“Wa-wait…Do I know you?” Scott asked the lady. “I-I’m sorry, but I don’t think I can give you my car.”

“No, please,” the woman begged. “My name is Amanda, and I need a car urgently to drive my son to the hospital.”

Scott was shocked. “To the hospital?” he shouted in anxiety. “What happened to your son?” he added.

“He is right there,” Amanda said, pointing to a faint corner in the parking lot. Scott and Rebecca followed her and what they saw there sent shivers down their spine.

“Oh my God…Here, take my car keys. And get me your phone number. I’ll message you my address,” Scott said, handing the keys to his expensive car to the unfamiliar woman. He grew restless after seeing Amanda’s little son lying in a pool of blood. It seemed he had tripped down and hurt his head.

Meanwhile, Rebecca was suspicious. “Honey, I don’t think it is a good idea to just trust a stranger,” she said. “The last time you did the same thing, it took us a week to find our old car that was stolen by the person who begged you for a lift. This is new, and I don’t want you to take a risk again.”

“Chill, honey,” Scott said. “I’m just trying to help. She doesn’t look like a robber to me. She just gave me her number.” Then he handed over the keys to the woman, assuming he had done the right thing by trusting his instincts.

“Thanks, I’ll never forget your help,” Amanda said as she put her injured son Tom and two daughters in the backseat. “Thank you so much,” she said smiling, driving past the supermarket gate.

“What do we do now?” Rebecca doubtfully asked her husband. “I hope she returns our car. Or else, you’re going to learn a very important lesson the hard way.”

After hearing his wife out, Scott was worried. Something didn’t seem right to him, especially when he saw Amanda smiling while leaving when she was supposed to be anxious about her injured son.

He felt something was still fishy about how it happened too quickly and hoped his wife was not right. He returned to where Tom lay and leaned a bit to check. That’s when he realized that the crimson liquid was not blood at all. It was an odorless red liquid dye.

“Oh, Jeez…I should have listened to you…I think we’ve been robbed,” he shouted and called 911.

“Robbed?” Rebecca shouted. “Oh no, then our car? I told you, and it’s all your fault.”

The cops immediately arrived at the spot and began investigating. But the things that unfolded next gave Scott a sleepless night he could never forget.

“Yes, officer, that’s right,” Scott said. “She said her name was Amanda, and her child was injured. Here, this is the spot.”

The officers examined the crimson stains. “Well, it looks like a well-planned theft. Let’s check the CCTV footage,” said the officer.

But to their dismay, the camera in that part of the parking lot was under repair. Scott lost his only chance of tracking down Amanda’s identity. He took a cab home with his family after the officers assured him they would soon find his car.

A disappointed Scott tried tracking his car with the Locator feature but was unsuccessful. He couldn’t think of anything other than waiting to hear back from the cops.

“Damn! Her number is switched off,” he shouted. He was anxious the whole evening, often checking outside to see if the cops arrived with some update.

The restless evening folded into the worst nightmare for Scott as he couldn’t stop thinking about his stolen car. “I knew she looked suspicious,” Rebecca said. “I have told you not to trust strangers several times, and you never listen to me.”

“Honey, please, can you stop?” Scott grinned. “I’m already upset, and right now, I can only think of a way to get back our car. Please stop annoying me.”

Scott spent a restless night and had fallen asleep in disappointment when a vehicle honked outside his house the following day. It sounded all too familiar.

“Honey, wake up,” Rebecca shouted. “Scott, wake up. I think someone is outside.” Anxious, the couple walked over to their main door. Scott got the shock of his life after opening it.

“Oh my God! Our car!” he shouted in surprise. “And who are you?” he said, looking at a man who got down from the driver’s seat. Scott gasped in shock after seeing Amanda get down with her three kids.

“You???” Scott shouted at her. “How dare you steal my car? I trusted you. Wait until I report you to the cops.”

The man with Amanda chimed in, and the first thing he did was calm Scott down. “Mr. Davis. Please calm down. I’m Ralph Moore, and this is my wife, Amanda,” the man said. “Hey, Mrs. Davis! How are you?”

“Your wife???” Scott gasped in shock. “And how do you know my wife? Wait a minute…what’s going on?”

“Yes. Can we please go in and talk for a minute? I’ll explain everything.”

Hesitant and confused about what was happening, Scott invited the strangers into his house.

“Your wife staged your son’s injury and took my car away last evening,” Scott complained. “We already reported to the police, but I don’t understand what’s going on now.”

“Yes, Mr. Davis. I got the complaint,” Ralph said.

“You got the complaint? What do you mean?” Scott asked. And that’s when he witnessed another truth unfold that made him shriek in astonishment.

“I am from the department. Amanda and your wife are friends. We were actually filming a short film to spread awareness on why people should not trust strangers with their cars or anything for that matter,” Officer Ralph said. “You must be aware of the surging car thefts in our place. So, we had decided to film a staged theft that looks real with authentic people to spread the message!”

It turned out that officer Ralph and his team were at the parking lot, filming Scott’s reaction to the theft. Rebecca was aware of it and had teamed up with the cops to spread awareness. She also wanted to teach Scott an important lesson on why he shouldn’t trust strangers again.

“Our main message was not to trust strangers and the importance of calling 911 during an emergency. You just did what we had in mind!” the officer added. “Scammers can approach innocent people in disguise, and we wanted to spread awareness.”

“Good gracious, officer! I almost lost it thinking my car was stolen,” Scott exclaimed in relief.

“Well, Mr. Davis. I appreciate your genuine participation. We would’ve returned your car yesterday itself, but it had broken down. As a token of gratitude, we filled it with fuel and fixed it, so it took a whole night at the garage,” the officer joked.

The short film soon made rounds on the department’s social media page. Scott and his family were mentioned as “actors” in the disclaimer. Scott became quite famous for his genuine reactions when the stranger approached him for help.

From that day onward, Scott and the people who watched the short film were aware of the importance of not blindly trusting strangers. Ultimately, he and officer Ralph became good friends, and they often discussed new tactics to spread awareness to people!

What can we learn from this story?

• Help others but ensure they are trustworthy and genuine. When Amanda approached Scott to help save her injured son, he blindly gave her his car keys without verifying her claims.
• Do not trust anyone blindly without verifying their identity. The main purpose of Amanda approaching Scott for his car keys was to film his reactions secretly and spread the awareness of why people should not blindly trust strangers.

Tired of not living a life worth remembering, Will met a desperate woman in a wedding gown on his doorstep one day. After listening to her story, he decided to sell his house for an astonishing reason. Click here to read the full story.

This piece is inspired by stories from the everyday lives of our readers and written by a professional writer. Any resemblance to actual names or locations is purely coincidental. All images are for illustration purposes only. Share your story with us; maybe it will change someone’s life. If you would like to share your story, please send it to info@amomama.com.

Anomama